Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

Posts

Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#1

Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

Barry Irby

I may have recovered about $900 from a long lost account. Been working on that for about three years and its much too long a story to go into, but it may happen and feel like a windfall. Now, what to do with the money?????

I am considering a Domino. Any of you have one? Which size? Do you enjoy it? Is it better, faster or even equal to M & T joints? Would you buy it again? Or, do you have one and find it disappointing and would not buy it again?

I bought a plate jointer/biscuit cutter and find it gathers a lot of dust.

Would this be a good gift to myself?

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#2

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

GolfSteve in Calgary

If you're happy using loose tenons, there's no doubt it will cut mortises much faster and more accurately than cutting them by hand.

For example, I made a "kids" table out of some scrap maple. Cutting the joinery took about 15 minutes of set-up time and 5 minutes of actual cutting time.

For some reason I feel like it's cheating and on "fine" furniture I feel like I should use traditional tenons and the Domino sits there unused more than it should.

ps. you must connect the Domino to a shop vac.

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#3

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

TomD

I can't imagine anyone not being happy with it if they won it at a golf tournament. Rounded edge tenons are largely a bad thing, so if one was looking for a reason not to get one, it might be along those lines. Lower gluing surface area, and harder to form.

It is stupid overpriced though. So that only works out if one is commercial and can get the money back. For 900 bucks you could make a CNC that did the same thing and a lot more, or you could buy two milling machines, or one bridgeport. All it is, is a router that swings through an arc. There are wooden machines by Mathias on youtube, and there is a russian guy who made his own. And there is the hollow chisel mortiser, which is a superior tool in most respects.

I briefly looked at buying one, and the model I liked was the larger one, it covers a wider useful range. Apparently it has a much better fence, which is an issue with biscuit jointers, and this kind of deal.

One of the purported advantages for floating tenons is that any butt joint one can make can become an M&T joint, sort of. In that application epoxy bonded hardware is a lot stronger, cheaper, and more versatile. If one is "cheating" why choose an inferior cheat. Domino joints would be faster to do, but that is not a huge concern, and the huge range of possibilities with epoxy bonded hardware more than makes up for it. If one had the domino one could use it, but for a lot of people there are many apps where biscuits would work just as well; then there are the situations where real M&T is just as fast or faster; and then you get into the rocket science, and for the odd occasion when an amateur might use it there are superior options anyway. I could see the lifetime gotta have one joints in a personal shop come down to a few dozen. Ten there is the risk one drinks the Kool aid and goes all hand tools the following year.

If I live long enough for the price to go to chinese levels, I will buy one. Obviously there are many people for whom 1K is nothing. I kinda fall into that slot where tools alone are concerned. But this one isn't that essential, and there are other costs to having tools, like storage, and any ancilary jigs that take up space, stocking the different tenons, and so forth.

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#4

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

Eric

I have the small one and really like it.

That said I'm a mechanical engineer and if I could convince my wife I'd move to Germany just to work at Festool. A lot of it for me is that fact that I can afford one every once in a while and I get all excited (this is a family forum) at the level of engineering.

Do I need one? No. I have several alternatives for mortising but I think it make a strong enough joint and I like that all I need to do to produce quality m/t joiner is whip out what is essentially a biscuit cutter should be. Think about how many tools you need to produce a mortise and tenon joint with traditional mortises and tenons. Unless they are design elements (I love Greene and Greene.) I use the Domino.

Good luck in your decision.

Eric in Los Gatos

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#5

I wonder....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.....how long it will be before some competitor offers a similar tool for half the price?

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#6

Re: I wonder....

Joseph Mulherin, sr

If you have to without buying such an expensive, simply use your router with the appropriate bits.

Mark your edges of the holes, set your router bit depth for the individual domino , then rout out the hole to the proper depth on each board, then insert the dominoes in and glue up and align edges of boards finally.

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#7

Bart Goldberg

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

Bart Goldberg

I have the smaller unit and I love this tool. It got it in exchange for building a bar for my brother's kitchen. I'm not a production woodworker, just a amateur, so I don't look at tool purchases from a return on investment perspective. Regardless of price, Festool just makes great stuff. I have used mine several times and think its great joinery system.

