Re: Finish for Winsor chairs
Mike Jurnigan
I have built a few Windsor’s over the years, taught a few classes, and have done countless demos around the country. Most old/ antique Windsor’s were painted, a few were made from a single wood, such as walnut, had a clear finish. Most Windsor’s were painted with an oil based paint that was white lead based. White lead base paint cannot be used today, except in a historical context, such as Mt. Vernon. Per Drew Langsner, the earliest mention of milk paint used on Windsor’s was around 1850. You will find a large number of old chairs with their paint stripped off and a clear finish applied. I have two this way myself. Talking with several people that work with museums this was probably done around 1876 (the first centennial). This is when America first gained an interest in antiques. So, if the clear finish is old, it has been accepted as being OK.
From my perspective, if the chair was made after 1900 and it has a clear finish it would be appropriate to refinish it with a clear coat. If it was painted, then I feel it should be repainted. The question should be asked, does the customer want it to look new or old and do they want a historically accurate finish? If they want it to look new and have a historically accurate finish that will be hard to do, because you cannot legally apply the historically correct paint. However if they want a paint that looks like the paint of old, Drew Langsner taught me the recipe that he uses in his book the Chairmaker’s Workshop. He recommends mixing 3 parts of high quality Satin alkyd enamel interior oil based paint (he personally recommends Pratt and Lambert) to 1 part flat or satin polyurethane varnish (I recommend the flat or dull rub poly). He then applies 2 coats of primer followed by 3 coats of paint rubbed out between each coat and a minimum of 24 hours drying time between coats. This will leave a nice low luster finish that is tough as nails and more flexible than the paint alone. It wears well and where it wears through, the wood that shows through will have a nice and polished patina. If the customer wants something that looks old, but is not historically accurate then apply milk paint.
There is nothing wrong in trying to educate the customer, however refer to rule number 1 in business; the customer is always right. Rule number 2, when the customer is wrong, refer to rule #1. The customer is paying for what they want unless it absolutely goes against your moral fiber, give them what they want, unless you know it is a valuable piece and that they would ruin it by doing what they want. At that point, I would refuse the job and let them take it elsewhere.