Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

Posts

Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#1

Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

don stephan

Recent discussion was interesting, but seemed to overlook one point. Picking some numbers out of the air, if the ideal pressure per square inch on a glue joint is 150, and a clamp can apply 3500 pounds of pressure, and that pressure were spread out evenly, that one clamp could apply 150 pounds per square inch over 23.3 square inches of joinery. Articles I've read before said clamping pressure spreads out at a 45 degree angle from the surface of the clamp pad.

Picture an edge joint between two pieces of pine 15" long, 3" wide, and 1" thick. The total surface area of the glue joint is 15 square inches, so a clamp providing 3500 pounds of total pressure is more than adequate, but only if the clamping pressure is applied uniformly to the entire 15 square inches. If the clamp is applied in the middle of the joint, and the pressure spreads out at a 45 degree angle, it is maximized over 6" of the joint. If the wood is somewhat flexible, like pine, little pressure might be applied to the joint at the two ends.

That is perhaps why many clamps are used on joints, or cauls to move the clamp pads away from the joint so the 45 degree spread reaches more of the joint.

The last article I read, in either FWW or PW, with pressure testing, said the limiting factor on how much clamping pressure was generated was hand strength of the woodworker, and that too much pressure could not be created by most woodworkers. Anyone have a cite for the article?

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#2

another myth to be busted

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't know how the force propagating at 45 degrees myth got started but it is easy to see that it is at best an estimate. How the force propagates from clamp face to joint depends on the stiffness of what is being clamped. Think of the extremes. If two sponges were clamped the force would not spread at all beyond the clamp face. If two pieces if infinitely stiff materials were clamped the force applied by the clamp face would extend to their ends. Wood of this or that stiffness/variety is somewhere between these extremes. Maybe 45 degrees seems to be a reasonable average.

The clamp and glue makers recommend a clamp every 12 to 14" for panel gluing. This recommendation would assume individual boards in the panel of at least 2-3" wide.

As far as the glue is concerned any pressure that doesn't deform the wood is acceptable. You can not "starve" a joint with any clamp pressure an individual can muster.

The most critical part of making a panel is accurate machining and complete wetting of both surfaces by glue after assembly. If these steps are successfully achieved, the clamp requirements are then easily achieved. Keep in mind that there is no downside to too many clamps or to much clamp pressure so long as the assembly is not buckling.

I have made temporary rub joints with yellow glue. In this case there is excellent contact and wetting and no clamp pressure. It always surprises me buy I usually see lots of wood failure when the joint is bashed apart.

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#3

It's easy to see how...

John in NM

It always was a rough rule of thumb, nothing more. A handy estimate for clamp placement.

Then lots of people start writing about stuff they do not understand, first in books and magazines, then on the internet. Oft repeated rules of thumb and estimates become hard and fast laws of physics, not because they pass even casual analysis, but because everyone says they are.

PT Barnum would have loved it :D

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#4

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

Ralph Lipeles

You use "pressure" to mean "pressure" and sometimes to mean "force". Pressure is force per unit area. Force is a number, similar to pounds, which is independent of the area involved.

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#5

Re: It's easy to see how...

Jesse Cloud

Way way back in the dark past when I worked as a lab asst in the metallurgy lab in a college, we were studying pressure and deformation using photo elasticity and other methods. Even in steel, the distribution of pressure was amazingly complex - no straight lines.

I would assume that wood works the same way, probably even more chaotically given grain directions and knots, etc.

Bottom line is that although the 45 degree assumption is only a rule of thumb, its probably a pretty good one. Way more practical than trying to actually figure out the precise answer for every glue up.

Having said this, on a complex chair leg lamination, I use at least 50 clamps.... :D

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#6

Re: I agee Bill, another issue is the glue

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

While I have followed this discussion with interest and some amusement at times. I have noticed that no one has mentioned the various types of glue. For centuries the Hot Hide glue has been successfully been used in many applications with the rubbing method only. Piano's come to mind and I am sure much 15th through the 18th century furniture that still exists were assembled without what we consider "adequate" clamping forces. I have and still occasionally use the old wooden clamps with the parallel jaws and the long reach. I doubt these could even approach the pressure exerted by my Bessy's, yet I have seen no evidence of failure in the joints I have assembled.

