Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Deposits - how much?

Posts

Deposits - how much?

#1

JL

Deposits - how much?

JL

First - this job is for my brother.

He wants to commission me to build a few chairs.

I have no problem w/ that.

Typically, when I bid a job, I ask for 50% up front.

That usually covers the cost of the materials. So $400 would cover the cost of lumber and supplies.

Other thoughts?

Re: Deposits - how much?

#2

For my brother I would not ask for deposit

Dick Coers

Unless you are in a situation where $400 would put you in a bind. My brother and I are not really close, but he is my brother and if I can't trust him, who could I trust. On the other hand, he may still have his first dollar. Ordering custom chairs would never be on his radar!

I've sold my work for almost 40 years now, and the only time I got stung was on a job where I did not ask for half down. They bought the samples I made, then after a delay on delivery on my part, they just walked away. No discussion, no contact, no more money. It stuck me with a bunch of finished work and a special lathe that I had purchased to do the job.

Re: Deposits - how much?

#3

Re: Deposits - how much?

Jesse Cloud

Even (or maybe especially) with family, I think its important to communicate well before starting a project. I learned the hard way that friends and family can change their minds mid-project - either losing interest all together or wanting something different.

Agree on the design, materials, finish, etc. so everyone will know what to expect, when it will be ready, and how much it will cost.

And if your brother is getting "a few chairs" for $1K, he's getting a very good deal!

Re: Deposits - how much?

#4

Re: For my brother I would not ask for deposit

paul in AZ

If it was my sister I would ask for the entire amount up front. In cash. They do have a long history of stiffing everybody so are in a different category.

Families can be tough.

Your brother may be more honorable.

Re: Deposits - how much?

#5

Re: Deposits - how much?

Mark Nowicki

Ask for what you typically take.

Mark

Re: Deposits - how much?

#6

Re: Deposits - how much?

robbcarr

I'm really astonished.... you would really ask you brother for a deposit?

My father has been in construction all his life and has always had the position that close friends and family always get stuff at cost or maybe even below in some cases..... I think that's a good way of doing things.

He has said that once you put friends and family in with the guy that walks in just off the street and start charging full price and something goes wrong, even if you go way above and beyond what you would normally do to fix it, it's likely to cause friction in the relationship and it's not worth creating bad feeling over or loosing a friendship, especially in the case of relatives.

For my brother I probably wouldn't even charge for the wood.... maybe make it into a birthday gift?

Re: Deposits - how much?

#7

deposit no, partial payment yes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am assuming this is a family "business" deal. The brother is paying for the chairs. Unless you have piles of surplus cash laying about I would ask for the price of materials before starting.

Re: Deposits - how much?

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Deposits - how much?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

For those closest to me, I've done plenty of work for the cost of material, or if they've bought the material and still insist on paying me, I'll say, "Whatever it was worth to you." When I say that, I don't care one bit what the amount I get is--I would have done it for free, so anything they pay is a bonus. Often I'll do that for someone who is in another trade whose services I may need at some point (like a good friend who is HVAC licensed...).

Jason

Re: Deposits - how much?

#9

Re: Deposits - how much?

Chuck in Mtl.

Conduct this as you would a business transaction with a non relative. My rule of thumb...do not mix business with family.

Re: Deposits - how much?

#10

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Deposits - how much?

Jim in River Oaks, Ont

I'd ask for the cost of materials and go from there.

I've had some not so good family politics crop in and destroy the flavour of a project, every one agreed up front on a deposit and I got a head start on the final piece, completed it and delivered it (500 miles away), not a penny was ever paid to me, sour feelings all around.

Even in a Good Family money can creep in and cause problems, keep it about business, get materials covered at a min.

Take care, Jim

Re: Deposits - how much?

#11

Re: Deposits - how much?

mdclor

I usually just make items as gifts for immediate family, but I did charge my daughter for the cost of the wood when I made a set of 4 chairs because of the cost. If a family member asks me for an item that they will use as a gift, I charge regular retail.

Re: Deposits - how much?

#12

Joe Bradshaw

Re: Deposits - how much?

Joe Bradshaw

JL, remember what the bikers say; gas grass or a&&, no one rides for free.

Re: Deposits - how much?

#13

Re: Deposits - how much?

fred in ct

If it were my daughters I would not charge them for labor or materials but if it was for my brother I wouldn't do the project for any amount, burned once was enough.

Re: Deposits - how much?

#14

Re: Deposits - how much?

TomD

I think the key is to know why you are charging a deposit. Deposits have different purposes, such as ensuring a place in a build line, and minimizing expensive tire kickers and covering the cost of admin. Or to finance the cost of materials, as you say. To spread the cost of a product over time like an instalment plan. To create an incentive for the client to stick with the project. And so forth.

If you take the word brother out of it, and add in the reason for the deposit in all it's specifics, then you should know what you are going to have to charge. Any gift you want to make as a result of the family relationship is another mater, though I think it is a bad idea because people rarely value hand work as it is.

When it comes to wood, the actual cost is the retail cost to them not your cost.

I recently bought my daughter a guitar she has never played before and is heading off to a dorm where a 4K custom guitar is not a good choice. I was in a local stereo store looking for some wires and picked up a Fender Dreadnought, on sale for around 90 dollars. Sounds "good", bought it. She was delighted. If she ever gets into it I would gladly make her a guitar but the experience indicates that a 4K guitar is actually worth 90 dollars to her, along with a bling surcharge of about maybe 250. I'd be better off selling a guitar if I was still doing that, and buying her a Fender Dreadnought and a small Japanese car.

Re: Deposits - how much?

#15

Re: Deposits - how much?

Mark Nowicki

The brother probably knows that JL does this for a living and he should have offered a deposit without being asked.

I had an uncle that used to shower me with gifts on my birthdays, communion and other special occasions.

He also had a Polish equivalent of a dollar store.

In the store, no member of the family ever got anything without paying for it.

Mark