Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

end grain gluing

Posts

end grain gluing

#1

end grain gluing

eliot feldman

Consider something like a picture frame miter glue-up. We know that it's basically a fairly weak end grain glue joint. Suppose one were simply to slide a long-grain veneer between the end grain pieces and then glue in all up. Then it would be end-grain to side-grain (twice). Wouldn't that be substantially stronger? ( I'm not asking about the usual spline or lap joint.)

Re: end grain gluing

#2

Re: end grain gluing

William Duffield

No, you still have two glue to end grain interfaces, which are just as weak as two glue to end grain interfaces. The glue will stick just fine to both sides of the veneer, but that doesn't buy you anything.

Re: end grain gluing

#3

I certainly think it's worth a trial, eliot


Re: end grain gluing

#4

No, it would probably be worse.

Keith Newton

One of the great shortcomings of mitered frames, is that any guan in MC will cause the boards to expand, breaking the outside of the miter, and a decrease breaks the inside of an otherwise perfectly made joint. The problem isn't so bad with narrow parts, but gets worse as the parts get wider.

For this reason, most larger picture frames tilt outward rather than laying flat. This allows the tilt to change slightly without breaking the joint. But with the veneer as you describe, any change in the width of the frame sides would be counter to what the veneer could accomidate.

Re: end grain gluing

#5

Re: No, it would probably be worse.

Bill Howatt

I agree. The width of the mitered edges would want to move with increased moisture but the side-grain of the veneer would not move to the same degree at all.

Bill

Re: end grain gluing

#6

Re: end grain gluing

Dick Coers

One way to get a better end grain glue up is two applications of the glue. Wet the entire end grain surface with glue and let it rest. When it has soaked in a bit, and certainly before it looks dry, apply a second coat and then clamp. That goal is to use the first coat like a primer. End grain soaks out the moisture and makes a dry joint. Try a sample and see if you like it better. I was taught this method, and I like the results.

Re: end grain gluing

#7

Re: end grain gluing

TomD

Just finished a few square feet of laborious endgrain glueing today. I am using up scraps of balsa wood core material. Like laying a parkay floor. I get teased for not doing stuff, but I doubt most of you will endgrain glue a half sheet of plywood area of fiddly little hand rubbed joints this week. This stuff is structural, since it is the cockpit floor of my solo flats skiff. The key to strength in this area is using epoxy. There was a regular writer for FWW several decades back who did fancy display cases with grillwork, and his miters were all glued with west epoxy, a great choice. He was the guy who gave up cabinetmaking for a ministry.

If you can slant the joint in the other direction so it is skewed. Or use your veneer as a subtle spline, or do a hidden dovetail, etc... You can add strength to a miter also.

There is a misconception that endgrain joints are weaker than sidegrain joints, this isn't true. What is true is that you can get full strength in a sidegrain joint, but only a minimal percent of strength in endgrain joints. But that has more to do with the ease with which sidegrain splits. If you glue endgrain to sidegrain, it will still break outside the glue joint, just as it does with sidegrain to sidegrain. But the 0 axis is what carries heavy loads, and it would be nice if we could just glue stuff end to end.

Re: end grain gluing

#8

What he said, plus

Tom Sontag - St. louis

A miter joint is only 50 percent end grain; it is also half long grain. I find if glued as Dick suggests it is plenty strong for frames. When I need extra strength I add the splines. What you suggest is unnecessary and would look pretty bad IMO.

Re: end grain gluing

#9

Yes, and...

David Yoho

This is the method I've used in the past that has worked well. However, I like it with liquid hide glue more than yellow. Problem is - if you go off and forget the yellow and it dries, you're screwed. The same is not true for liquid hide glue. Otherwise, it works well with either.

Re: end grain gluing

#10

confused

tom sontag - st. louis

Your last paragraph did not register very well in my brain. I dissect it below:

--There is a misconception that endgrain joints are weaker than sidegrain joints, this isn't true. What is true is that you can get full strength in a sidegrain joint, but only a minimal percent of strength in endgrain joints.



Those two sentences seem to say opposite things. Isn't a joint with "only a minimal percent of strength" weaker than a full strength one?

--But that has more to do with the ease with which sidegrain splits.

Let's keep the discussion on the JOINT, not the nearby wood

--If you glue endgrain to sidegrain, it will still break outside the glue joint, just as it does with sidegrain to sidegrain.



I am tempted to test this. I'll take your word for now.

--But the 0 axis is what carries heavy loads,



?? Help!

--and it would be nice if we could just glue stuff end to end.

Amen brother.

Re: end grain gluing

#11

Cutting the Profiles

Yonak

It seems to me an issue would be how to profile the end slices. If you profile it with, say, a router, along with the rest of the rail, it will tear out at the trailing end. Maybe the slice could be made extra thick for the trailing ends and then re-cut the mitres if it can be done accurately.