Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Non-toxic finish for Beech table

Posts

Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#1

Non-toxic finish for Beech table

Jordan

Hiya! I'm a new woodworker and have finished all the cuts and assembly for an Arts-and-Crafts style dining table made from Beech. It's not a perfect piece of furniture but it is my first big scale attempt at something and I love the fact that I made it on my own, warts and all.

I am also 14 weeks pregnant and am now facing a quandary for how to finish my table. I would like to have the table done before the birth of my baby, what is a good kind of finish I can work with while I am pregnant? I'd still be using a respirator and working in a well ventilated place, and I can work in shifts if necessary. After it's finished I will be putting a glass top to cover the dining surface so water resitancy isn't a big concern.

I have been exploring shellac but I actually live in the Middle East and getting ethanol may prove to be a problem. Is there another medium that shellac can work well with? I've also thought about just rubbing loads of wax into the wood, but I'm not sure if this is a good idea.

Any tips or advice is appreciated! And please be kind, I am an admitted novice but I am eager to learn. :)


img

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#2

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

Alexandre Grigoriev

Shellac can be dissolved in isopropyl alcohol (propanol). Anhydrous, if you can't find it. Also, it could be that denatured (undrinkable) ethanol is still available in Islamic countries. Shellac premixed with ethanol may be available, because it's not drinkable.

Over shellac, I'd suggest water-borne oil-modified polyurethane, such as ZAR UltraMax, antic flat sheen. It's the closest thing to solvent-based poly, without obnoxious fumes. Shellac is not really necessary, though. If you don't have spray equipment, I suggest using foam brushes for it. Don't use cheap foam brushes because they fall apart. "wooster pro classic" foam brush is so far the best. Try to apply it when it's not too hot.

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#3

Send it out

paul in AZ

Send it out and have a pro paint shop do it for you. Problem solved with whatever finish you choose.

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#4

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

don stephan

Nice table design.

Be aware that beech moves more seasonally than typical furniture woods we use here in the US such as cherry, maple, oak, and walnut. So be sure the design allows for wood movement if there are seasonal changes in relative humidity, and/or forced air heating and/or cooling that dries out wood.

Personally I don' like glass on dining tables. Spills are too likely, and if the liquid gets between the glass and the tabletop cleanup can be a challenge. Wax reportedly water spots very easily so I wouldn't recommend a wax finish on any dining table.

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#5

What do you have available?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

That is a very nice table.

Beech is a nearly white wood. You do not want to put a finish on it that will yellow with age. I would suggest a water based acrylic finish if it will have a glass top. Most of the water based finishes resist yellowing when exposed to light and air.

a water base finish designed for kitchen cabinets would be ideal.

What kinds of finish do you have available?

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#6

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

William Duffield

I also recommend shellac. The shellac itself is non-toxic. It is used for coating medicines and candy. To avoid any prohibitions on drinkable ethanol, you can use a denatured alcohol as a solvent. However, the most common denaturant is methanol, or wood alcohol, which you really want to avoid at all costs. A much safer alternative for dissolving shellac flakes is Behlen's Behcol, which is ethanol denatured with isobutanol. Another safer shellac is Zinsser Seal Coat, which is dewaxed shellac dissolved in ethanol denatured with isopropanol (rubbing alcohol). In some markets, Seal Coat may instead be labeled Zinsser B.I.N Clear Sealer. You don't want to drink isopropanol or isobutanol, because they will cause severe gastric distress, but when you are pregnant, drinking ethanol is not a good idea, either.

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#7

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

John in NM

First off, your table looks great! I like the dovetailed battens under the top - just beware of getting finish in there if they are supposed to allow the top to move seasonally. Depending on the design (say if they are fixed with a center screw and the rest floating) those are the parts that I would put a minimal finish (one coat) on and then maybe some wax.

The rest, well, I would use a brush and regular varnish of whatever type is available to you where you live. The reason is that you are planning to use a respirator, so I don't think you need to worry so much about fumes. Varnish fumes are pretty mild compared to a lot of the two part finishes the pros use in their sprayers.

A pre-mixed shellac is also a good choice if available in your area. Again, use the respirator if you have any concerns at all about fumes. Even pregnant, I think a respirator will provide sufficient protection to use either of these two materials.

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#8

Finishing is very labour intensive :-)

GolfSteve in Calgary

I would use wipe on Polyurethane (I like Deft, but any brand is probably OK), 3-5 coats should suffice,

or I would use Polymerized Tung Oil (the stuff Lee Valley sells), 5-7 coats to get a decent build and shine.

or I would spray shellac (local painting stores probably have access to denatured alcohol); assuming you have access to a decent fume hood or ventilated area,

or I would spray water based lacquer; assuming you have access to a decent fume hood or ventilated area,

If you wear a respirator properly there's very little exposure to fumes.

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#9

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

Jesse Cloud

I agree with Paul. Send it out. There's a lot of variation in how finishes are formulated in different places, hard to know just what solvents are used by the local factory.

I know several high end woodworkers who send most of their finishing work out. No shame in that.

Not a time to take a risk.

And, yes, its a very good looking table.

