Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

How to smoke a brisket?

Posts

How to smoke a brisket?

#1

How to smoke a brisket?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have smoked many pork shoulders successfully but my one attempt at brisket left it dry and bland.

If there is a Texan (or similar) out there that will share the secret to Texas smoked brisket I would be most grateful. Now that it is the price of Porterhouse steak I don't want to risk screwing up another.

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

#2

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

ronster

Texan here. You can find great online and detailed help on this. I've done this a lot and have a great brick & steel set-up, so I can highlight a few things. Indirect heat is important in TX (firebox to the side). Watching temps is crucial for newbies (elders can feel doneness). I run my fire to achieve about 250 in the cooking area. Shooting for 190 internal temp on the brisket to call it done. Wrap in HD alum wrap at 180. Otherwise, minimal handling. Start fat side up and leave it alone at best you can. I'm referring to a full brisket and not just a flat.

Haven't done one in a year. Crazy prices.

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

#3

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

Jerry White

Another Texan here. I used to do briskets quite often, but haven't done one in a long time. I echo Ronster's advice......long and slow cooking over indirect heat with the fat side up. Takes about 6 to 8 hours, if I remember correctly. If you try to cook it too fast you will end up with a dry and tough piece of meat.

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

#4

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

Tom Dunlap

With REALLY big papers!

Old Cheech N Chong humor...hehehhehe!

Tom

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

#5

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

Jerry White

Bill, check your email.

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

#6

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

First, trim off MOST of the fat cap, but not all. The last brisket I did went from 17 lbs to 13 lbs when I did this.

Brine it overnight--look online, but apple cider vinegar, salt and water are the main ingredients.

Indirect heat of about 250ºF (I normally don't smoke this high, but the brine raises the boiling point of the juices), for about 1 hour per pound. Wrap it in foil after an internal temp of about 190ºF, and let it sit for 30 minutes before cutting. There is often a temperature "hangup" at about 160ºF--keep going, it's not done--you need the higher temp to break down the tough parts of the meat.

This will result in juicy, fall-apart, melt-in-your-mouth brisket.

Jason

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

#7

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

Robb Carr

I do briskets about once a month and have never had one come out dry - I use a Brinkmann smoker the kind that puts a pan of water between the fire and meat. I just put it on the rack and replenish the charcoal fire every 60 minutes or so until it's done. I don't turn the meat or brine or mop or anything... leave the hood closed and just let it smoke! I smoke a lot of stuff; ducks, ear corn, ribs and are always very pleased with the results.

There are probably better smokers out there and the Brikmann is cheap I think it as like $50 bucks when I got it (30+ years ago), but I can't imagine the results being much better.

I know some people try to use a Webber kettle and place a pan of water in the middle and build their fire around it, with the meat over the pan and they seem happy with the results, but I can tell a difference, the Brinkmann consistently produces juicer and more smoke favor.

Now, some say you can 'smoke' on a gas grill by making an aluminum foil packet of saw dust or chips. But, in my opinion you're better off putting the meat in the oven, because that's about what it will taste like coming off a gas grill!

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

#8

Smoking begins at 6 AM

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Thanks to everyone for their secrets. I will be trying an experiment. Will explain when I see how it turns out.

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

#9

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

Clay & Jennifer

Good advice from all. I wrap the meat in butcher paper after a few hours. Aluminum foil holds all the steam in and makes the meat soggy. The meat will heat a temp plateau at 165 for several hours. That's normal. The water in the meat is being released which keeps the temp from rising. I am a native son of the Republic of Texas and have run lot of brisket through my smoker.

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

#10

So how did it turn out?


Re: How to smoke a brisket?

#11

Report of experiment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This was an experiment. True brisket has become trendy and locally it is as high priced as boneless rib eye. So I thought I would try smoking a 5 lb compact chunk of choice chuck roast, which unfortunately had been well trimmed. However, chuck roast has internal fat that could simulate brisket.

Smoked at about 220 for 6 hours with a combination of cherry and hickory (what I had). Removed at internal temperature of 180 and rested one hour. . It had a nice crust but would have benefited from the surface fat that had been trimmed (we bought it for a pot roast so the smoking was an after thought). I think I prefer the taste of just Cherry but more research is needed on that point.

To my surprise it was tough. Not too tough to easily eat but not "falling off the bone" tender like my pork shoulders are when they are smoked. Given the choice I would prefer spending the effort on a pork shoulder. But I came to the same conclusion when I smoked a true brisket in the past. I don't get that falling off the bone tenderness I encounter at a TX BBQ place.

So, whether an untrimmed large chunk of chuck roast can be substituted for brisket remains to be investigated by someone better at smoking brisket.

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

#12

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I would guess

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...that your roast would have benefited from a higher smoking temperature. Tough cuts of meat need the higher temps to get broken down, and while a good steak is done at about 140ºF, a brisket needs to get to 190ºF. Otherwise, I almost always smoke everything else at about 200-220ºF.

Jason

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

#13

Re: Report of experiment

ClayFoster

Beef with a lot of connective tissue has to be cooked low and slow. Just because it's done doesn't mean it's tender. A thermometer is helpful, but but it only tells when the meat is at a certain temp, not when it's tender. I usually smoke a brisket 12-15 hours. It takes a long time for the collagen to dissolve into flavor.

One consequence of low and slow can be too much exposure to smoke, which causes a creosote flavor to sneak in. That's one reason I wrap the meat in butcher paper after about 5 hours. The paper also keeps most of the moisture in without steaming the meat like foil would.

The first time I smoked a brisket after moving to Indiana, my Hoosier wife asked me what time I would start cooking so the brisket would be done by 7 in the evening for our guests. I told her I would start about 5. She didn't know that meant AM until the clock alarm went off at 4 AM.

Re: How to smoke a brisket?

#16

Followup report- Mexican BBQ

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For lunch today I thin sliced some of the smoked chuck roast, heated it up with some sauce and rolled it in a tortilla. Yum. Yesterday I thought the experiment ok and worthy of further experiment but today I declared a success as fixed for lunch.