Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

OT- Countertops: Granite vs Quartz

Posts

OT- Countertops: Granite vs Quartz

#1

OT- Countertops:  Granite vs Quartz

JohnT

SWMBO has decreed that the kitchen must be renovated.

We've been looking at countertops (flooring will be a separate OT message...).

There are several varieties of Quartz that we have found and like the look. We also identified a Granite that we really like (assuming we can find enough slabs we like).

Price (including installation) is close enough between the two materials that we could go with either (although the prices vary quite a bit between dealers).

We'd like to know peoples real-life experiences with either quartz or granite. I am under the impression that granite needs to be sealed periodically, and is more prone to cracking if edges are stressed, or something heavy is dropped on them, and that Quartz is less heat resistant but easier to maintain.

Also, if anyone has ideas of what I SHOULD be asking the contractors as far as installation/hidden costs, etc. Kind of unsure why two dealers can have such different prices for the same square fee of the same material....

Thanks in advance for any replies.

-John-

Re: OT- Countertops: Granite vs Quartz

#2

Re: OT- Countertops:  Granite vs Quartz *LINK*

mdclor

John, just to kick this off, I will clear up the question about sealing granite. Different granite have different absorption qualities. We have had 2 different granite and not sealed either without any staining even after drops of red wine sat for a period of time. Read the info at the link for more info. Sorry, but I have no knowledge about quartz as a counter material. HTH


To seal or not to seal

Re: OT- Countertops: Granite vs Quartz

#3

I've had both...

John in NM

And would buy either one again, just based on the aesthetic requirements.

Granite does not need sealing, as it is not a reactive family of rocks. Marbles and travertines are carbonate rocks and will react with acidic foods and stain easily. That is where this tale comes from, and the granite vendors just repeat it to be on the safe side.

Many vendors sell 1.25" thick granite, which is unlikely to crack under normal use. Thinner granites could have problems in poorly supported applications, such as shelves or if there is no sub top on the cabinets.

I have not found the quartz material we have now to be heat sensitive. I suppose if you had a smoking hot frying pan you dropped onto the counter and left there, you might damage the resin matrix, but that's what it would take. Under normal cooking conditions I doubt any of the pans are hot enough to damage the stuff.

As to installation, the main thing is to try to design the kitchen to minimize seams as much as possible. The guy who comes out to do the template may not realize that fewer seams will be better (our last one did not). Sometimes there is not much that can be done that way but it is good to give it some thought first.

Re: OT- Countertops: Granite vs Quartz

#4

Re: I've had both...

Steve Schoene

The smoking skillet is a real risk. I have a friend who did pull such a skillet onto his quartz countertop and ended with unrepairable damage that force him to repair it. I also rather object to the marketing of "quartz", which is after all about 20% plastic resin, with quartz filler. (The figure the makers give is a by weight measure which skews the number. It's volume that determines whether the top would be damaged.

Re: OT- Countertops: Granite vs Quartz

#5

Dupont Zodiaq

Mike Farinella

We have had this for almost 6 years with absolutely NO problems. It is the successor to Corian. Will not stain and requires zero maintenance other than just wiping it down. !0 year warrantee too!

Re: OT- Countertops: Granite vs Quartz

#6

Marketing names

John in NM

I agree with you there, whether it's calling the sand composite material "quartz" or calling everything short of marble "granite".

Re: OT- Countertops: Granite vs Quartz

#7

Granite-what's in a name

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It would seem that any rock type that isn't marble is called "granite" when in fact most aren't. Fly by night rock installers may carry rock of various kinds that may be less sturdy than the rocks that quality places carry. We have a particularly high quality local place. When we were picking out rock ( a gneiss from India) we were shown the attributes of rock that would make it not readily fracture, stain etc.

Bottom line- given the huge number of rock compositions that get turned into counter tops no generalizations are useful. Buy what looks good from a quality installer.

Re: OT- Countertops: Granite vs Quartz

#8

Re: Granite-what's in a name

Barry Irby

I bought some "granite" for counter tops. It was interesting. Most of the places I checked with were run by Russians. I am still wondering what the connection is. Was told that most of the stone was mined in Brazil, shipped to China for cutting a polishing, and then sent here for sale as countertops. Was also told the reason the most colorful stuff with all the stripes and swirls in it was expensive was that it often fell apart along the swirl lines. To find highly varied stuff that was sound was rare. (I also assume that it is priced by popularity or desirability)

I know almost nothing about stone. The local granite is gray and crushed into gravel for roads and concrete. Cut and polished I think it woudl make a very good if nondescript countertop. I recognized gneiss as some sort of stone, but have no clue as to what it actually is. I think you are buying anything they can cut and polish.

Re: OT- Countertops: Granite vs Quartz

#9

Gneiss

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

As India is crashing into Asia it is mashing and folding the rocks at the interface, as well as pushing up the Himalayas. Mucht of the rock sold around here is gneiss from this source. It is swirly and will have garnet, feldspar and quartz crystals, more or less coarse, making up the rock. It can have other crystals as well. I have seen pieces with huge blue Kyanite crystals in spectacular patterns. Indeed Brazil does produce granite and there are dozens of other sources as well.

Re: OT- Countertops: Granite vs Quartz

#10

Re: Gneiss

Barry Irby

Its a matter of scale. The "standard" pieces seem to be about 9' by 11 or 12'. Huge compared to a sheet of plywood, but tiny compared to the Himalayas. They have started to slice the sheets so thin they have to add fiberglass reinforcing to the back. I am not a fan of stone countertops. Just have not been bitten by the bug. If I were buying it I would want the most outrageous patterns and swirls.

Re: OT- Countertops: Granite vs Quartz

#11

We have it here too

John in NM

In the Appalachians and many other mountain ranges.

Gneiss is usually a granitic rock that has been metamorphosed under both high temperature and moderate to high pressure. The minerals in the granite are remelted and recrystalize as larger versions of themselves, often with new minerals like the kyanite you mentioned that typically form under higher pressures than the minerals in granites.

It makes an attractive countertop or tile due to the large minerals and foliated texture.

Re: OT- Countertops: Granite vs Quartz

#12

What we had...

John in NM

Was solid black (gabbro or diabase) on cherry cabinets. I actually prefer more fine grained and uniform countertops so that you can see spills and stuff easily. The fantastic swirly rocks look nice, but tend to hide spills and debris.

Re: OT- Countertops: Granite vs Quartz

#13

Re: Silestone Quartz

DLCinSTL

I have friends that have approximately 10-years old Silestone brand quarts kitchen counter tops that still look like new. They say they are very easy to care for.

Re: OT- Countertops: Granite vs Quartz

#14

Re: Silestone Quartz ++

Bob Entwisle in NJ

We had Silestone countertops installed about 8-9 years ago and have been very happy with it. No problems.

Bob in NJ

Re: OT- Countertops: Granite vs Quartz

#15

Radon?

Alex Grigoriev

Was it certified for radon emission?

Re: OT- Countertops: Granite vs Quartz

#16

Tiny volume of rock...

John in NM

Radon is very much a trace byproduct of a trace element in granite, and only in the more felsic granites, so that black stuff I had or a swirly metamorphic rock won't produce much at all.

The figure I remember seeing is around 0.13 pCi/L, well below the figures quoted in articles designed to frighten the ignorant.