Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

OT-Kitchen/Bath flooring

Posts

OT-Kitchen/Bath flooring

#1

OT-Kitchen/Bath flooring

JohnT

SWMBO decreed that the kitchen must be renovated. New flooring is required, and we will also be re-flooring the entry and bathroom.

The kitchen and entry are contiguous, so we will use the same material for these 2 rooms. Kitchen is a high traffic area. The bathroom is a separate project, and can be floored with a different material.

We've been looking at ceramic tile, but I'm reluctant to go this route due to:

1) Staining of grout/difficulty cleaning, especially in the bath; and

2) The loss of "floor to counter" height in the kitchen. I'm really tall, and if I lose another inch by adding backer board and ceramic tile to the floor, my counters will be too low.

We also looked at "Luxury" vinyl tile (Armstrong Alterna). Our local home interiors designer seemed really keen on this, and it looks really nice. Overall appearance is similar to ceramic tile, but it can be laid directly over the existing linoleum and won't add appreciably to the floor thickness. Also, we were told that if there was a flood (like in the bathroom), the tiles would lift off the adhesive, and we could dry the subfloor, re-apply the adhesive, and put them back down without damage. Severely damaged tiles (like from gouges) could be removed, replaced and re-grouted.

I'm leaning toward the Armstrong Alterna tile, since it seems like a win-win. But my wife has read online complaints about scratches and irreparable damage to the pattern with something as simple as a stone in someones shoe.

I'm not so keen on the material if it's going to be that fragile.

Does anyone have experience (good or bad) with the "Luxury Vinyl" (i.e Armstrong Alterna or equivalent)??

Thanks for any responses.

-John-

Re: OT-Kitchen/Bath flooring

#2

JL

Re: OT-Kitchen/Bath flooring

JL

A while back, I had vinyl tile installed in a portion of my basement (the portion that wasn't my shop).

I have not had any noticeable damage to the tile over the course of several years. It is next to my shop. While I do have a "door mat" (old carpet scraps) between the shop area and the rest of the basement, I don't always thoroughly wipe my feet. I can assure you that the cats definitely don't.

The product is an Armstrong tile, though I forget which one. I have the leftover tile in case of damage. The pattern we chose has shown no appreciable wear and we are quite happy with it.

Re: OT-Kitchen/Bath flooring

#3

Re: OT-Kitchen/Bath flooring

John McGaw

My good friends decided on the upscale vinyl tiles, the sort that is actually grouted, when they were having their new home's kitchen and breakfast area refitted before moving in. It looked good in the store and it looked good when it was put down but Nancy reports that it is a maintenance headache, never looks clean, and is easily damaged and stained. Overall she really regrets putting it in, especially given the high price.

Re: OT-Kitchen/Bath flooring

#4

Re: OT-Kitchen/Bath flooring

Bill Howatt

I have Permastone vinyl tile that has its own grout lines in an entrance hall. People often think it is ceramic.

It has been down about 9 years and still looks like new. However, in the winter we always have a carpet runner down from the doorway in. Around here this is most likely when sand from the walk is present (ice and snow season). For the same reason people have winter footwear and will take it off near the door. It dawned on me a while ago that we seem to be like the Japanese; people take their shoes off most times any time of year.

I was told by the vendor that a damaged tile can be removed, by heating IIRC, and replaced.

Our entrance leads into an engineered walnut hardwood floor and I am a lot more nervous about sand being tracked on it.

The pattern and color also determine how obvious any damage is. A mottled, marble-like pattern can hide a lot of minor damage.

Bill

Re: OT-Kitchen/Bath flooring

#5

Re: OT-Kitchen/Bath flooring

Chuck Jurvelin

Three years ago I remodeled our kitchen/dining area and hallway and used Armstrong Alterna and it has held up very well. I used the recommended acrylic grout and it looks just like ceramic tile except it is much warmer to walk on. This past January, I remodeled one of our bathrooms and again chose Alterna. It is easy to work with and looks great. Rather than score and snap, I used my table saw with a carbide blade to cut the tiles when necessary. If you use the acrylic grout, do a small area at a time and try to limit the grout spreading to the joints, not like you would with thinset. I am 100% satisfied and these are high traffic areas.

Re: OT-Kitchen/Bath flooring

#6

Re: OT-Kitchen/Bath flooring

DLCinSTL

We installed Armstrong Alterna tile in a small hall bath about eight months ago. I installed and grouted it myself. I grouted from "wall to wall", which makes for a very water resistant floor. The glue was as sticky as fly-paper and I used a 100-pound roller, as per mfg. instructions. We selected it over ceramic tile for the very reasons you have suggested. Visitors think it is real marble. Armstrong specifically warns about using "rubber-backed" throw-rugs, etc. because of discoloring of the tile. It can be scratched and damaged. I'm not sure I'll use it in the kitchen when the time comes. After all, there are times that appliances must be mover, plus there is heavier traffic use.

Re: OT-Kitchen/Bath flooring

#7

Re: OT-Kitchen/Bath flooring

Steve Schoene

Ceramic and particularly porcelain tile is very durable compared to vinyl. The solution to having to clean grout is to use epoxy grout. Modern versions are not more difficult to imply than regular grout. For advise see the John Bridge forum about tiling.