Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Bar Clamp Testing

Posts

Bar Clamp Testing

#1

Bar Clamp Testing

TomD


I mocked up the rig above to measure clamping force. There is a 3.6 x 1 inch maple board that spans 22 inches (I had to check the actual pivot points on the blocks the board is resting on with feeler gages. The contact points were on the right side of the left block, and about 1/3rd in on the right block. The contact points were 22 inches apart as mentioned).

The only in-obvious detail in the set up is that for the board to apply force to the center of the scale, while being available to the clamp on the edge of the bench, the scale had to straddle the beam and a collection of blocks on the frame under the beam.

I started out placing the clamp on the "center" of the beam, which turned out to be at the 12 inch mark when I later identified the actual pivots. So the ratio of force was 22/12. In other words the read out on the scale would be nearly half of the actual force. Since the scale tops out at around 300, if the clamp was stronger than twice that, I could move it to the left so that 3-1 or 5-1 ratios could be achieve. (in theory, the strength of the piece of wood is a limiting factor).

The first time I tightened the clamp I got a reading of 170 x (22/12). That was using a lot of my hand strength, but not leaning into the clamp with body weight. I could hear minor wood snapping sounds After I took the fixture apart, I found a few dents and such, and a dent in the metal surface of the scale. I felt that was about all I would do in a real world situation. I also felt that I had probably sprung the board more that I would have normally. I got a deflection of less than 1/16" over the 10 inch length of my ruler, but that would be a lot more than that over 22 inches, maybe 1/8, which would be 1/4 as far as a spring gap to close, over 22 inches. I need a better rig to measure that though, if one cared. A dial indicator would be better. I do not feel my measurements were necessarily all that close, because for one thing they didn't vary than much at different loads.

I also noticed a dent across the face of the board from clamp bowing, I would guess.

I had to go get the camera, and when I came back I really leaned into the clamp, actually pulled on the clamp with my body weight which is considerable. That test which was certainly more than I would normally use yielded a reading of 277, but the original reading was 7, so call it 270. So all told that is 495 pounds. I know I have, normally in a bit of desperation, probably got that high in the past, and maybe more. The idea here wasn't to set a world record for clamp setting, but to get at least some idea what the loads involved are like before clamping pressure gets so high it badly dents the stock, or the applier of torque starts to feel he is overdoing it.

On the other hand I have seen jigs where bolt heads were closed with pneumatic ratchet handles. A 2000 lbs level would be possible, I would guess (the limit again being the stuff that is happening to the wood). But on something like the 7 inch wide by 1.25 inch thick boards I mentioned earlier you are going to get a 12.6 reduction in PSI without much coverage at all in some places unless the clamps are at least every 10 inches. That would be a net clamping force of 3465 pounds, with about 38.5 PSI, though it is unlikely the force is even. (table of boards of 6 feet x 1.25 x 7 inches)


The main thing is that it is easy to do this kind of experiment, and satisfy oneself what kind of pressure one can get. There is nothing definitive about these tests as people and circumstances vary a lot, but a lot of questions can be easily answered experimentally and in little time with stuff from around the house. The initial inquiry comes from at least a 20X disparity. I think this rig was within .2X, though the results are a lot more variable due to subjective factors.

Re: Bar Clamp Testing

#2

Formulation is the most subjective part...

John in NM

It is quite likely that clamp manufacturers are talking about something quite different than this sort of set up when they quote those 3500 lb figures.

The force you are measuring is quite a bit higher where the 5/8" screw meets the clamp pad, because it is not distributed over a wide area. Without knowing the specific definition of the spec's quoted, you may well be coming up with corroborating data rather than conflicting data.

Re: Bar Clamp Testing

#3

Re: Formulation is the most subjective part...

TomD

Hmm, I am not an engineer, so I can use all the help I can get. But I think there may be a confusion between a force of 3500 pounds and 3500 psi.

Now in this case, in theory the pad is actually larger surface area that 1 square inch, though it's bearing is not all that even. But yeah, there probably is more than 1x psi at the contact point, which until the bearing squished out (creepy initial cracking sounds) was having an effect.

