Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Loss of Thickness Allowance for Rough Lumber

Posts

Loss of Thickness Allowance for Rough Lumber

#1

Loss of Thickness Allowance for Rough Lumber

don stephan

Wondering how much allowance others make when buying rough lumber. My experience when getting rough lumber from a reputable mill is that I seldom will lose 1/4" when making rough lumber up to about 42" in length flat and straight, surfaces parallel. But when I need flat and straight pieces between 42" and 8' or so, I often lose between 1/4" and 3/8" when making flat and straight, surfaces parallel. It's frustrating to remove more thickness, but less so than having to throw out lumber because it wasn't yet flat and straight parallel and now too thin.

Re: Loss of Thickness Allowance for Rough Lumber

#2

Re: Loss of Thickness Allowance for Rough Lumber

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

If you need to remove a quarter from four quarter stock to achieve S2S, either the lumber you are buying is a lower grade than you should be choosing for building furniture, or you have misidentified your dealer as reputable. I expect most of the boards I buy to end up at 7/8 and all at 13/16 or thicker, even at 8' or longer. If I do find a board with enough cup or twist that it won't yield 3/4, I won't turn it into chips and then throw out the reminder. A much more effective strategy is to examine it closely before making the first pass over the jointer, and if it won't yield long, wide 3/4 boards, I'll cut it appropriately to yield shorter and/or narrower boards that are 3/4 or more. A secondary strategy is to make wider, thinner boards for things like drawer sides (where 5/8 or 1/2 is often sufficient, depending on the scale of the drawers). You have to have immediate and continual access to your detailed working cut list, winding sticks, thickness gauge and a pencil whenever you are dimensioning lumber, and check one against the other at every step.

Re: Loss of Thickness Allowance for Rough Lumber

#3

The answer depends......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

on what you are doing with the lumber. For example, if I was making a 7' table I would not flatten the lumber on a jointer. I would plane it to thickness and count on it being sufficiently flexible to squish flat in the clamps. If I was making a screen door and needed 2 pieces 7' for the frame I would rummage through a stack and find something already nearly dead flat. As far as straightening edges one does what one has to do. We figured 25% waste when making flooring in long lengths.

In any case your dealer and grade has nothing to do with your issue of straightening and flattening. In a 1000 bdft pack of lumber there are going to be pieces that did interesting things when they dried. The main market for this lumber knows how to accommodate these twists and wiggles so they are not considered defects by the mills putting up these packs for sale. When one works hardwood lumber one has to learn to deal with this natural product and its normal variance.

Re: Loss of Thickness Allowance for Rough Lumber

#4

Re: Loss of Thickness Allowance for Rough Lumber

Robert

Lumber is sized as it comes off the mill and what we buy after drying is different.

What I mean is a 4/4 board may actually be 7/8" thick when you get it home, leaving only 1/16 on each side to mill to nominal 3/4 thickness. When you buy s3s or s4s lumber its even worse you usually have a 13/16 thick board, leaving essentially nothing to make up for.

If I was making a table top I would get 5/4 lumber. This will usually mean I'm getting a 1 to 1 1/8" thick board, leaving enough room for planing flat. I not, then you have to pick through and choose the straightest boards you can find (and store them properly when you get them home).

I generally am quite picky when choosing wood for a top or long boards, and I try to accomodate the yard by choosing a few "not so straight" boards for shorter parts. Oh, and I let them know this when I'm picking through. They really don't like people going through and skimming off the cream.

Re: Loss of Thickness Allowance for Rough Lumber

#5

Lumber thickness correction

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

4/4 lumber is typically sawed at 1 1/8", though I have seen it slightly less on a highly accurate mill where there is less risk of a thin miscut. After drying it will be an inch thick or slightly more. 5/4 lumber is sawed at 1 3/8".

Re: Loss of Thickness Allowance for Rough Lumber

#6

Dale Lenz

Ask my sawyer to

Dale Lenz

cut my lumber 1-1/8" Works well for me.

Re: Loss of Thickness Allowance for Rough Lumber

#7

Re: Loss of Thickness Allowance for Rough Lumber

Steve Jenkins

I've been buying hardwood lumber in the rough for over 30years and can't recall ever getting it thinner than the specified thickness. 4/4, 5/4,8/4 etc.