Bart

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#8

Rick L

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

Rick L

http://youtu.be/2RQcClMWeh4

Horizontal slot mortiser is a better, simpler, cheaper option. I've been using slot mortisers for 35 years.

http://www.woodcentral.com/shots/shot390.shtml

http://www.woodcentral.com/

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/readarticle.pl?dir=powertools&file=articles_834.shtml

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#9

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

Jesse Cloud

OK Barry, I've been quiet for a while but you drew me out. There's nothing on this board that attracts more bull than a Domino thread...

First, the one thing I agree with is the statement that there's nothing the Domino does that can't be done with other tools, many of which you probably already have: routers or drill presses or mortising machines or slot mortises or chisels or ..... And that's an important caveat - it won't let you do anything that you can't already do.

It does, however, make floating tenons very fast and very accurately. I have most of those tools and I have worked on all the others mentioned. I have both the small and the large domino. I have made several hundred, maybe a thousand joints with the domino. Before I had the Domino I made many thousands with other methods. So I have a few clues about the issue.

So, here's some data, as Bill would say:

I have both sizes of the machine, most all of my usage is with the small one. I mostly make tables, desks, dressers, and chairs. If I were making an exterior door I would use the big one.

I have bought many Festools and sold a few a year or two later, always for 90 percent of what I paid. Festoons hold their value, so if you buy it and don't like it, you can sell it later and recoup most of your investment.

You can buy the tenons from Festool or make them yourself, using exactly the same technique you would use to make any other floating tenon in your shop.

Are they strong? Will I recently used the domino to make a delicate little nightstand with tapered legs. After I dry-fitted the thing, I got up on it and jumped up and down a few times (I weigh just short of 300 pounds). The joints were all still perfect and tight - before I even used any glue.

I sit on dining chairs made 8 years ago with small dominoes every night, never a creak out of them.

Personally, I hold tenons in no special reverence. If I need to make some, I want to do so in the fastest way I can make a good one. And one more thing, I don't understand why people think us hobbyists have all the time in the world. I'm retired, but I still have a life and can only work in a few hours a week for woodworking - so if I am going to turn out several interesting pieces a year, I need to work efficiently and make the best use of my time.

But, yes, the big caveat is that the Domino is a one trick pony. It does mortises, nothing else (though they will also sell you the tenons to fit). So if you do tenon work, its worth thinking about.

One more thing, following up on Bill's question, The Domino was first marketed in Europe about ten years ago, so the patent will expire in a few years. I suspect others will make similar tools then. Not sure they will be a lot cheaper. When Festool's track saw patent expired a few years ago DeWalt, Makita, and several others brought track saws to market. They were about $100 cheaper, not as accurate, and few were sold.

Hope some of this helps.

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#10

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

Jerry White

Jesse covered the subject very well. I will say that I have the smaller Domino. Bought it as soon as it hit the US market, and yes it cost a lot of money. However, I have never regretted buying it. It has proven to be my go to machine for joinery. I sold my biscuit jointer after purchasing the Domino due to lack of use and I'm not sure now that I want to keep my hollow chisel mortiser as I don't use it any more.

Barry, just in case you don't know; if you buy the Domino you can try it out for 30 days and return for a full refund if you are disappointed in the machine.

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#11

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

Richard McComas

I've had a domino for several years now. I also have a Felder Mortiser I bought sometime before the domino. I haven't touch the Felder since except for an occasional large mortise. The domino is faster for me to setup. If something were to happen to my domino I'd buy another.

