OT-Kitchen/Bath flooring
JohnT
SWMBO decreed that the kitchen must be renovated. New flooring is required, and we will also be re-flooring the entry and bathroom.
The kitchen and entry are contiguous, so we will use the same material for these 2 rooms. Kitchen is a high traffic area. The bathroom is a separate project, and can be floored with a different material.
We've been looking at ceramic tile, but I'm reluctant to go this route due to:
1) Staining of grout/difficulty cleaning, especially in the bath; and
2) The loss of "floor to counter" height in the kitchen. I'm really tall, and if I lose another inch by adding backer board and ceramic tile to the floor, my counters will be too low.
We also looked at "Luxury" vinyl tile (Armstrong Alterna). Our local home interiors designer seemed really keen on this, and it looks really nice. Overall appearance is similar to ceramic tile, but it can be laid directly over the existing linoleum and won't add appreciably to the floor thickness. Also, we were told that if there was a flood (like in the bathroom), the tiles would lift off the adhesive, and we could dry the subfloor, re-apply the adhesive, and put them back down without damage. Severely damaged tiles (like from gouges) could be removed, replaced and re-grouted.
I'm leaning toward the Armstrong Alterna tile, since it seems like a win-win. But my wife has read online complaints about scratches and irreparable damage to the pattern with something as simple as a stone in someones shoe.
I'm not so keen on the material if it's going to be that fragile.
Does anyone have experience (good or bad) with the "Luxury Vinyl" (i.e Armstrong Alterna or equivalent)??
Thanks for any responses.
-John-



