Best Template material?
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
What is a good material to use to make templates, say for a foot pattern? It needs to be easily sawed and shaped by file, etc. without fuzzing up and hold a crisp pattern edge.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Best Template material?
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
What is a good material to use to make templates, say for a foot pattern? It needs to be easily sawed and shaped by file, etc. without fuzzing up and hold a crisp pattern edge.
Re: Best Template material?
William Duffield
There are tradeoffs with any template material. Some people recommend tempered hardboard. I've used baltic birch plywood, lexan, lauan doorskin, cherry, mahogany and other hardwoods, but I think I prefer aircraft plywood and Finnish birch.
Re: Best Template material?
Terry in Edmonton
As well if the template is going to be used many times I will use 1/4" MDF covered on both sides with laminate. This will give a template that doesn't seem to ever loose it's sharp edge.
Re: Best Template material?
Barry Irby
Also, you can use the phenolic sheets they make router table plates out of.
And there's always aluminum and steel.
Part of it depends on how many cycles you want. The tempered hard board mentioned above has worked well for me and is "nearly permanent" in my shop where a few dozen cycles is a lot. If I were going for a really heavy duty one I might take the suggestion of laminating both sides or a piece of 1/8" tempered had board.
Some of mine died of clumsiness before they actually wore out. Hitting one with the router bit still running (Cutting part) is never good. OTOH, a Steel one with trash the bit.
It also depends on the what is going to bear on it. A good bearing and one of larger diameter will help one last a long time. I ave used some where I ran the shank of the bit against the pattern. OK for a few uses and if you are gentle, but not good for many cycles. I have had the bearing fail in mid cycle and trash te pattern, probably because I was not paying enough attention.
The gentleness factor is important. If you are heavy handed, putting a lot of pressure on the pattern, they done last as long. If you sneak up on it or pre-cut the blank to where you are removing very little material they last longer.
The Finish or Baltic birch plywood does well because the nature of the plywood tends to cancel out grain patterns and the fact that side grain compress easier than end grain. Using a double thickness bearing spreads the load over more surface area and lasts longer and thicker plywood provides more surface area on the edge.
The required accuracy matters too. If you are making some free form shape where a few hundredths of an inch don't matter much you can make the pattern out of most anything. Or you may need a really accurate pattern that will keeps its shape and produce very accurate and repeatable copies.
Re: Best Template material?
John McGaw
I've always used tempered hardboard, mostly because it is cheap and there always seems to be some around the shop. If you were talking about something for heavy production use then it might not be the best choice.
Hadn't thought of phenolic
John in NM
That would be my choice for a heavy use template. Less durable than aluminum, but certainly good enough and much easier to work with. I may have to get some to try out.
Currently I use aluminum for router pattern templates.

Kinda scary, but sure is fast 
Re: Best Template material?
Yonak
This is a very valuable thread. Thank you for bringing it up. I have had to re-make several tracing templates over time and this gives me some ideas to make them more permanent. I especially like the laminate idea.
Re: Best Template material?
Jesse Cloud
I just use MDF, but the first thing I do with it is to make a couple of backups, also from MDF.
changing the emphasis on template property
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Replies have focused on choosing a template material that is durable. I should have called what I am interested in "Model-Template". I am most interested in a template material that is most easily shaped and the shape easily refined by filing and/or shaving. In my case I am usually designing a shape. When it is refined satisfactorily using it to trace a pattern for a leg or whatever. The requirement is easily shaped and durable enough to trace 4 legs or whatever.
I have almost no experience with MDF. Does it shave and file easily and leave a fuzzless result? The plastic laminate idea looks attractive for I know it files easily.
Re: changing the emphasis on template property
Paul in NJ
Bill,
I do the refining with a pencil and eraser, usually on poster board. It is easy to cut a a fair curve in it with scissors or a knife. If you are careful it will transfer an outline quite a few times. It does not have to be perfect. After you cut out the real object is when the refining and fairing really counts.
I think I have read Mary May the carver uses mylar drafting vellum. I used quite a bit of that in the stone age before CAD (computer aided drafting). You use a special plastic lead on it that is easy to erase but doesn't smear. The film is stiff but flexible. I am going to try it one of these days.
Paul Dzioba
Re: changing the emphasis on template property
AZ in Colorado Springs
I was going to ask what the purpose of the template would be and you already addressed that. I have a few patterns (as I think of them for tracing) made of hard board and the skin of an old interior door. Easy to cut to shape using a scroll saw (my patterns are not huge) followed with files and sandpaper to smooth the curves.