Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

OT - New vehicle?

Posts

OT - New vehicle?

#1

JL

OT - New vehicle?

JL

After many years of service (and 180K+ miles) it has come time for me to retire my Subaru Forester.

I am contemplating getting rid of my old F250 also. I rarely drive it as it gets only 10 mpg.

My thoughts were to get a vehicle that had a reasonable towing capacity (2000 lbs or more). I need 4WD. I would like to have reasonable (25 mpg or greater) gas mileage.

My current thoughts are a Subaru Outback (AWD, 2700 lbs towing capacity, 25-32 mpg) or a Ford Escape (4WD, 2000 lbs towing capacity, 21-28 mpg).

Not really interested in a Jeep. The value isn't really there.

Re: OT - New vehicle?

#2

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT - New vehicle?

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

I sure like my Subaru Outback! Current one (my third) is a 2011, with just 60K miles so far. The others both had well over a 100K on them when sold.

In all that time - and mileage - I've NEVER had to do a repair. I am religious about keeping up on the maintenance, including brakes, tires, etc.

My 2011 2.5 Ltd averages about 25mpg around town and 30 or so on trips. Best I've done is 33.3 mpg on a 600 mile flatland trip. Hills, of course, would lower than somewhat...

Re: OT - New vehicle?

#3

Re: OT - New vehicle?

John McGaw

I'd vote for the Subie. I, too, ditched my remarkably unreliable Dodge truck, got rid of a car and bought a 2008 Outback and a trailer. I've not had anything that I couldn't handle with the combination and I figure, if I did, I could rent a heavy vehicle for occasional hauling use and still come out way ahead. I only wish that mine got the sort of mileage you quote. Whenever I get above 22mpg average on my normal routine I am in the mood to celebrate.

Re: OT - New vehicle?

#4

Re: OT - New vehicle?

Jesse Cloud

Well, this is turning into a love fest for Subaru. And I'll all for that.

We sold our Outback at 205K and I think it think had many more miles left it in. Now have a Forester that just hit 100K. Only repair ever was to fix wires that had been gnawed by rodents (totally an outdoor car in the sticks).

Next car is very likely to be a Subaru, probably an outback. We take a lot of long road trips these days and I think the ride on an Outback is smoother.

I sprung for a 4wd Toyota Tacoma pickup, but always take the Subaru if the weather is bad. ;)

Re: OT - New vehicle?

#5

Re: OT - New vehicle?

Joseph Mulherin, sr

I bought a 2001 Subie Forester last year in

feb. that had 232,022 miles on it. Have driven it for about 6,500 miles in one year and still am getting about 22mpg in city and about 23.5 on highway.

Sent in oil to Blackstone Labortories in Fort Wayne, IN to get an analysis; report came back stated that engine is good for many more miles with out any problems noticeable. Cost $25.00 for report.

Had to do some minor body repairs, spray painted when finished, looks like new. Rides like a dream and hugs the road like a beetle.

Re: OT - New vehicle?

#6

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Lafayette thanks y'all...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...as you're all helping keep my friends and neighbors employed! The Outback and Legacy are produced about 10 minutes' drive from my house.

Jason

Re: OT - New vehicle?

#7

Another vote for Subie

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

My wife is on her second Subaru Forester. Great little cars.

If I recall correctly, the Escape is made by Mazda, or a joint venture with Mazda and Ford, can't remember. So...

Re: OT - New vehicle?

#8

Re: Lafayette thanks y'all...

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Jason, I used to live in Lafayette from 1941 till 1965. Went to Jefferson High when it was on Brown street & ninth street. Graduated in 1952.

Re: OT - New vehicle?

#9

Another Outback vote


Re: OT - New vehicle?

#10

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT - New vehicle?

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

John,

My 2008 didn't get all that great gas mileage, either. The 2011 does much better. I think the CVT has a lot to do with it.

Re: OT - New vehicle?

#11

Subie outback

paul in AZ

My two year old Outback has the 4 cyl. and gets as much as 32mpg in the city. Plenty of power -the 6 cyl. is not necessary.

Stop and go traffic eats gas and the A/C cuts a good 4mpg off the mileage.

Overall no complaints about fuel economy.

My son has a 6 cyl. and gets 16-18mpg. But thats in Boston traffic and he has a lead foot.

I only wish they offered two wheel drive. All wheel costs gas mileage and is of no use at all in southern Arizona. I like the CVT.

Re: OT - New vehicle?

#12

Outback Towing Capacity...

Mike Circo

Love my 2013 Outback. I would do it again in a second.

But be sure to get all the details on towing capacity. The 2700 lb stated may be only for the 6 cylinder version, and then it requires trailer brakes. Watch the marketing vs. engineering statements. I'm sure it will tow the amount stated, you just have to fulfill the special conditions to do it.

I drove the Ford Escape when shopping cars and found it much smaller than the Outback. The stat you have to watch for is that passenger and cargo capacities are given in "cubic feet". Therefore that number includes height. The Escape is tall but short-bedded and narrow compared to the Outback. So unless you stack your grocery bags three high, or buy 3 foot lumber sections and pile it up, or carry rear seat passengers that are 7 feet tall, the stated sizes are false economies. (Just something I noticed)