I am trying to brush Zinser SealCoat. I am using it straight from the can.
I'm brushing it on the small wall clock I am (still!!!) working on.
I'm using a Taklon brush.
I can't get it to flow on nicely. I can't keep a wet edge it dries so fast. I keep sanding it down smooth after each attempt. I keep getting lines, streaks, puddles, brush marks and so on. Looks horrible.
I just watched a decent Paul Sellers video (episode 8 of his clock project) where for half an hour he brushed on shellac. Made it look so simple.
I am wondering it this SealCoat should be thinned out. If so, how much?
Thinning may help but not very much. Thinner product (1lb cut rather than the 2lb cut from the can) will require twice as many application. You can use some pure turpentine as a retarder (2-4 drops to a cupful) to give it more time to flow and level. You may still have to do some leveling.
I never had much luck brushing solvent finishes; I either pad them on or spray.
I've brushed a fair amount of SealCoat. I always used a nylon/polyester brush. No thinning or retarding. Put it on, and leave it alone, don't try to work it in or move it around too much. It's thin to begin with, so only put on a thin coat.
Cheap DNA is often denatured with methanol, which is poisonous and can be absorbed through the skin or the lungs. I find that brushes that are part Taklon and part sable work better than all Taklon for shellac, for example, Robert Simmons Sapphire brushes. For flat wood in projects the size of your clock I use a half inch either flat or mop brush, and for carvings and mouldings, I use a half inch oval or filbert, for example:
Trying to keep a wet edge is an exercise in futility. Just brush one brush full out to a feathered edge, refill the brush and apply another patch next to and overlapping the previous patch.
Thinning shellac with alcohol will not slow down its drying. In fact, it will speed it up. Use the turpentine as suggested above. A couple of tablespoons per quart will slow down the drying.
I can't understand how additional shellac could possibly speed up the evaporation. After half of the alcohol is evaporated, the mixture that remains is the same as the unthinned Seal-Coat you started with, and due to the previous evaporation, it's colder, so it will continue to evaporate at a slower rate. It also has more water mixed with it (condensate from the atmosphere), which will additionally decrease the evaporation rate of the alcohol.
I bush shellac generally, I don't worry about a wet edge and I don't worry about sanding unless there is a big blob. What I do is after a few coats I take my alcohol and a good cloth (sometime pumice) and rub it out using a bit of linseed oil for lubrication. It takes a bit of practice but works. Of course this is on flat stuff, haven't tried pieces with curves.
"After half of the alcohol is evaporated..." Better to think about this in terms of a specific amount of alcohol. For example, 1oz per sqft. A thicker mixture goes on thicker, and thus will have more alcohol per sqft. So maybe after 1oz/sqft of alcohol has evaporated, half of the alcohol is gone from a thick coat, but all of the alcohol is gone from a thin coat.
You're controlling for different parameters, which totally changes the discussion.
Also, the evaporation rate is not linear. That's why you can pad or brush several thin layers quickly, but then must wait several hours before continuing while the small amount of alcohol that remains in the shellac has time to evaporate, and the film to "cure".
"You're controlling for different parameters, which totally changes the discussion." I don't know what you mean here.
"Also, the evaporation rate is not linear." Yes, of course it's not. But neither was I providing an exact calculation, just trying to simply illustrate a point.
That's why you can pad or brush several thin layers quickly, but then must wait several hours before continuing while the small amount of alcohol that remains in the shellac has time to evaporate, and the film to "cure". Here you seem to be making my point for me. A thicker coat takes longer to cure...
I brush shellac, Zinsser "Traditional Finish" which I believe to be a waxy shellac, 3 pound cut. Sometimes I thin 1:1 for a seal coat. I have gone through three gallons in the past few years, flat surfaces. I use a foam brush. The foam brushes that Woodworkers Supply sells in packs of 50 hold up in the shellac solvent. Others disintegrate. For small parts I cut pieces of upholstery foam to be used as a brush. Works good for finishing on the lathe. When done, brush is tossed.
I have sprayed shellac. It is difficult to spray, being sensitive to humidity and prone to runs. But the result is glass smooth, and occasionally covered by a layer of condensed water if it is too humid .
I have watched two professional woodworkers from our club brush shellac. They both use a "thirsty" natural bristle brush. (They both apprenticed under the same mentor, Emmett from Knoxville) They use long strokes, one direction only, and never go back over an area once a line of finish is laid down. They work quickly.