I grant you much of the older joinery was designed to hold without excessive force on the "glue" but panels were still glued up with individual boards and veneer applied without vacuum pumps.

Bill you have much more knowledge of the chemical and physical bonds

that adhere to the wood and also maintain the structural integrity of the glue itself. In nature many "joints" are made without any clamping force at all and have incredible adhesion, Barnacles are only one of the examples. What effects does the (woodworking types of) glue itself have on the clamping force required to achieve a strong joint?

We have fish glue, Hide glue, Yellow glue, Titebond 1, 2 and 3, Epoxy (many types), cyanoacrylic's, and I am sure many others.

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#7

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

Keith Newton

Well Don, While hand strength will present a limiting factor. Then if you look at the link I posted, the higher numbers were gained as the threaded shaft increased in diameter.

However, One of the major things which should be obvious, is the handle itself. Someone posted a pic of a slide-action clamp stating that it should be sufficient for most. It may be, but I would think that is the worse handle configuration of all.

If you kept the threads constant, then think of the handle strictly in terms of a lever, you start to see that huge gains are achieved with more length out from the center of rotation.

Let's start with the screw-driver type handle. First, it requires a good squeeze grip, as well as wrist rotation. When I was a lot younger, I really had great strength with both of these, but at my current age, my grip is probably half, and the rotation is quite painful from arthritis, so that is one thing to consider if you aren't there yet.

However, if that handle was a 1" diameter, this is a good starting point. If we doubled the D to 2", the same effort applied before should double the rotation pressure. If we put a cross T handle 4" long, we double that, but take away the wrist rotation action, then favor the thumb against the pivot / fulcrum, with the other fingers hooked around the cross-bar pulling. Around 4.5" is about where most consumer level clamps max out, which is about 8 ~ 9 times the starting sample, if all other parts were constant.

We can then double or quadruple those numbers with cheater bars or big channel-lock pliers, but doing that risk bending or breaking the casting which weren't designed to withstand. When I was looking at the charts in the link I provided before. They kept the acme thread constant, and I think the pitch probably stays the same even if the screw diameter doubles, but all the other parts were engineered heavier, and handles longer to achieve the highest numbers.

Just think of the handle in terms of mechanical advantage of a lever which can be determined by considering the balance of moments or torque, T, about the fulcrum, then multiply that by the screw leverage advantage.

"Give me a place to stand, and I shall move the Earth with it. Archimedes 3rd century BC.

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#8

Re: I agee Bill, another issue is the glue

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"What effects does the (woodworking types of) glue itself have on the clamping force required to achieve a strong joint?" I don't know.

If the glue is not a good gap filler the excess needs to be squeezed out of the joint. This criteria applies to any of the glues where water is a large fraction of the formulation- hide, yellow, white, etc.

The clamp brings the surfaces together, keeps them together and squeezes out excess glue. One just needs ample pressure to accomplish these tasks. I am not sure that the kind of glue would matter much.

Rubbing the rub joint squeezes out excess glue. Rub joints are often small (glue blocks for example) so it is not hard to get the surfaces together. No clamp necessary for yellow or hide glue.

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#9

A thought and an anecdote

AZ in Colorado Springs

As far as the rule of thumb for 45 degrees is concerned, it makes me think of "fall angle" for sand and other materials. You can't pile up sand as a cylinder, but it forms a cone instead. The sides of the cone are determined by the "fall angle," or the way the granules of the material hold together, and eventually slide down the side, forming a cone. The fall angle varies according to the material. I especially remember reading about this in something related to fence posts and mailbox posts. Turn the picture over, and fall angle shows how much force will be required to uproot a fence post or mailbox support, depending on: the material it's buried in (what kind of soil is in your yard), how deeply it's buried, and the width of the lump of concrete or whatever else might be affixed to the base of the post to anchor it. (The fall angle is important, because the post won't slide straight up, but will want to raise up the inverted pile of dirt.)

As it would pertain to woodworking, this concept would relate to the stiffness and dimensions of the boards in the glueup. If you are attaching edge banding to plywood shelves, the shelves are wide and stiff, but the edge banding is narrow, so even though its job will be to stiffen the playwood, it increases the requirement for clamps. (I'm currently working on such a project; I glue them up in pairs, with the edge banding next to edge banding, and the plywood shelves act as two large cauls. If you have an odd number of shelves to make, use one completed shelf as a caul for the last glue up.)

