Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Less than perfect DT's

Posts

Less than perfect DT's

#1

Less than perfect DT's

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Yesterday, my wife and I wondered around an antique mall in Medina, Ohio. Although we only live about 25 minutes away from this place and have passed it many many times over the years, we'd never gone in. The place is huge, clean, and well lit.

Medina Antique Mall If you are ever in the neighborhood.

I came across this piece that was labeled "All original Pennsylvania Hepplewhite 4 Drawer Chest - Cherry and Walnut. ca. 1790-1810". I'm no expert at identifying woods by any stretch but it looked like Cherry and Maple to me. At any rate, I liked the look of it. It's very similar to a chest we have now.


Like a lot of you guys probably do, I pulled the drawers out to have a look at the DT's. I expected them to not be perfect works of art, and they weren't. They were nicely done, tight and so on, but not works of art. I expect they were done for functionality and purpose opposed to looks.


Why am I posting this? I don't know other than whenever I look at antiques anymore I always recall the conversations here on WC about DT's and whether or not way back when were they cut for looks or functionality.

Most of the furniture in my house has been handed down from my mother and/or father and other family. As well as pieces my wife and I have purchased over the years. Except for a few exceptions, none of the DT's are perfect. Or what today we expect DT's to look like; perfectly spaced laid out pins and tails cut with great accuracy.

I suspect a lot of what we (my wife and I) have is what was considered 'working class' furniture. Not high end stuff. I've never seen in person high end stuff like a Phiily highboy or something. But I just think the contrast of perfect DT's and working DT's is interesting.

This chest was $650 btw. It was pretty nice (in my eye).

Re: Less than perfect DT's

#2

Re: Less than perfect DT's

Steve Schoene

Just a note. While this might not be the highest example of the cabinetmakers art, such pieces are still not "working man's" furniture. I'd suspect from looking at studies of estate inventories such pieces would have been made for a member of at least the top 20% of the wealth distribution.

Re: Less than perfect DT's

#3

It used to be that dovetails ......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

were put there to hold something together. Given that this chest of drawers lasted nicely for 200 years I would say that the maker was successful and with luck he/she spent little enough time making them that they could buy food and pay the rent with the income.

Today dovetails are used to flaunt the maker's dovetail making ability. It gives me great delight to spot a tidied up dovetail in a piece of studio furniture, an imperfection that would not have bothered someone making a chest of drawers in 1790. And, unlike the chest of drawers you saw that was likely bought by a middle classes person in need of a place to put his socks, the modern studio equivalent would be priced at $5000 and almost no one could afford it.

My wife's father was an insurance salesman. Most of the furniture in their house(mahogany) was made by a local shop. The point is that a small shop in Utica NY could make furniture that middle class people could afford. The dovetails are functional. If it didn't show it was not refined. Now days if you want an affordable place to put your socks you need to make it yourself.

Re: Less than perfect DT's

#4

Re: Less than perfect DT's

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Interesting point.

Thank you.

Re: Less than perfect DT's

#5

Re: It used to be that dovetails ......

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"Today dovetails are used to flaunt the maker's dovetail making ability."

I was thinking of you and your views on this subject when I was looking at this.

Thanks.

Re: Less than perfect DT's

#6

Re: It used to be that dovetails ......

TomD

True in the woodcentral world but not true in the art furniture world.

1) The whole exposed joinery, look at my joints! thing comes from the design schools that emphasized the idea of revealed structure in buildings and so forth, an industrial look where the mechanical aspect of buildings was emphasized. By the way, this is deep into the past probably edging into 100 year old thinking, not exactly some new fad. I am not even sure that while we have a very good woodworking program at some of the art schools around here, where one would have to go to see that kind of furniture, it was around during the 80s, but I don't see it as much these days, or even many handwork galleries. The point is that it is a design issue not an execution issue. The people buying 4 thousand dollar make-up tables in ebony and pear, think they are getting a master craftsman's work already, they wouldn't know what to look for. As Bill points out, sometimes you can slip woodfiller past them.

