I am installing a n all stainless steel shower. I would like to build a removable pallet of sorts, out of either cedar or redwood. I know how I want to build it but I am wondering about the finishing. I intend to pre-finish all the parts with 4 coats of the epiffane varnish, except I would like to leave the part that you actually stand on either raw or maybe a coat of oil. Because I like the idea of the "sauna" look. However I do wonder about the long term effect of soap & dirt. If I have to varnish all of it I will in order to keep the fresh color.
You want to make a redwood or cedar floor for a shower and keep it redwood (cedar) color. I'm not sure that it can be done in the long term. Here is a photo of redwood used as a platform partly exposed outdoors. Originally had two coats of urethane in April 2014. Sun, salt air, lotions, soap pretty much got the better of it. The redwood stands firm, but the finish was ineffectual in seashore conditions. Maybe others had better results.
If I was doing that, I would build it simply and cheaply. Considering all the body hair, soap scum, and shampoo residue, I'd throw it away fairly often. I guess I could power wash it a couple of times, but if you building it with slats, it's going to be tough to clean.
Mike, If I were doing this, I would use CPES, which was developed to repair rotten wood in areas which are really hard or expensive to replace, but it will penetrate soft woods pretty readily, and fortify the wood however deep it penetrates, making it less absorbent to water than it would have been without it.
I used it on come Eastern Redcedar, Juniperus virginiana, for a work island about a year and a half ago down at my cabin. That wood would be too soft to use for a work top, but after wetting it good with this, it feels as hard and looks as rich as cocobolo, and still has the red, pink, and golden hues that it had when freshly cut, while the legs and drawer fronts have faded on down to more of a tobacco color.
It is expensive, but I only used one wetting, then lightly sanded with 320, then wiped on a coat of Minwax poly. It ended up looking like about 8 coats of wipe on, but I feel it really is a lot better than any of those. I don't mind paying more for something that saves a lot of time. Plus being down in the wood, it won't suffer the same problems of finishes designed to form a film over the top, especially as they age and loose their flexibility, or effectiveness from a ding.
I got what I've been using from Jamestown Distributing, but they have more recently been pushing the Total Boat brand, which seems more economical, and environmentally friendly. However I have not been able to find any independent test to compare these products.
Bill Tindall, have you had any dealings with these finishing products?
Maybe I have some data that would explain a few things. I tried CPES and it made a great solid piece of wood with an tough finish. Unfortunately, I chose to use it on outdoor furniture. The New Mexico high desert UV rays tore it up.
Boats need something with good UV resistance. Maybe thats why Johnstown Marine backed off. And yes, you can get additives for UV resistance - now I know.
And happily, UV is probably not a problem in your shower.
The "Sauna" look is unfinished - traditionally pine. A sauna does not get the soap etc. as you would get in a shower, so not a problem in that application.
I still think that you should leave it unfinished, as any type of finish will eventually fail under shower conditions. The purpose is slip-resistant, which fits the unfinished scenario. When it gets too cruddy with soap scum etc., take it out and power wash it and put it back.
It occurs to me I've seen this sort of thing made on TV. Unless you are fighting a budget for the materials, using a wood like Ipe might be a better choice. This way you wouldn't need to worry about a finish at all. When it needs cleaning, just remove it and power wash it.
Thanks everyone. I've heard about something like those wood hardeners, I was told they are some kind of nano technology?? I had thought about Ipe & I might just switch to that. I built an Ipe deck 10 years ago & used no finish & of course it's grey now. I might still be inclined to put oil or something on it because it looks so great when wet?
might be worth considering. It hit the market several years ago with a big splash, but I haven't seen much on it lately. You would have to do a search to see what is available.
I agree I don't want to slip on it. Maybe sand with only 36 grit? Or knurl (texture) the wood somehow. Maybe drill a bunch of small (1/8") holes & glue in rubber spheres. Actually I think there is something out there like 220 grit with an adhesive back you can put on a ceramic tub.
You won't have slipping problems if it's slats, maybe splinters but not slipping.
I often put a stippled texture on pistol grips that is pretty easy to do. If you want to try something like that I'll lend you some of the older tools I made for it that I don't use any more - one is a hammer like tool and the other goes in a Dremel vibro-engraver.
Any kind of texture will just gum up with soap scum though and be a cleaning nightmare.
The more I think about your design challenge here, the more I think I would go with some kind of resin impregnated wood or plan on frequent replacement if it were in my hands to decide. YMMV, but any way you cut it this is a tough one.