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#10

Another Possibilty

David Yoho

Jordan, it's a shame you have to work in such a cramped shop space :)

Here's a different option you might consider. Unless this table is to be used in a formal setting where surrounding furniture (dining room?) is finished with a hard topcoat finish and it must match, you could get away with a hand applied oil finish. I have that exact scenario in my own dining room where we purchased a very high end, hand-crafted cherry table and sideboard. I made the Queen Anne-styled chairs and finished them with stain from the manufacturer, Watco Oil, and paste wax. Today you can't tell the difference between what we bought and the chairs. They all look as if they came together.

The beauty part of an oil finish is it's easy to apply, easy to repair, and can later be top coated with many choices of harder finishes if desired. Probably the biggest down side to an oil finish is its resistance to spills. However, if you care for it properly I don't think that would be a major issue.

An oil finish is thin and it takes many coats before it begins to build. It will always look "in the wood" and not so much "on the wood". However, you can achieve a nice sheen this way and following it up with a good paste wax will add to it. I've heard other woodworkers say an oil finish looks "muddy". I can't say I've experienced that the times I've used oil. Maybe I'm doing something different, I don't know!!

As long as you wear proper finishing gloves to protect against the finish getting into your skin and a respirator for the fumes, you should be fine. You'll also want to dispose of any rags you use in a proper manner to avoid a fire from spontaneous combustion issues. The easiest way is to either put them in an approved air tight container or simply drop them in a bucket of water before discarding them later.

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#11

Oil on beech?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have no experience oiling a light colored wood. My guess is that it would turn an ugly yellow brown with age. Anybody with experience with oil on a light colored wood?

The finishing suggestions offered have for the most part overlooked that it is beech that is being finished. The finish I have seen on this wood has had the objective of keeping it light and naturally colored. Hence, the finish must not be colored or age to a color. A blond shellac or water based non-yellowing finish seem to me best for this application. Any shop as well equipped as the one in the picture is going to know where to get these finishes.

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#12

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Soap and water.....

Jesper, Denmark

Mix up a strong solution of soap flakes in warm water and wipe on the table several times. This does not discolor the wood, but protects it against spills, so you can dispense with the glass plate.

It won't get shiny, but will get a nice sheen.

The method is hundreds of years old, but still favored here for both tables in light colored woods and floors.

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#13

I've heard of a variation of that one...

John in NM

Used on lime plasters - rubbed soap without the water (or at least with very little water). Supposed to make the plaster waterproof due to the hydrophilic end of the soap molecule bonding to the plaster leaving the oil loving other end of the soap hanging out to repell water.

I never knew a similar technique was used on wood though, pretty neat.

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#14

Re: Oil on beech?

Barry Irby

Is American Beech identical to European Beech? Which is this? If they are different, does the European version have the same negative characteristics as the American version?

A friend has some beech furniture and its finished with some sort of very blond (lacquer?) finish. there are a few spots on ti where the finish appears to have "blistered". Spots the size of a fingernail that popped off the surface. Makes me think surface prep would be very important.

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#15

Kneale Brownson

Does vegetable oil count, Bill?

Kneale Brownson

We have a kitchen with a worktop made of 2X6 beech and 2X2 walnut that gets a bath of hot vegetable oil every few years. Wife does a lot of dough rolling on it. The beech is very slightly darkened but has not yellowed.

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#16

Re: Oil on beech?

Howard Acheson

>>>> Is American Beech identical to European Beech?

No, American beech is a wood known to wiggle all around with changes in relative humidity.

European beech is the wood very frequently used when making woodworking benches. It's more stable than it's American cousin.

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#17

Re: Oil on beech?

William Duffield

Most antique wooden moulding planes were made from beech, and oiled with linseed oil. Mine are not an ugly yellow brown; they are a deep rich brown, which I find very pleasing. My new moulding planes, treated the same way, are not ugly, either, but are much lighter in color, but tan, not white. It will be many years before the wood and oil oxidize to the color of the old ones. While not furniture, they should age the same way.

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#18

Jesper, Denmark

Re: I've heard of a variation of that one...

Jesper, Denmark

My house was built in around 1923. The floors are tongue and groove pine in full 17 foot lengths in the living room. They have never been treated with anything else. Maybe they have been covered with throw-rugs at times, but never varnished.

Biggest concern is that the whole house was built with fresh sawn lumber, so shrinkage gaps in the floors. The structure itself is full brick, so only the flooring and the roof structure is wood.

Incidentally, the flooring joists are 6 x 6 pine on sorta 3 foot centers. Basement ceiling 1" planks with 4 inches of clay on top as insulation and lath and plaster underneath. Now replaced with vapor barrier and Roxul.

Do I need to tell you that shoveling that clay through a small basement window was not a fun job?

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#19

I wouldn't take any chances with chemicals

Dick Coers

of any kind. I'd pay for someone else to put on the finish. Nice job!

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

#20

Re: Non-toxic finish for Beech table

joe mohnike

As you can tell woodworkers are the friendliest people. You might see if there is a woodworking club in your area. You might be able to have one of them do the finish for you at your place, it could also be a learning experience for you.