Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Polyurethane questions

Posts

Polyurethane questions

#1

Polyurethane questions

mdclor

Good morning to everyone! I have some Minwax Polycrilic WB poly in both satin and semi-gloss. I don't remember buying it or using it. I'm pretty sure it must pre-date 2008. The first question is how do I determine if it is still usable? (there is printing on the lid which I assume to be the lot number and maybe an expiration date, but the Spanish instructions were stuck to the lid mostly covering the printing :/) Secondly, will it, or any poly, stand up to hot coffee cups without any rings? TIA

Re: Polyurethane questions

#2

Re: Polyurethane questions

Hank Knight

If it's no good, it won't cure. Wipe some on a scrap and see if it cures over several hours. If it dries to the touch, appply a second coat and see what happens. If it's still tacky after 24 hours, throw it away.

Re: Polyurethane questions

#3

Re: Polyurethane questions

John in NM

I'd agree with Hank on this, except those water poly's dry much faster in my experience. Personally, I don't like them much, too many coats and they get this funny looking blue-white tinge to them.

As to whether they'll stand up to coffee cups, I don't know. My usual tactic is to use an oil poly or spar varnish (not like you can find that any more - it's all poly) and just touch it up over the years as needed.

I bet though, that a sprayed on conversion varnish would be the way to go. Something like the commercial factories use - I bet Bill can fill you in on all that. If I were making tables for sale, I would be using a pro finish on the tops if not the whole piece.

Re: Polyurethane questions

#4

Have you opened the cans yet?

Dick Coers

Old water based poly cans are often filled with rust if they are not filled to the rim. They got the coatings right on the inside of the cans, but often the rims corrode. I don't use coatings that old, not worth the chance of ruining the project. I'm no fan of that water based product either, I prefer General Finishes if I have to use water based.

Re: Polyurethane questions

#5

Re: Polyurethane questions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If it looks good it will be good. Latex finishes die by coagulating or getting viscous, or rusting the can(typical failure).

Will it stand up.....test it.

The solvent based urethane varnishes are durable to all sorts of attack. We wash our tables with soap and water and sometimes forget and set hot pans on them.

Again, in your case test it.

Personally I am not fond of the water based material appearance.

Re: Polyurethane questions

#6

There is no "cure" to these finishes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

After application the water evaporates, the mushy polymer balls left behind coalesce into a film, the coalescing solvent evaporates and that it. There is no chemistry involved, just evaporation. I don't know of any way they can't dry hard. They only way to make these finishes fail is for the mushy polymer balls to not coalesce. Application at too low temperature will cause this problem. In that case the "film" will be grainy/sandy.

Re: Polyurethane questions

#7

Re: Polyurethane questions

mdclor

Thanks for all the info. I tried the satin one on scrap and the first coat sanded to white powder after about a half hour. The can indicated waiting 2 hours. Then I applied a second coat and that seemed to be fine. I will apply one more coat then wait 24 hours and begin testing with various hot and cold beverages. So far, I have not been able to detect any hint of bluish tinge.

Re: Polyurethane questions

#8

Blue haze

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The old formulations dried to a film that scattered light. I am unsure what the scattering species or structure was in the film but what ever it was it was of a size and refractive index that scattered visible light. The blue light scatters more than the red end of the spectrum (which is why the sky is blue) so the scattering film looked bluish .

One can demonstrate this phenomena by shinning a bright focused beam of white light through a glass of milk. For the side where the light is scattered the light will appear blue and the transmitted beam will be red as can be seen by putting a white piece of paper on the other side of the glass from the light source. It is a good experiment to demonstrate why the sky is blue and the sun set is red. but I digress........the modern formulations don't seem to have this scattering material so they typically are not bluish. Never-the-less these water based finishes don't have the brightness of oil based finish.

Re: Polyurethane questions

#9

Re: Blue haze

Yonak

Bill, I'm on board with many of the advantages of oil based finishes over water-based. Is there a way to mitigate the yellowing effect of oil based finishes ?

Also, when you say water-based finishes don't have the "brightness" of oil based finishes, can you describe what you mean ? Do water-based finish obscure the features and character of the wood more ?

Re: Polyurethane questions

#10

answers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Is there a way to mitigate the yellowing effect of oil based finishes ? Some oils don't yellow as much as others. Some solvent based finishes don't yellow at all or very little. It all depends on what the polymers are that form the film. In the professional finishes that are sprayed I look for "water white" in the descriptor. That said, it is easier to come by a water white water based finish than a solvent based finish.

Also, when you say water-based finishes don't have the "brightness" of oil based finishes, can you describe what you mean ? Finish something nice like walnut or cherry and look at it in bright light. The water based finishes I have tried lack brightness. They look duller and more lifeless.

Re: Polyurethane questions

#11

Re: Polyurethane questions

TomD

I add amber to the blue ones until they warm, a little.

As far as I know there is plenty of spar varnish out there, but maybe not in the same stores. Try Z-spar captain's varnish. Try marine stores.

Re: Polyurethane questions

#12

Re: Polyurethane questions

TomD

You are not alone in that. I have used standard Valspar water, and warmed it with amber tint, and it is OK, but not outstanding, though I don't know if I was even shooting that high on the pieces in question.

One option you might try, if you had some need to use water, are the water based guitar finishes. I have gone back to lacquer, but a ton of work has gone into making those capable of selling 4K instruments, and those instruments sell on their finishes, probably more than their musical properties.

Re: Polyurethane questions

#13

Tinting....

John in NM

That's not a bad idea if one has to use the waterbased stuff. I even have some amber transtint I use for coloring paste epoxy.

Unfortunately, marine vendors are kinda thin in the Albuquerque area :D One paint store does sell a Sikkens spar, I should try that one day.

About 10 years ago Home Depot still sold a non poly spar varnish, though I don't really know what the oil used in it was. These days all the brands I've seen around are polyurethane spar varnishes - which is fine most of the time too.

Re: Polyurethane questions

#14

Re: Polyurethane questions

Alex Grigoriev

If you want warmer WB finish, try one of oil-modified WB poly. I'm using mostly ZarMax, but other brands also have that.