Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

Posts

A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

#1

A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

don stephan

A painter a few days ago asked if I could straighten the pieces of some stretcher frames he had purchased on the Internet. They looked like pine, had one or two tight knots in each pieces, and were both cupped and bowed. Did not take long to reach agreement that they were not suitable for expensive paintings.

We started talking about what might be the ideal wood for stretchers perhaps 36" by 30". He has seen many advertisements using poplar, which is a stable and very affordable wood, but not available quartersawn. I wondered about quartersawn red oak, which is likely more stable and resistant to bending in the same dimensions, but of course heavier.

Anyone have any experience with good quality stretchers for canvas and linen? I'm wondering what the ideal wood choices might be. Not sure how valuable it would be to peruse Internet ads given what he was sold.

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

#2

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

Stuart Johnson

I would be concerned about the tannin in Oak and the impact on the canvas.

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

#3

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

Keith Newton

Hey Don, Why do you think QS Poplar would better than plain sawn? I don't think you need to worry about that down on this level.

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

#4

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

Barry Irby

The few that I have actually looked at were made of "white wood". Probably something like whatever SPF framing lumber is. Spruce Pine Fir. Seems like you would want something straight grained, clear and quarter sawn or as its known in the softwood trade, vertical grain. Not sure the vertical grain or quarter sawn part is all that important in pieces this small.

Poplar would be excellent and you could have it quarter sawn or you could select some out of large stacks if you had access and permission. I have a thousand feet or more that is tree run and some of it is quartered, just by chance.

Oak would be excellent too but heavy. Maybe you could route some grooves in it to reduce the weight. Turn it into little wooden I beams. Or you could make little I beams like tiny truss joists. Am I over thinking this? Sure.

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

#5

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

john Veerkamp

QS oak would be a problem. typically canvas is stretched and fastened with staples or tacks. Oak would be too hard and possibly splintery to work.

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

#6

why quartersawn?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If I understand what these things are I don't see how the grain orientation would be important on such a small piece of wood.

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

#7

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

Tony - Memphis

My wife is an artist. I've had the same thoughts and experiences. After looking at many paintings, it seems that none are straight or square! I've use poplar and "white wood" to make a few. No major issues, but we just accepted that things would not be perfect. So far, so good. Stapling is/can be a real pain. I hate stretching canvas! Last time we tried, I had a couple of bum wrists and couldn't do it. That was pre-gessoed canvas though, and it was really stiff (won't do that again). The real fine woven stuff that was raw was easier. Also made some hardboard "canvases" for her. I used poplar for the frame. Have to make those look nice because the wood shows. No, those weren't perfectly flat either! I'll be anxious to here if anybody has figured this out. Trouble is, these are typically long narrow pieces with a fair amoutn of stress applied - not a good formula.

Tony (al in all - pre-stretched canvases are not a bad deal!)

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

#8

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

Dick Coers

Soft maple is my favorite wood for this application, poplar will work just fine. I'm not bashful about adding a center support or two on bigger frames. They don't have to be big, so it doesn't add much weight. Shoot a Kreg screw to install those. They really add the strength. I too would not use oak because of the tannin. A good canvas stretching pliers is the key to a good job on the canvas.

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

#9

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

Hank Knight

What Dick said. I have also used "white wood" - some kind of pine/spruce/fir successfully, as long as it's not pitchy. Oak is bad for the reasons alerady mentioned. Soft maple meets all the criteria, except it can be a little heavy. It is very stable, so it doesn't need to be quarter sawn.

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

#10

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

AZ in Colorado Springs

I made a couple about four years ago for a friend using poplar. I used pieces with straight grain. I used M&T joints for the corners and cross braces (one was about 3'x4' and the other about 4'x6'). I framed the smaller one about 18 months ago and it was flat and dropped into the frame easily. The other one hangs on the wall unframed and it looks fine. I'd think if the pieces deformed it'd show up looking at the art.

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

#11

Great Replies!

don stephan

Thanks everyone for very helpful replies.

Regarding qs v fs lumber, I won't apologize for preferring quartersawn. Having learned a few years ago how to properly flatten and straighten lumber, I'd likely get similar results with flatsawn, but I haven't used much, and have been getting great results with quartersawn.

Thank you for reminding me of the tannin content of oak. That alone is good reason not to use it for stretchers in my opinion.

The flatsawn material the painter had bought on the Internet were unbelievably poor quality wood and results, which probably also steered me to quartersawn as a knee-jerk reaction.

I'll probably make a sample for him from 5/4 flatsawn poplar resulting in 3" x 7/8" finished dimensions, with a separate 5/8 x 5/8 quarter round bradded along the outer edge to hold the fabric off the stretcher itself.

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

#12

use 4/4

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It would be rare 4/4 poplar that would not clean up at 7/8" in a 3" wide strip.

Re: A Great Canvas (Painting) Stretcher

#13

Ellis Walentine

Don't overthink it

Ellis Walentine

Gonna weigh in on the side of practicality here. Having lived with three generations of artists, I can say that the pine stretchers you buy at the art supply store, with mitered bridle joints, are perfectly suitable for stretching canvas. A stretcher doesn't need to have a lot of structural strength, and if it isn't dead flat, it usually doesn't matter; it's pliable enough to conform to whatever frame you put it in.

OTOH, I've made scores of custom stretchers, from whatever wood I had handy -- usually softwood because it is easier to drive staples home in softwood. Poplar is fine, too. The cross-sectional dimensions depend on the size of the frame and the wood you're using, but 3/4" x 2" is pretty standard. You can use center structure on larger frames to keep them from bowing when you stretch the canvas. I've put them together with bridle joints, lap joints, nails, biscuits, splines, drywall screws, miter feathers, gussets, pocket-hole screws and even Scotch fasteners, and they all seem to do the job. In other words, whatever works for you. I wouldn't go crazy on the joinery.

One thing I suggest is to bevel the face of the frame that goes up against the back of the canvas, so that it only contacts at the outside edge. Also, I ease the edges and corners somewhat. For stretching, all you need is a pair of canvas-stretching pliers and a staple gun with 5/16" staples.

Keep it simple.

Ellis