The anecdote: when gluing up panels with wider boards, say eight or ten inches wide, I'll position the clamps farther apart. But, if I decide to add a clamp in a space that's a bit wider than the rest (as in the clamps weren't spaced quite evenly) I'll see a little more glue squeezing out where that last clamp is applying force across the joint. Makes it seem that this is as much art as it is science, at least as we practice it in our woodshops.

Good discussion.

Andy

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#10

Pet Peeve!

Tony - Memphis

I used to work for a company producing performance valve train components. We didn't make valve springs, but we sold them. Everybody in the industry talked about spring pressure in lbs. Oh well.

I've never considered clampnig forces and don' really care! I clamp as hard as I can and use as many clamps as I have. No failures...yet. I'm a mechanical engineer, but some things ain't worth worrying about too much. I have had some pipe clamps slip on me and I've bowed some clamps.

Tony

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#11

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

My grandson, age 16 at the time, did a science fair project. Pine BORG lumber 1" x 4" was cut into 24" lengths. They were overlapped by 3" and glued with all the commercially available wood glues at the time. The joints were clamped while curing. This 45" long sandwich was supported by two concrete blocks. An empty paint can was placed over the joints. 16d common nails were added until the joints failed. The nails were counted for each joint failure. The Gorilla polyurethane joint required almost TWICE as many nails as any other to cause failure! The glue did not fail, the wood broke. He is now 22. I now use Gorilla glue whenever glue blowout is not a concern caused by expanding glue. It does make a mess.

Wood strength, glue, clamping pressure, clamping angle, # of clamps, additional hardware added to joint, can woodworkers win. Make a mistake in your project, try taking it apart to correct it, UGGH, does any of this really matter?

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#12

Clint Searl

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

Clint Searl

The myth that needs busting is the one calling for gobs of squeeze out and twenty tons of clamping.

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#13

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

Alex Grigoriev

All PVA-type wood glues are stronger than most wood (MUCH stronger than pine). Your GS did something wrong.

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#14

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Experiment was attended and supervised by his father, a professional cabinet maker. Weight of approximately 300 more nails to break the Gorilla joint. I don't believe that the results can be argued with! All the conditions were the same: amount of glue, pressure, wood species, concrete block distance, empty can, nails, curing time (4 days). All the wood came from the same boards purchased on the same date. Knots and other defects were eliminated as best as possible. This was not scientific, wood was not analyzed by any instruments, just by eye. Which instruments do you analyze your dimensional lumber with? Do you use micrometers, X-ray, specific gravity meters, hardness meters, moisture meters, sap density, or weight meters? The tests were repeated a week later with SYP instead of white wood( white wood could be mixed species), SAME RESULTS!

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#15

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

Alex Grigoriev

Were the surfaces jointed, or glued as sold?

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#16

Also, was that green or KD board?


Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#17

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

The wood was glued as sold with normal dimension lumber surface. The only thing that was significantly different in the test was brand(type) of glue. We are not talking about 5 to 10% improvement. Gorilla glue was nearly 100% better

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#18

You don't buy green at the borgs


Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#19

Re: You don't buy green at the borgs

Alex Grigoriev

You do buy green at borgs. Most DF 2*X lumber is sold green. 1x4 pine could be either rough lattice, or dimensioned KD pine (pretty smooth), you didn't say which. Even then, KD 1x4 is often cupped, and thus not suitable for gluing as is.

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#20

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

Alex Grigoriev

PVA glues are not gap-filling. They require that the mating surfaces were smooth enough to make a thin glue line. Polyurethane glue is gap-filling. But this is its only advantage. Also, if you have a dog, make sure to keep the PU glue well stowed away.

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

#21

Re: Clamping Pressure Over the Glue Joint

Steve Schoene

Polyurethane glue is not really gap filling. It foams up and looks like it is filling gaps, but that foam doesn't have strength.

In all the other comparisons I've seen the polyurethane glue has tested as being LESS strong than PVA glues. I can't explain the results presented earlier.

It's also clear that it is virtually impossible to over clamp a glue joint. More clamp pressure means a stronger joint, although joints generally get "strong enough" well before the maximum attainable joint strength. This has been studied by serious scientists and published in peer reviewed journals.