Bill mentioned PSI. depending on the footprint of that clamp, psi could be + or - x of the load. Whatever the PSI are doing, that error in understanding: is it a net force of 3500 (small elephant) or is it a small elephant in high heels, that is nothing like a 5x or 10x factor (well for a clamp, high heels, might be up there). You don't get from 350 to 3500. I think the load is the issue here. I can make a 10 ton press for a few cents whenever I want to, I just get a pin, with the correct load, getting 10 ton psi is probably easy, But that isn't what we mean. We mean a 10 ton elephant.

If you have two equal weight people standing on either ends of a teeter totter (basically my test rig), and one is wearing sandals, and the other is wearing high heels, there can be a localized difference in psi, but they should still equal out in balancing the teeter totter.

Re: Bar Clamp Testing

#4

Re: Formulation is the most subjective part...

John in NM

Bill was quoting manufacturer specs, we do not know how the manufacturers came up with those specs. They may or may not have any bearing on the reality of woodworking.

You can easily get 350 from 3500.

Say the face of the acme thread screw is .5" diameter, giving it an area of .25 sq inches. If the screw threads are rated to provide 14,000 pounds of force without damage, that gives you 3500 psi at the face of the screw.

A typical clamp pad of a pipe clamp is 1.75" square. That gives you 3.0625 sq inches, reducing the pressure to 1,142.857 psi. Then divide that by the joint area, which is highly variable, and you can quite easily be down around the 100's of psi also quoted.

Just depends on which part of the system you're talking about.

Re: Bar Clamp Testing

#5

Re:Force/Area=Pressure

TomD

That I understand. I think you are missing the point of testing. It isn't to disprove a particular spec, it is to find out what actually occurs in actual clamps in the shop. I think my clamps are somewhat representative, better than average quality, average maintenance. They are real clamps not lab ideal circumstances clamps.

It is also to measure reasonable force applied, when does the wood dent, how much deflection is reasonable, and so forth. These are metrics that while I can imagine someone with the strength to apply 3x force over mine, I have never seen anyone handle a clamp like that on a cabinet grade project. Parts are supposed to fit.

One of Bill's thought experiments was to work back from a psi figure listed as optimum by a glue manufacturer.

"One can turn this discussion around and approach it from what is required. Franklin recommends 175 to 250 psi for an edge glued joint with a dense wood , maple for example, in a factory production situation. Pick a typical situation for panel gluing ( length, thickness, number of clamps, and one sees that what ever clamp you use must deliver something around 2000 psi to achieve the recommended clamping force. It is a short leap of logic to then conclude that clamp manufacturers (maybe not yours) will make clamps to deliver at least this force, plus some, for a margin of error."

So if we are looking for a per clamp force of 2K, that is nowhere near the 350 ish, to 500 level, I measured. But as I said, rather than guessing, philosophising, or quoting, one can easily measure such matters oneself. I have plenty of example of manufacturing specs that seem to be made up in the marketing department. I don't trust I verify.

"Say the face of the acme thread screw is .5" diameter, giving it an area of .25 sq inches."

Actually, .196. I calculated it, but a simple head math check is 76% of the square area. I do head math all the time calculating circular section boat specs. Of course 3/4s of the squared area is close enough in most cases.

"If the screw threads are rated to provide 14,000 pounds of force without damage, that gives you 3500 psi at the face of the screw."

Actually 71 400 psi. Same force, smaller area, higher psi.

Sounds like your clamping force is based on the yield of the screw? That would be very "optimistic". The beefy bar on my clamp dented a faint line across the width of the maple board, at loading of about 495 pounds. I don't want to be in the same area code when they apply a force of 14 000 pounds.

"A typical clamp pad of a pipe clamp is 1.75" square. That gives you 3.0625 sq inches, reducing the pressure to 1,142.857 psi. Then divide that by the joint area, which is highly variable, and you can quite easily be down around the 100's of psi also quoted."

Or actually reducing the pressure to 23 300 psi, or about 11x the yield of maple.

I find this interesting, but not very useful. I just use the stuff I have on the stuff I make. It may well be true that the ideal psi range is 175-250, but Titebond I is well respected for zero psi work, or the 14 psi bagging, so I don't know what to make of their numbers, other than that I doubt they actually occur that much in nature.

Re: Bar Clamp Testing

#6

Didn't miss the point at all...

John in NM

To quote you

"So if we are looking for a per clamp force of 2K, that is nowhere near the 350 ish, to 500 level, I measured."

I outlined a possible explanation for this discrepancy.