I know I've read many reports here through the years about florescent fixtures and lights in workshops that were either replaced or upgraded. Recently one of the four 8-foot double tube T-12 fixtures in my shop needed a new ballast. In the past I've replaced a few without issue because I was able to buy replacement magnetic ballasts at the local home improvement stores. This time all I could find were electronic ballasts.
Not knowing better, I bought one and installed it. It worked for a few times before it stopped. After looking into it I found that GE says you can't mix the two types when the fixtures are on the same line.
So now I was faced with trying to find a magnetic ballast at an electrical supply house, replace the old T-12 fixtures with T-8's, replace them with new T-12's, or replace all 4 magnetic ballasts with electronic. Since I still have a box of T-12 bulbs on hand, I made the decision to stay with T-12's even though the standard has shifted to T-8's. I was able to buy new electronic ballasts for less than the whole new fixtures, so that's what I did. I expect I'll be able to find replacement ballasts going forward too.
I installed all four ballasts and turned on the lights. They came on instantly and there was no more of that annoying hum. Wow, I should have done this sooner!
What do you mean "GE says you can't mix the two types when the fixtures are on the same line."?
Does that mean they can't be on the same breaker? Or as one of two in a dual ballast fixture? I acquired a box of newer ballasts at a freight auction and have started changing mine out. but, being lazy I was doing them as they failed. Have had no problems with the new ones and the old ones seem to be trundling along. What next?
After all this time lighting has become "new science" again. Can't use CFL's on fixtures that have day'night sensors. What's an old Fuddy Duddy to do?
Over the years I replaced mag. ballasts with electronic without any issue. The electronic ballasts don't cause the fixture to vibrate (hum), they don't flicker, they are more efficient and they are brighter.....according to my GE brother in law lighting engineer.
I purchased an electronic ballast for the 8-foot fixture that wasn't working and installed it. It worked for only a short time before not coming on the next day. I went online after this and checked reviews. Although people said they hadn't had any issues (not sure what their configurations were other than 8-foot T-12 two-tube fixture), there was one fellow whose comments rang a bell with my situation (copied below). Based off of that information I just replaced all four of mine. The good from it is my lights come on quicker, quieter, and replacement ballasts will be easy to find going forward.
I had two 8' fixtures in my garage. One fixture went out, replaced the magnetic ballast with a 74475 electronic ballast. The first one lasted about one evening and stopped working. I replaced it with another and it lasted 2 hours. I called GE service line and told them my problem and the first thing they asked was "did I have another magnetic ballast wired to the same AC source" and of course I did and he said "that's the problem". The electrical noise caused by the magnetic ballast goes down the ac line to the other ballast and burns it up.
That's crazy. Unless you have electrical noise filters, that "noise" created by the magnetic ballast will be present on ALL circuits in your house/shop, as they're all connected electrically.
I could MAYBE see that a magnetic ballast physically right next to an electronic one would cause problems. Otherwise, I'd say you found a couple from a bad batch--I think all the electronic ballast manufacturers have had problems of some sort or another over the years.
I have a bro-in-law who designed electronic ballasts (now he oversees design work, I think, maybe production). I'll have to ask him sometime.