Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Need help identifying a tree

Posts

Need help identifying a tree

#1

Need help identifying a tree

Craig Spacek

With all the recent storms in Texas I was able to harvest a small amount of lumber in Austin from a damaged tree but I don't know what kind of tree it is. I'm guessing it is some sort of hickory or ash but I'm not able to find a match in my tree guide. Can anyone help me figure this out with these pictures?

Thanks,

Craig






Re: Need help identifying a tree

#2

Re: Need help identifying a tree

John Veerkamp

wood looks a lot like pecan I got that was downed by hurricane Ike in Houston. however the leaves do look more like Hickory. Don't think it is Ash.

Re: Need help identifying a tree

#3

Re: Need help identifying a tree

Yonak

On the other hand, it does look like ash to me, in the wood, the bark and the leaves.

Re: Need help identifying a tree

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: Need help identifying a tree

Dale Lenz

Ash has opposite branching and usually a diamond pattern bark. Could not be sure from your pictures of opposite branching and your bark picture was to close to see a pattern. Ash would be my guess at this point??

Re: Need help identifying a tree

#5

Re: Need help identifying a tree

Curt Stivison

I vote for ash.

Re: Need help identifying a tree

#6

Re: Need help identifying a tree

John K Jordan

Eliminate guesses. Cut a small section. With a razor blade, make a smooth slice across the grain. What you see with a 10x magnifier can be compared with photos on-line or on Hoadley's book "Identifying Wood."

The Hoadley book is invaluable for those interested in wood. Without my copy I would do a lot of guessing.

JKJ

Re: Need help identifying a tree

#7

Re: Need help identifying a tree

Craig Spacek

Thanks for everyone's input. As soon as I can get back to where the wood is stacked and drying I'll take a look at the end grain with a loupe and see if i can match it to something. I'll start with ash.

Craig

Re: Need help identifying a tree

#8

Trees and wood ID

John K Jordan

You are more fortunate than most since you have the leaves and bark. At first glance, the trunk and leaves don't look like what I thought ash should look like but I don't have my tree library handy and don't have ash in my woods so I can't comment intelligently on that. There are plenty of on-line tree id references. This one seems to describe the characteristics distinguishing ash from other species:

http://treedoctor.anr.msu.edu/ash/ashtree_id.html

The Wood Database has some info and photos on many species. They list info on ash species. They have an article on distinguishing different types of ash:

http://www.wood-database.com/wood-articles/ash-wood-black-white-and-everything-in-between/

As for indenifying just from the wood, it can be tricky. Hoadley first teaches what to look for then takes you through a decision tree, first seperating by porosity. Keep in mind there can be huge variations in appearance of ring, pore, color, and grain even within the same tree. Some things are pretty consistent, though, like the approximate number of earlywood pore rows, the width and appearance of rays, and the configuration of latewood pores. I also use a uv light for some species. For example, I use a UV light which causes some species, like black locust, to fluoresce distinctively. Good clean fun!

Oh, if the budget hasn't been slashed the US government will id up to 5 samples of wood per citizen per year. It may take weeks to get an answer. Years ago a forum member here has a question like yours and sent me a piece and sent one to the government. 1o minutes after I looked at her sample I wrote back "elm" (elm has a very distinctive latewood pore structure). Some weeks later she got a letter from the lab with one word: "elm". Yea!

Here is the link:

http://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/research/centers/woodanatomy/wood_idfactsheet.php

JKJ

Re: Need help identifying a tree

#9

Re: Need help identifying a tree

Don Orr

JKJ has the best solution for positive ID. To me it does not have the normal growth habit of Ash which is commonly a straight single stem. It could easily be Box Elder (Acer negundo) which is sometimes called Ash Leaved Maple. Not all box elders have red stains in the wood and they often grow like in the photo with multiple stems and outwardly resemble ash trees. The slice of wood does complicate the ID because it resembles a more porous wood than BE. Up here in the Northeast they are weed trees to me.

Any chance it sould be Butternut?

There are several species of Hickory, of which Pecan is a member. That's a possiblity. I'm not familiar with other southern trees.

Re: Need help identifying a tree

#10

Leaf Snap

Tom Dunlap

Find the app called Leaf Snap

Then take a leaf, put it on a light colored background and snap a picture Leafsnap will guess for you and give you results

Re: Need help identifying a tree

#11

Re: Leaf Snap

Keith Newton

Thanks Tom, I had heard of this, but hadn't gotten around to loading it until just now.

However, after only a brief look, I have to wonder how good, and or thorough it is. When I looked at the alphabetical index, there were only 11 listings starting with W, and under Oak, only about 21-2. We have more than that in my home state.

And then just giving a quick check on something familiar like Post Oak, Quercus stellata, I'm afraid they chose a poor example to show for that species. That is not to say there wouldn't be a single leaf on a tree like the one shown, but I would call it atypical, in my opinion.

Re: Need help identifying a tree

#12

Ash

Martin S.

If it has opposite branching, it is an ash.

Maples, (no) Ashes (probably) Dogwoods (no) Caprifoleaceae (no) Bignoniaceae (no) and Horse chestnuts (no) all have opposite branches.

It is not a pecan, based on the leaf.

My best bet, based on the pics, is ash. I'd have to see a leaf scar to tell green ash from white ash.

Of course, you don't have to listen to me, but I do have a BS and MS in Forestry from SFASU.

Having said that, I have mis-identified trees before, so I could be wrong.