I am shopping for a 5hp cyclone dust collector for work. What are some of the opinions out there? Oneida and Clear Vue promote themselves as being superior, are they? And if so is one better than the other? We just purchased a Felder RL 160 which we love, but in the next location we want to clean up, we don't have enough free floor space. We do have a spot that a cyclone unit will fit, the big sacrifice will be the higher noise level of the cyclone unit.
I have a 5 hp Clear Vue and I love it. It's the only cyclone I've ever had or used, so I can't compare it to or rate it against others. The reason for my post, though is to encourage you to be a little creative with your installation. I have a very small shop (27' X 17'). I had to install my cyclone inside the shop - there was no place else to put it. It was a screamer - so loud it heart my ears. I built a small sound buffering enclosure around it and tamed the beast. The cyclone and the enclosure take up a little room, but not much more than the cyclone by itself; and the decibel reduction is more than worth the sacrifice of a little bit of space for the enclosure. My advice is to buy the cyclone you think is best and don't worry about the noise, deal with it after you install the cyclone.
I have a 2 HP Oneida that does the job in my one man shop. I will easily handle 2 machines (even planer and jointer) at the same time, so I am a happy camper.
The noise is not that bad. I can have a conversation or talk on the phone while it is running (in a residential garage shop).
I think the main things to look for is the motor and the filter. Oneida usually offers a good name brand motor (Leeson on mine), but many have cheap Chinese motors that are quite loud.
I never knew it was the motor that made a dust collector so loud. I alway thought it was the spinning impeller and air movement that made all the racket.
I have had an Oenida 5HP for over 10 years and can not complain at all. I don`t think between the two your looking at, you wouldn`t be wrong on either one, but I would check with clear vue what kind of motor they use. I would make sure that I would get an American made motor. Leeson is a great motor. Which ever one you order, make sure you ask what kind of motor is on it. Good luck with your shop. I whish I would live close to you, I would love to help put it in, I really enjoyed putting mine in. What are you going to use for pipeing. I used S&W pvc and it`s the best thing I did. Larry
Around 8 ~ 10 years ago when I built my shop the only 3hp cyclone I found at a reasonable price was the Grizzly. I really like to purchase US made items but Oneida was at least twice the money for the same air flow / power. (They have since become more competitive). I did have an issue with the capacitor on the motor, but Grizzly was very good with their customer service and the problem was quickly resolved. I have had no issues with the unit since. It does a great job, but is quite noisy. Don't know if any other units moving that much air would be any quieter though! I piped my unit in using 6" PVC sewer pipe with a custom made 8"/ 6" / 6" Y fitting, as I have almost all my equipment on mobile bases, I installed 6" drops with gates on the walls around the shop and hook up with 4" flex lines. I have had no issues even with my 20" stationary planer (except it sure fills up my 55 gal barrel fast).
My Clear Vue was supplied with a Leeson motor. I bought it before the company changed hands. I don't know what motor the new owners supply. I would assume it is still the Leeson, but can't say for sure.
I think Larry is referring to S&D PVC. S&D refers to Sewer and Drain. It's the green stuff, much less expensive than the white schedule 40 or 80 PVC, but perfectly adequate for a DC system. It's what I used and I have no complaints.
Hank is correct. It SD or S&D PVC, but it not always green, sometimes white. It is thin wall and about half the weight of the regular plumbing grade stuff. The lighter weight is a big advantage. The fittings are more limited that the plumbing stuff but about half the price or less. I used two forty fives instead of one 90 degree elbow to help not reduce the air flow.
Look on Bill Pent's site for lots of information. I thought about making some of my fittings, but never did do it. I am completely satisfied with my SD pipe. Really enjoyed the mental challenge of making the pipe work.
I don't have a cyclone, and can't help with that, but what I did was add a little closet on the exterior of my shop and put my DC and air compressor in that. I REALLY like the quieter operation. I do not return the air to my shop. I figure any dust the system picks up is gone and I don't have to think about the quality of the filters.
A number of the replies are promoting PVC which is a good option to consider. However, John seemed to indicate that he is shopping for his work place. A commercial establishment may required to use metal ducting due to code or insurance, etc.
I am not sure if newer (or specific locations) codes or a particular insurance policy would require metal instead of PVC, but I can state as an Engineer in an industrial factory (until my retirement about 9 years ago), I installed several large vacuum systems in our facility using PVC. The plant I worked at (in Indiana) was set up using several 5 HP Acro Wand vacuum pumps and a 100+ Hp rotary vacuum and several hundred foot of PVC piping. Never had any issue with codes or the Insurance inspector at that time. These systems were used both for derbies removal and as a vacuum source for part placement systems. (Vacuum held the parts in robotic placement mechanisms).
In Ontario, Canada , while dust collection is dictated by the building code, it is enforced by the local fire dept. not the building inspectors. I will check into ducting with them.
John, I installed a ClearVue 5hp (Leeson motor) a couple of years ago and I am quite happy with it. One thing I really like about the ClearVue is it is clear - when setting up and testing the system it was easy to verify that that things were working properly by simply watching the dust and chip movement. There is "some assembly required" but all parts were well made and went together quickly.
I used 6" S&D pipe and the thing really sucks. I highly recommend installing in a sound-insulated closet. I used 6" staggered-stud insulated walls with a baffled filtered air return and can easily carry on a normal conversation in the shop with the thing running. There is actually more noise coming from the air intakes at the machines than from the cyclone (and it's a real screamer without the closet!) I also put my big air compressor in the same closet since it's loud too.
Remove your compressor's intake filter and pipe it to the outside of the "closet" where you then remount the filter. You can do this with some low pressure hose and a couple of barb fittings. The closet will tend to concentrate the fines that get through your DC, and they will get sucked into the compressor.