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#12

Re: I wonder....  and some youtube

TomD

Depends how similar. The patent has about another 10 years to go, I don't have a specific date, I googled around, and that seems about what people are saying. The companies like Makita And DEwalt that jumped into the tracksaw market, didn't save enough money on the product to make waiting worth while. The marginal cost reduction wasn't worth the years of standing on the sidelines. Plus it would be reasonable to believe the Festool product was better. They are a quality manufacturer, and they aren't trying to squeeze their product into some patent loophole, they had the fat of the land to work with. In business situation showing up with a better solution 10-20 years before your competitors, is worth something. But yeah, someone will do it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=msFb8s79bWs

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fFYwtE3SeU8

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F0FpgdzR56c

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#13

Re: Speaking of which

TomD

I think you are right that if you make thousands of joints as an amateur that you are basically a professional, assuming we are talking about real joints. When I got my biscuit joiner 25 years ago or so. The first thing I did was make a bookcase out of curly maple, for VHS cassettes. The top shelf was dovetailed on, and 5 additional shelves were installed with biscuits. I had figured out how to install them in sets, so I would guess I put in at least 40 joints. I remember that the glue-up was... tense. So in a sense it paid for itself on the first job. Cost was 159 (still use it today), and it saved me the time cutting 40 joints that first day. However... I would have used some kind of fixed joinery on the bottom shelf, and then used turned wooden nibs for the rest, which would have required me to drill 16 shallow 5mm holes, and now that VHS is a thing of the past, I could adjust the shelves if I want to. In reality I would never have cut 40 M&Ts, and the shelf is as tight as the day I built it.

For the most part biscuits are not for making chairs, but one of my early projects was a a set of Krenov saw horses. Of course they went together in almost no time, and for 6 months supported the hull on my 24 foot sailboat as it was being built. I used 2 50 gal drums to support one end, and saw horses at the other. They supported the hull weight, and the weight of workers in the hull. A Krenov saw horse is not even as well supported as a bedside table, having only 2 legs, and no braces other than the joint itself. After about 15 years of heavy shop use, I had to re-glue a few of the joints. I would prefer to have used dominos, or real tenons would have been best. But the often underestimated bisuits are very strong indeed. No doubt there are situaions where biscuits are stronger than dominoes because they can be planted very near the edges of the stock, and they don't make as large, penetrating cuts.

Cost is really the main reason not to have a domino. I would have one even if I never used a floating tenon in a situation where a real tenon could be cut, except for cost. And for a lot of people the high cost of Festool stuff is part of the attraction.

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#14

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

William Duffield

I agree with Jesse (and Jerry and Richard), mostly. I also have both the DF500 and the DF700XL. If you can afford the larger machine, you can avoid buying the smaller, even for smaller projects, if you get a $70 after-market attachment for the larger machine, the Seneca Cutter Adapter:

http://www.senecawoodworking.com/products/rts-500-cutter-adapter-for-festool-df700

I, and many other users, find the DF700 a bit easier and more comfortable to use, and the locating pins are much more convenient than the ones on the DF500.

I will however argue that it is NOT a one trick pony. There are other applications for it other than run of the mill mortises. For example, with a simple attachment, I use it for shelf pin holes (the 4 mm and 5 mm tenons are a lot less expensive than shelf pins) and table top buttons.

I also sold my DeWalt biscuit cutter as soon as I got my first Domino, and have tried (but not very diligently) to sell the mortising attachment for my drill press.

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#15

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

Mark Nowicki

Barry:

I am going to jump into this as a Festool (their Canadian operations) hater.

I swore off buying Festool after my first and only purchase of one of their saws, so I can't comments on the utility of the Domino.

What effect not having a Domino is having on your woodworking output right now?

Mark

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#16

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

William Duffield

How could he know the effects of not having a Domino? Wouldn't you think he would need to try it out to find out whether using one would significantly increase his productivity, or reduce his error rate, or result in fewer joinery failures?

Of course, that was a rhetorical question. The next one is serious: What happened with your experience with your tracksaw? Festool USA and local dealer service in the US, in my experience, have been exemplary--not perfect, like Lee Valley's service, but as good as one could reasonably expect.

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#17

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

Barry Irby

I don't know what effect it is having. As William points out, I don't have one, so I don't know. I am speculating.

