Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

How Thin The Veneer

Posts

How Thin The Veneer

#1

How Thin The Veneer

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

of friendly discourse has become here on WoodCentral.

Case in point is the Tommy Skaggs SawStop thread with outright verbal blows exchanged.

Time was, this forum carried on the novel experiment that was Badger Pond where more than a few lifetime friendships were formed. There was a real sense of identity and cooperation that prevailed. Even when disagreements on a point arose, posters were aware of the difference between "disagree" and "disrespect."

I've gone read-only here because I wanted to sit back and watch without feeling the obligation to jump in and correct clear errors. There were a plethora of opportunities to do so in the Skaggs discussion, but I'm not, nor have I ever been, a member of the thread police here, or anywhere else.

There is no need to respond to this message. But if you value Wood Central as a place to stop in to learn, to seek advice, to give advice, or just generally share in an atmosphere of respect and cooperation, I suggest that you go back and read the SawStop thread with an eye for tone and how the give and take were treated.

I'll not speak for anyone else, of course, but if that is how discussions will proceed on Wood Central, it will continue to poke along without further input from me.

Re: How Thin The Veneer

#2

Re: How Thin The Veneer

mdclor

Mark, wordsmith that you are, you said it much better than my feeble attempt. Thank you!

Re: How Thin The Veneer

#3

There was a time

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

When we had regional picnics that we could meet and put a face to the names that we saw at Woodcentral and exchange knowledge and verbal barbs face to face, where the intended emotion was obvious from the expressions and tone of the voice. It is difficult at best to determine the tone of keystrokes.

For some reason certain topics, Sawstop being one of them seem to bring out highly polarized points of view with no room for compromise.

Lee

Re: How Thin The Veneer

#4

Re: How Thin The Veneer

BobS

Well said. I did the same, watching the exchange without any interest in contributing to what could have been an in depth discussion of table saws in general and the flaws inherent in them all (SawStop as well). Nope, lets bash about like the proverbial bull in a china shop and steamroll over anyone that dares to disagree.

For my liking the discussion ended rather abruptly without any details on the fixes or resolution, don't quite understand why. Seems to me if you are planning to use the forum to air the dirty laundry about a specific tool it would be worthwhile to also air the final results as freely. Just my 2 cents.

Re: How Thin The Veneer

#5

What I've always liked about this forum...

John in NM

Is that the moderation errs on the side of moderation. Sometimes threads do get out of hand, and words are exchanged that would likely never be said in person, without the comfortable screen of online anonymity.

But I find that better than the alternative, as I've seen on other forums, where in the extreme people get banned for little more than disagreeing with the forum owner/representatives.

We are all adults after all, and we all do make mistakes in intent and speech when posting or reacting to posts. Most everyone who posts often has made such mistakes, and I would like to believe that most of us learn from them.

Perhaps it is a naive sentiment, but I look at some of these contentious debates as the material by which we can learn to not hold grudges. Without that material, I doubt many of us would learn it. I learn by making mistakes more often than by memorizing rules.

Re: How Thin The Veneer

#6

Re: How Thin The Veneer

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Well said Mark, thank you.

I am a post Badger Pond, member of the WoodCentral 'family'.

I guess the only thing I can say is that I do consider WoodCentral and the folks who frequent the message boards here, to be to be a (my) family of sorts, and occasionally we get a little out of hand. Similar to the mayhem that occurs once in a while at any family gathering.

At the end of the day, we're all here due to a common interest of one sort or another etc.

So:

1) Tommy, I'm glad that your TS problems have been fixed!

2) It's good that between SS and the vendor things were made right.

3) Glad I didn't waste any of my "making a fool of myself capabilities" on that thread, (saved em for this one).

Ok, I'm done.

Bob in NJ

Re: How Thin The Veneer

#7

Re: What I've always liked about this forum...

Dick Coers

I agree John, Ellis does a wonderful job. I've asked for moderation in the past, and got the help I asked for.

I often wonder if the demographic here is what I think. A majority of older men that, well, can get pretty grouchy. We've put in our dues, paid the price with broken or breaking down bodies, and more often than not, consider our opinions as gospel. We consider that this gospel is based on life experiences and should not be questioned. A lot of these discussions so remind me of having teenagers back in the house. But in the case of this forum, we all have the life experiences to back up our conversation. Not like a teenager who is just simply wired to think they are always right.

Still the best forum around!!!!

Re: How Thin The Veneer

#8

Re: How Thin The Skin

TomD

I think it is a delicate thing because there is the risk with this kind of comment that it just comes off as patronizing, or culturally tone deaf. The "I am better than the rest of you" part is obvious (whether intended or not), the cultural part is just that some people are not afraid of argument, and consider it a fine thing. There are certain professions built around it.

What we may need isn't the thought police, but more participants who haven't been heard from, and would like to share some new perspectives in maybe 20K posts over the next few years. I am not certain why the post volume has fallen off on some forums, but I don't think it is for lack of "Atta boys, or "couldn't agree mores". Or because we don't have enough people promoting their better manners, which last I heard was bad manners...

I salute those who have sidelined themselves and look forward to the new content that we can all enjoy if not agree with. But someone new needs to step

Re: How Thin The Veneer

#9

Clint Searl

Re: How Thin The Veneer

Clint Searl

The variety of exchanges offer an opportunity to speculate about the involved personalities.

Re: How Thin The Veneer

#10

Ellis Walentine

I guess I need to weigh in

Ellis Walentine

To me, this has to do with the nature of community. No community is perfect, nor will any number of rules or enforcements change human nature. We get incensed about perceived wrongs, others pile on or hold back. The beauty of the forum format to me is that enough discussion can usually inform any issue enough that people go away satisfied, or at least informed. Sometimes, it gets messy in the midst of the discussion, but as long as there's no outright flaming, I tend to let the debate run its course.

There are many dimensions to these discussions, and many possibilities for misunderstanding. Not least of these is that we all have different facilities with language and protocol. I try to view posts in the sense that the poster intends, which means I have to overlook misstatements, biases, unintened slurs and flawed logic. However you articulate your position, it's valid here unless you cross a few commonsense lines in the sand.

I say, let's not be afraid to say what we really think, as long as we don't hurt others.

Ellis