Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Chair Repair

Posts

Chair Repair

#1

Chair Repair

Tom Minehan

I have been asked to repair a "collapsed" dining room chair. The chair is the typical dovetail construction. The joints were not broken nor glue starved. Whatever kind of glue was used apparently failed and the joints loosened and came apart (those not loose, easily came apart with a slight mallet blow). I have the joints cleaned up and the chair dry fit together. My question is "What type of glue should I use now? Epoxy?

Re: Chair Repair

#2

Re: Chair Repair

Stuart Johnson

If they are tight you might want to consider hide glue.

Re: Chair Repair

#3

Re: Chair Repair

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Dovetails are not a typical joinery method for chairs. Quality chairs much more often, and more appropriately, use mortise and tenon construction.

How old is the chair, and how many more generations do the owners want it to survive? What were the abuses the chair was subjected to, that caused the glue failure? How many times has it been repaired in the past? What are the characteristics of the failed glue? What methods and materials did you use to clean out the joints?

If you use nails, or pocket screws, or epoxy, or polyurethane, or unibond, or aliphatic resin to rejoin it, this will likely be the last time it will be repaired. The next time it fails (and it will), it will be curb furniture, or the excess cost to mke the repair will be excessive. There are many good reasons that museum conservators and antique furniture restoration experts will only use hide glue on valuable antique chairs.

http://www.workbenchdiary.com/2014/02/eleven-reasons-to-use-animal-hide-glue.html

I just drove 4-1/2 hours with my furniture repair kit, in case I need to do some repair and restoration on some antiques at my son's house. The only glue I brought with me is Old Brown Glue.

Re: Chair Repair

#4

Re: Chair Repair

Tom Minehan

Thanks for the replies. The chair is not an antique but part of an 8 chair dining room set about 10 yrs. old. I meant to say mortise & tenon construction. It says "Made in Thailand" on the bottom. The owner states that the chair was not abused and other chairs in the set got "wobbly" but did not collapse. He put an angle bracket on the bottom to stabilize them. I suspect all the chairs may have a glue problem. The current hardened glue is brown in color. The only thing I did was to scrape the old glue off the tenon's and out of the corresponding holes and reassemble. My concern was what glue to use on hardened glue? I will try the hide glue as you guys have suggested.

Re: Chair Repair

#5

Do a test

David Yoho

You say the glue was brown in color. This doesn't have to mean it was hide glue but the way to test if it is would be to lightly wet it and then use your finger to see if it feels sticky or tacky. If so, it's hide glue. Otherwise, it's not.

Re: Chair Repair

#6

Re: Chair Repair

Jesse Cloud

Another complication is that if the chairs were made in Thailand, they were made to fit in close to 100% humidity. The fit is now probably much looser. You may need to shim the tenons to achieve a snug fit.

I used to work for the State Department and it was a common problem amongst people returning from third world posts. They bought furniture which looked great there, but cracked or collapsed soon after coming to the states where humidity is more variable.

Consider wooden brackets screwed between stretchers under the seat, a traditional practice. Its what keeps cheap furniture together in the U.S.

Re: Chair Repair

#7

Re: Chair Repair

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

If the original glue is hide glue (as per David's test), you can reconstitute and reactivate what is there already by just adding more hide glue. If however, it is something else, you are wise to remove as much as possible before trying to reglue, while being carefull to minimize the removal of the wood itself. If shrinkage or glue removal (or even sloppy original joinery) has loosened the joints, it is relatively easy to shim the tenons with veneer and hide glue until the joints are snug again. Optimum snugness is when you can assemble and disassemble them with hand pressure, but they don't fall apart due to gravity when you hold the joint by one component.

Re: Chair Repair

#8

Re: Chair Repair

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have repaired several old (not precious antiques) chairs in the last 50 years. I will not use any glue except hide glue. Chairs are probably the worst application for wood. The stresses that chairs see when "scooted" away from the table with 100 to 200 lbs on the seat are tremendous. Chairs are tipped onto 2 legs with weight on the seat, people "drop" onto chairs etc. etc..

This means that almost, if not all chairs will loosen over time. When a chair is glued with hide glue the normal failure mode is the joint will "break" loose. (the same failure mode will occur with any other adhesive). However with hide glue the repair is both easy and if done properly the repaired chair is as good as new. As far as I know no other adhesive will bond to old adhesive and maintain any permanent strength. Hide glue will "re-wet and dissolve" the old glue (regardless of age) and form a bond as strong as the original.

This means a chair repaired with hide glue can be repaired innumerable times without issue. To repair, first test as above to determine if the original glue is hide glue. If the original glue is not hide glue, clean off ALL of the old glue. If it is all you have to do is remove any loose glue and derbies. Then test fit the joint, if it is "loose", either use veneer or plane off a thin shaving from a scrap of wood, apply glue to the tenon or loose area of the dovetail, wrap the shaving around the tenon or insert into the dovetail and let dry for an hour or two.

Then try fitting the joint, if it is still loose add another layer of material as above. When it is too tight, sand, rasp or file off any excess material until the joint fits with hand pressure, apply hide glue to the joint and clamp in place.

You have now made an easily repaired joint as strong as the original joint, the chair will be useable forever if future repairs are made as you just did.

Re: Chair Repair

#9

Re: Chair Repair

Jim O'Connor

In the past year I was asked to repair some stools of Asian origin. They were made with round tenons and mortises. The socket part was tapered due to the wear and wobble. they had been glued with a white, stickey type glue. I shimmed the tenons with shavings to fit, used hide glue and advised the owner when they came loose again to throw them in the fireplace. If they weren't made with hide glue in the first place they don't have much value in my opinion.

Re: Chair Repair

#10

Re: Chair Repair

Joseph Mulherin, sr

There is a scientist lady on YouTube recently who has done an exam on just how well all of the glues stand up to her exam. Good viewing for any who might be interested.

Titebond 2 came out best....253 lbs.

Re: Chair Repair

#11

Re: Chair Repair

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Just went back and viewed it again....and it seems that the plywood she used broke first in almost every test rather than the glue itself. Take it for what it is worth....

Re: Chair Repair

#12

Re: Chair Repair

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Yes, Titebond in all its iterations is a fine adhesive. BUT, it can't be repaired like hide glue because new Titebond (or any aliphatic glue) doesn't adhere to itself like hide glue does.