Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

End Grain Joinery.

Posts

End Grain Joinery.

#1

End Grain Joinery.

DAvid Frame

Hello Friends,

I'm looking for information on joining shorts of pressure treated lumber for my fencing. There are many finger joint router bits that I sure will do a good job. I normally fabricate short pieces of pressure treated lumber and make Scarf Joints to make boards long enough for fencing or other applications. I glue them with epoxy and clamp the two boards together to make sure the scarf joint won't fail. Is it possible to us a finger jointing router bit and have it stand up to the strength of a scarf joint?

Please let me know how you folks deal with lumber stretching.

Thanks for your time,

Sincerely,

David Frame

Re: End Grain Joinery.

#2

Re: End Grain Joinery.

David Yoho

First off, I've never done what you are asking about, especially with PT lumber used outdoors. I've always made sure I had the proper lengths for the job and use smaller cutoffs for other things that come along later. That said, I'm not sure why you're asking your question if your scarf joint method has worked so far. Is it that you're wanting a new type of router bit to try out or is it that you're wondering if finger joints are stronger than scarf joints for your application?

I just finished a 12 x 12 deck with a pergola above and new steps and railings leading to our screened porch. All this just to have a place to put our new hot tub. As usual, all the PT lumber was fairly wet. When it's still wet it doesn't take crisp cuts like that required of finger joints. I'd say your scarf joints wouldn't have that issue and as long as the epoxy is working, it's probably safer to go with what has worked for you.

Re: End Grain Joinery.

#3

Re: End Grain Joinery.

John K Jordan

David, 40+ years ago a totally clueless me made a few beautiful joints in pressure-treated lumber for a deck railing. I quickly learned my lesson - joinery in PT outside is a waste of effort. All the PT lumber I had was soaking wet and very soon twisted, cupped, shrunk, and otherwise destroyed the joint. I suppose kiln-dried PT might be different but I've never had any.

I've made a few such joints since but always reinforced them with steel plates or straps embedded into recesses chiseled into the backside of the joints. This has worked fine.

These days I use a lot of PT here on the farm. I try to make every joint in a 2-by structural beam over a wide post and secure with screws or bolts. Often I double beams for more strength - in this case I try not to join at a post. All joints are overlapped with another board which takes care of the odd length nicely. Where doubled thickness is not needed, I will back a butt joint with say a 3' length and fasten with screws and perhaps construction adhesive.

I suspect you are more concerned with looks for your fence than I am for a horse shelter, so your scarf/epoxy joint might be better, assuming it has held up in the past in sun and rain. I don't have wood fences but I have seen plenty of beautiful fences in horse country where each joint was made in the center of a post and strengthened with a short piece overlapping the butt joint in front. Usually painted black this looked great and seemed to hold up over the years.

JKJ

Re: End Grain Joinery.

#4

Re: End Grain Joinery. *LINK*

Hank Knight

David,

I think a "finger joint" bit is what you're looking for. See link below. I generally agree with others about the difficulty of joining PT lumber. Nevertheless, I built my gardener wife a potting bench out of very wet PT lumber 5 or 6 years ago and glued the joints with polyurethane (Gorilla) glue. I hate gorilla glue, but it worked great for this application. The bench has been outside since I completed it and it is still solid. I didn't use finger joints; I used half lap joints and screwed them together with SS screws along with the glue.

Good luck with your project.

Hank


Finger Joint Bit

Re: End Grain Joinery.

#5

Re: End Grain Joinery.

TomD

"Is it possible to us a finger jointing router bit and have it stand up to the strength of a scarf joint?"

Yes and no. It comes down to the anticipated failure mode. If you have a classic post function with all the loading in longitudinal compression, a finger joint might be stronger, if you are talking about a beam mode where the failure mode is in tension/compression then probably the finger joint is going to go first since there are many endgrain to endgrain surfaces. If you are super lucky in how you set up a finger joint, or carefully scale your material, there can be mini scarfs at the edge of the piece, these will stop easy initial failure in the joint from fiber lifting. But you could also set it up so that the edge of the finger joint is a but joint and these are much weaker in a bending failure mode.

You can scale scarf joints to loose less material. In a scarf joint in real 2x4 material one could loose 32 inches a scarf, but if done on the narrow axis, one would only loose 16 inches a scarf. You may know that for different grades of wood, all pretty perfect, scarfs as recommended at slopes ranging from 1x8 to 1x20. The main reasons for the variations are the different qualities of the various grades of wood. The same idea applies to useless crap wood, or uses that do not heavily load your wood. So you can scarf joints with even steeper slopes, you will get 100% strength of worse grades since they are breaking at lower loadings anyway. The same concept applies to uses that do not heavily load wood since a scarf joint of well less than 100% might still be strong enough. Unfortunately I don't have any numbers for you since I have never scarfed PT wood. And up here there are so many knots in it, that it has very little strength at all. There does come a point where the scarfs get so blunt they are harder to glue up, depending on your method.

Re: End Grain Joinery.

#6

Re: Harware bonding

TomD

One option is hardware bonding. You bond a stud into the end of one piece with epoxy, then bond the other end into the piece you want to join it to. This method require a 3/4" hole in either side of the joint, and some 1/2" rebar. It is basically dowelling, but the concept uses an oversized hole and a rebar or threaded rod stud. Alignment is no problem because you have an oversized hole.

An example of such a use is I am building a motor boat where the boat does not have a transom. The motor mount is a pedestal, and water can drain to either side of it. The problem is how to bond the pedestal to the deck of the boat. I will certainly tab it in with epoxy fillets and glass, but then the load transfer is in shear to the plies of the admittedly cheap plywood I am using. So what I am doing is putting in some mainstrength bulkheads under the deck, and I will stud bond directly into them as well as all the tabbing. This work great because I don't even have to make the holes all that accurate, and in this case I can mount the studs in the pedestal while it is inverted, then pot them into holes in the deck, no problems with glue running out of the joints.

If you were joining two pieces into a 36" post it would be easy to set up, but in the case where you are joining two 20 foot poles you would have to work a little harder to make the joint, without the glue oozing out. Obviously you are going to bond the endgrains together. This is the basic method they use to bond windmill blades to their hubs, or to glue hugely loaded keels to race boats. It is VERY strong.

Re: End Grain Joinery.

#7

Re: End Grain Joinery.

David FRame

John,

I forgot to mention the PT lumber has been stickered in my shop for over the last two years. So I guess your right by using epoxy to adhere the joint together.

Thanks for you advice and time,

Your friend at WoodCentral,

David Frame

Re: End Grain Joinery.

#8

Re: End Grain Joinery.

David Frame

Hi Hank,

I completely forgot about Polyurethane glue. As we both know, moisture is what sets that glue in motion to dry. It just so happens I have a brand new bottle of Gorilla Glue. Thanks for the tip.

Thanks for your guidance.

Your friend at Wood Central,

David Frame

Re: End Grain Joinery.

#9

Re: End Grain Joinery.

David Frame

Hi Tom,

This my first time I'm gluing a scarf joint in PT lumber. The PT lumber has been stickered in my garage for the last two years. I'm sure the epoxy or polyurethane will hold. The only reason I don't want to buy a finger joint bit is the cost.

However, I built a home in New Orleans and I needed a 16' x 7" x 1" piece of maple to cover 2x4 and 1" of sheetrock that was the top of the handrail to make it look clean. On top of that, I added some risers and on top the risers I added an upside down trapezoid for the handrail.

Thanks for your help,

David.

Re: End Grain Joinery.

#10

Re: End Grain Joinery.

TomD

Good luck with the