Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

Posts

Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#1

Got LED Lights?  Got EMI?

Barry Irby

I know some of you have installed LED lights. I have been looking for some to replace aging failing florescents. Now I am reading about Electro-Magnetic Interference particularly with AM radios. Some of the reading indicates that as they change the transformers and get the switching faster they will interfere with FM reception.

I have found that when I drive through at a local McDonald's that just upgraded their outside lighting my radio goes to static until I pull away.

So, any of you have any experience with EMI from those new fangled lights? Wonder if it affects other stuff like computers?

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#2

Why LED lights

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What is the advantage of replacing either T12 or T8 with an LED fixture, other than trendy?

Advantages of a currently installed T12 or T8:

1.It's already installed

2. If it is not working a new ballast will upgrade the fixture to an electronic ballast that does not flicker, is more efficient and provides more light. It takes a few gray wire nuts, a wire stripper and screw driver to complete the task in less than 10 min.

3. Either a T12 of T8 will make more light and isn't that what it is all about?

4. One can get any quality and color of light they want by selecting the optimum lamp for the fixture.

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#3

Re: Why LED lights

Paul in NJ

I just replaced two 8 foot fluorescent fixtures with three 4 foot led fixtures from Costco. I am very happy with the quality and quantity of light they provide. I am not able to measure lumens but they sit side by side with other existing fluorescent fixtures and seem to be brighter and cast more light. They use slightly less energy. As my existing fluorescent tubes burn out, I will replace the other fixtures. My older fixtures have magnetic ballasts that are noisy. A quality electronic ballast costs more than a new led fixture so it is a no brainer for me to replace with led. It seems like I have to replace fluorescent tubes every six months or so and I have to take them somewhere special to dispose of them. Ever break one of them? Small glass shards everywhere and is the dust toxic with mercury? I am sold on led.

I have not experienced EMI when listening to Pandora or music generated from my phone to the stereo.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#4

Re: Why LED lights

Barry Irby

The two fixtures I am eyeballing are 8' two tube models. Have not done the research, but I am not sure T-8 bulbs are available with the single post ends or the electronic ballasts. Also the bulbs are somewhat hard to change so the long life of the LED's is appealing. I was looking at buying the fixtures cheap at a freight auction. We go to an auction about once month and they come up fairly often. Cheap and next generation technology was just too appealing to pass up. Trying to modernize here and get past that stagnant ancient technology. After this I am going to work on indoor plumbing.

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#5

PS....

Barry Irby

I got some electronic ballasts at the same auctions (cheap) and have been changing out my shop lights to T-8's. Most of the lights were junked fixtures scavenged over the years from various houses I was flipping or whatever. Did I mention I am cheap?

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#6

Modernizing

Yonak

Good move on the indoor plumbing, Barry. We recently upgraded and we've never looked back.

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#7

Re: Got LED Lights?  Got EMI?

John McGaw

I've not experienced any EMI, at least not any that I've noticed. I have a few enclosed LED fixtures, a dozen or so LED lights in other fixtures, and many meters of LED tape installed in various places. If there was one I'd expect to emit EMI is the tape setup in the library cabinets since those are fairly high-powered and have a RF-controlled remote dimmer on them. But, like I wrote, no detectable EMI.

I did, several years back, have a CFL bulb that caused intermittent static but it failed completely in pretty short order curing the problem permanently.

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#8

Here's the thing about next generation tech...

John in NM

8 tracks and betamax were once the next generation technology :D

Personally, I think LED lighting will stick around and CFL's are going the way of the Dodo bird. I've yet to meet anyone who likes CFL's, just people who believe they should like them. LED's on the other hand are seen by many as pretty amazing tech.

To answer your original question, I believe that the reason power lines and fluorescent lights interfere with AM and not FM has to do with frequency - FM is 2-3 orders of magnitude higher frequency. The interfering multiples of low frequency emission do get up to high frequencies, but usually they are weaker the higher they get.