Then there is the misbegotten recommendation of Takalon. I was at a shellac seminar given by the guru of shellac, Don Williams. When he got to the Takalon part I offered the opinion that I had bought one of these brushes and it was useless because it held so little finish. Unfazed, he offered the opinion that I didn't know how to use it and invited me to learn in front of the class. It works, but not by any means one would discover on their own.
What I recall about the process..... With jar of shellac in one hand and brush in the other, dip brush and start brushing a small area, in short strokes, like a mad man. Think windshield wipers on high. Dip, and brush to spread over a small area. Don't worry about drips from the brush; just brush them out. I likened it to padding with a brush.
What ever means you settle on, it will likely take practice to become proficient.
Turpentine has a high boiling point. It will takes months to be rid of the smell and fully harden the coating. From the perspective of never having used it, in theory, it seems a poor idea.
Shellac thinned with pure isopropanol brushes nicely and dries slowly.
I don't know what you mean here. I was just pointing out a general principle: If I hold Property A constant while I vary independent Property B, the effects on Property C can be very different than if I vary Property A while I hold Property B constant.
that a few drops of pure turps in a cup of shellac delays evaporation just enough but then dries up nicely (powders) over night. Largely does away with laps when doing hand-applied. Can be sprayed as well but may tend to create sags on vertical surfaces, and pressure needs to be adjusted to higher in the HVLP range of my gun.
Residual scent is negligible unless too much is used.
Jeff Jewitt markets a product called "Shellac Wet" which works as a retarder and a flow agent. It does well but can't be top-coated with waterborne or water based finishes due to adhesion problems.
"Trying to keep a wet edge is an exercise in futility."
Tell me about it...
" Just brush one brush full out to a feathered edge, refill the brush and apply another patch next to and overlapping the previous patch."
But that leaves very obvious lines. Do you just expect that and rub out? Do you always rub out shellac?
It seems like you can't get a nice finish off the brush and that you need to plan on rubbing out regardless. Is that correct?
I have to say that this (somewhat) pricey Taklon brush is pretty useless. It holds very little finish and the bristles/filaments are so wimpy and limp it almost impossible to 'brush' with it.
If you apply it like Bill Tindall describes (and as taught by Don Williams), each application is brushed out to a feather edge. With enough coats and an appropriate brush, it all averages out, and the overlapping edges are not noticeable.
A cheap brush will not perform to your satisfaction, for several reasons, and not just the raw materials. A good brush also has a large reservoir to hold more finish, and very fine bristles with flagged ends. The Robert Simmons brushes, if you buy them at inflated retail prices, are also expensive, but are much less expensive from Jerry's, especially when you find them on sale. (If you can tolerate the email barrage, sign up for their sale notifications.) You might also be using a brush that is too large, and delivers too much finish to be feathered out before the edges start to dry. Even for large surfaces like table tops, you don't need a brush wider than 1", and for smaller areas, 1/2" or 3/4" work better.
The first brushes I bought for shellac and for lacquer were 1" and 2" wide, and made from "multi-varmint" bristles: badger, pure hog bristle and skunk. The Kolinsky sable I mentioned in the previous post is a particular type of weasel. I rarely use the 2" brush any more. These are really expensive, from Woodworkers Supply, items 850-392 and 850-399. The bristles are set in place with epoxy, so they don't fall into your finish, and the ferrule is stainless, and soldered together. These are all features that are essential to the performance of the brush, but also significantly add to its expense. Since they are so expensive, they need to be cleaned thoroughly and carefully after every job.
If you need a video tutorial on an effective method of brushing on shellac, reference Don Williams' video, "Creating Historic Furniture Finishes." He notes that he has slowed down for illustrative purposes, so he doesn't appear to be "brushing like a mad man."
You can sand lightly between coats of shellac with 400 grit. "Lightly" means by hand with the grain, and not so vigorously that you melt the shellac and load the paper. There's no need to tack off the dust, since it's pure shellac, and the alcohol in the next coat will redissolve it. You can also rub out the final coat, with Liberon 0000 steel wool, or Norton or 3M grey synthetic steel wool. To kill two birds with one stone, I use the grey "ScotchBrite" to apply beeswax (usually in the form of Johnson's paste wax) after I've finished shellacing.
All I know is I get a shinier surface if there is just enough pumice on the pad to be noticeable. Perhaps I'm using so little that it tends to stick with the pad?