It seems to me that the way I cut M & T joints now is tedious. I have a hollow chisel attachment for my drill press and a tenon jig for my TS. Both work as well or better than I expected, but require certain amount of fiddling. Setting up the Drill Press requires a number of steps and eliminates using the drill press as a drill press. This process requires two completely different thought processes. Cutting mortises and cutting tenons. It seems to me the domino woudl allow you to basically have one thought process, cutting mortises, and would not tie up either the DP or the TS.

Also, I have a tiny shop and the Domino would not take up much or any room. If space and money were no object I might prefer some sort of dedicated floor model machines.

Festool machines appear somehow delicate to me and over priced. But, I have no first hand experience with any of them.

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#18

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

Mark Nowicki

I believe Barry is over 18 and he can speak (post) for himself.

It is not my style to make obsequious or critical posts about Festool or LeeValley.

I tend to express my pleasure or displeasure with my wallet, and in above mentioned cases, it is squeezed so tightly you can hear the pennies screaming.

Mark

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#19

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

Jesse Cloud

Two things:

Surprised to hear you say you feel Festools are delicate. Most of the Festool owners I know use them in their business and work them hard. I have mistreated my router and tracks for many years, cutting through nails and screws, dropping them on the concrete floor, etc. and no worries. The Domino just never gets into a situation where is it worked hard, though I often keep it running through a few dozen mortises at a time.

Secondly, I think you should get one in your hands and cut some joints. Woodcraft stores usually have a demo in the store and are happy to let you give it a try. There's probably someone in your area with a Domino that would let you give it a whirl. Maybe take them up on that 30 day no questions return policy.

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#20

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

Barry Irby

This is the sort of first hand info I was hoping for. Thanks. I did not say they WERE fragile, I said they APPEARED delicate. Glad to know they are rugged. I would hope they are tough, at the price they charge.

Good Idea on the WoodCraft Demo. I definitely will try that. Thanks for the idea.

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#21

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

Mark Nowicki

With a Domino you don't make mortise and tenon joints, you make loose tenon joints using ( as far as I know) proprietary tenons.

Other ways to achieve the same effect are:

-a router with a mortising jig, either homemade or purchased

-a bench top mortiser, if you have a work bench you have room for one

- Dowelmax or Jessem or others.

All of the above will achieve the same results as the Domino at a fraction of the price.

Expensive means different things to different people, and besides how people choose to spend their money is their business.

My experience with Festool track saw has been very good and with vacuum good.

The saw got stuck a few times with the blade in downward position and running at full speed. No plastic parts have fallen off. The twist to lock cord is a POS, finally, after it disconnected for the umpteenth time, I just forcefully twisted it into locked position (using slip joint pliers) and left it permanently attached.

On the vacuum I have had to repair the switched power outlet three times, it gets loose and it does not make contact with the prongs. It is (or was) cheaply built.

The Systainer cracked the first year I had it.

Festool had a major recall in Canada of some of their tools, if you are interested how it was handled, you can check out the Canadian woodworking forum.

Unfortunately, we don't have a Bob Marino in Canada, so we don't experience the same service as you do in the US.

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters

#22

Re: Question for Domino tool owners/lovers/haters *LINK*

Rick Christopherson

I normally refrain from posting advise whether someone should or shouldn't buy. So if anything I say sounds that way it is accidental.

The best gauge of how satisfied current users are is the used market. You don't find used Dominos up for sale very often, and when they do, they get snapped up pretty quick.

There are a lot of ways to make mortise and tenon joints, but most don't have the repeatable precision that Domino has. A sloppy tenon is not very effective. New users frequently complain that the tenons are too tight because they don't just slip in place. They don't immediately realize that this is something desirable, not a detriment.

If you do get one, don't just grab it and go. It may look like a biscuit joiner, but that level of precision means you need to re-train your habits from biscuit-use to be more precise too. It's the one tool that I emphatically tell even experienced woodworkers that they need to practice using before they go live on joinery.

I also recommend that you read my supplemental manual before you buy. It will give you some additional information that may help you make your decision.


http://www.waterfront-woods.com/festool/Domino_DF_500.pdf