Eventually it is possible that lighting technology emissions will interfere with phone and computer communications, which these days are significantly higher frequency than an FM radio. When is anyone's guess.

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#9

FM vs AM

Jerry Nicholson

Besides being higher in frequency, FM (Frequency Modulation) receivers respond only to deviations in frequency and reject changes in amplitude. One of the selling points of FM in the first place, in addition to wider frequency response, was its inherent rejection of atmospheric static and other sources of interference.

Of course a very high level of interference can overload even an FM receiver, especially a cheaply made unit.

Jerry

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#10

Re: Got LED Lights?  Got EMI?

Dave Bair

I have a 12-volt LED flashlight that came with my cordless drill. If I point it at my radio, it will create static in both the AM and FM bands. It will not affect the radio if the light is directed elsewhere. It is a really cheap radio that's old enough to have a tape player rather a CD player.

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#11

Re: Why LED lights

TomD

In what sense more efficient?

I installed track LEDs in my parent's kitchen where once they have a double fluro. Anywhere I have ever lived has too little light by most standards, never a lighting plan, so these kinds of systems are pretty basic. The amount of light was great, the watts consumed 24, the light is directional, any time you want more you slide on another module, the lights can be dimmed. Supposed to last 10s of thousands of hours between changes on the bulbs, the bulbs cost about 4 dollars each. Not easily shattered, many, many more options in the look. The look aspect is particularly true because the manufacturers are starting to make fixtures without replaceable bulbs due to endurance limits like 25K hrs. So they can mold them in about any shape you want.

Installing the whole unit was two wire nuts, and one outboard screw on the track. I forget what I had to do, because I remember there was some clever thing required to get it mounted, but can't remember what I did.

LEDS are going to change the way we, live. I hate to say it, but people aren't going to bother turning lights off, if they ever did.

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#12

Re: Got LED Lights?  Got EMI?

TomD

Eventually will we have transformers in every lightbulb, or will we get a different form of supply? I kinda wonder what they are doing in china, because they sure sell a lot of lightbulbs without transformers, and a lot of remote transformers.

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#13

Re: Got LED Lights?  Got EMI?

walta

When I search “LED RFI” or “LED EMI” lost of the links are 2 or 3 years old.

I do not thing you will have a problem with current products.

I would like to see a YouTube video of Dave’s flashlight and radio any RFI should not be very directional.

Walta

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#14

Re: Got LED Lights?  Got EMI?

John K Jordan

I have one recent LED bulb in a std base over my lathe that has so much EMI that one electronic caliper is unusable closer than about 3 ft. Other lights, no problem. Other calipers, no problem. Maybe both are out of spec.

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#15

Every solution has its problems

Barry Irby

LED lights just seemed like such a winner. Very efficient, good light, very long lived. Just did not expect this step backwards.

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#16

Re: Every solution has its problems

Bruce Mack

I have 2 Costco overhead LED lights as well as 2 LED task lights. Often all are on. No problem with shop FM radio.

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#17

Re: Got LED Lights?  Got EMI?

John McGaw

Since digital calipers (at least the ones I've looked at) use optical encoding to determine their position it could be that your particular LED bulb is emitting pulses of light at a switching frequency which is able to jam the caliper's optical detectors. The detectors are internal but there might be leakage. It might be educational to simply block the light from the bulb from reaching the calipers to see what happens to the interference. Even reorienting the calipers might change the situation.

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#18

Re: Got LED Lights?  Got EMI?

John in NM

Though there is no date given on this article, it does explain the phenomena pretty well and gives some handy graphics of the broadband emission of some products. As I understand it, the higher quality LED lamps (and thus more expensive) do not cause as many problems due to more effort going into proper filtering.

I noticed yesterday that some of the semi trucks I passed on the highway interfered with the FM radio too.

Re: Got LED Lights? Got EMI?

#19

Re: Got LED Lights?  Got EMI?

Alex Grigoriev

Digital calipers use capacitive sensors, with very low power consumption, always active. Optical sensors would take more power, because the tracking is always on in the calipers.