2) If you know what you are doing, the really good DTs are a nothing. Pros don't worry about difficulty, that is what being a pro is about. Now bill is correct that you can find wildly designed (or I should say I did back when I looked at that stuff in the 80s but it may still be true), fancy studio furniture where the guy goofed the exposed joints and did an artful job of pasting them over. But not too many people last in that business, they eventually learn you can make twice the profit from a set of railway tie steps for a track house and they only take 45 minutes to make, and they drift off. A lot of that stuff is the student's first attempt at making it after design school, and he quickly learns you have to be very fortunate to make it in that world.

3) Those dovetails look pretty good to me they are tight, and they are the narrow type that in it's day was a form of showing off one's ability, though it was faster to do in some respects. There are the saw cuts that overshoot, but those did not save time in the making. On the front, if you overshoot, you could be said to be saving time in chopping ouot the pins. But it is wasted motion on the tails.

4) Overall they look like well cut joints probably made by an apprentice, or some other lower in the pecking order individual.

5) Though this is a nice piece, it is nowhere near the top of the pile (I'm no expert might well be in the top 20 percent), and the top in the US is nowhere near the top in europe. As Bill points out, stuff was made locally which further fragments the authority one can invest in any on piece. Let's say it was made in Picton Ontario, do we then know that was the standard that applied across the whole new world? This stuff was barely a step above stuff that comes in a flat pack today, though based on their technology and organization.

Re: Less than perfect DT's

#7

Clint Searl

DT's are highly overrated


Re: Less than perfect DT's

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

actually...

Jack Guzman from Maine

In my opinion those are some pretty near perfect dovetails.I always look at the dovetails when checking out furniture . What I am used to finding on old stuff looks pretty rough.---Jack

Re: Less than perfect DT's

#9

A theory and a question

Jesse Cloud

First, the theory. The fit is actually pretty tight, the only thing thats off about the tails is the overcut. Strangely, the overcut is pretty consistent. My bet would be that the guy who was making the drawer fronts and the guy who was making the sides had a miscommunication. :\

Now the question. The wood on the sides seems very rough, almost battered. Is this just age or some unusual wear or environment?

Re: Less than perfect DT's

#10

I find over cut common

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It just is a quicker way to make them. In that day it was all about get a reliable drawer assembled with the least labor. I have a 1850 drawer that looks just like it.

Re: Less than perfect DT's

#11

a comparison

Gary Smyth

A comparison example. Three drawer pine hall table sold as 1820 to 1850. Utilitarian.

Re: Less than perfect DT's

#12

It appears to me that he used a hand-saw

Keith Newton

Maybe the drawer was too tight after making, so maybe the maker, or someone later flipped it over, and used a hand-saw to skim off some of the front, and side.

Why they wouldn't have used a plane beats me, but that is what those marks look like to me.

Re: Less than perfect DT's

#13

Re: Overshoot sawcuts

Alex Grigoriev

I think the cuts were made by eye, and then the depth was marked with a gauge on waste only. This is why they are overshot.

Re: Less than perfect DT's

#14

Re: Overshoot sawcuts

TomD

What is interesting is some have it and others don't.

Re: Less than perfect DT's

#15

Re: I find over cut common

TomD

How is it quicker. Sounds like saying running on the outside of the track is faster than running on the inside. I do agree they had other priorities, and they may not have cared about this, but these are way overshot on a few of them and not on all, so where exactly where they saving the time? The other thing is he nailed the hard part and goofed the easy part, which is somewhat a practical approach, at leas this priorities were correct, but with that skill he could have wasted less time driving past the exit.

Re: Less than perfect DT's

#16

Re: Less than perfect DT's

John McGaw

There are obviously two different beasts involved here: the dovetail as stable strong joinery technique and dovetails (and joinery in general) in a time when they are seen as an important part of the "art" of furniture. In the 19th century the joints on a utilitarian piece were just there to do a job and nobody was going to study them as long as they worked.

We had a presentation at the guild meeting last night by Gary Rawlins of Asheville, NC where he talked about his design process and how he developed his own style for his very high-priced furniture. As part of the show-and-tell he passed around a couple of tiny drawers (scale from my hand) to show his typical drawer construction.


Clearly these dovetails are going to last but they surely go above and beyond when it comes to joinery required for a tiny drawer. They are "art". Me, I quite unashamedly use my Leigh jig whenever I need a precise joint.