Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

Posts

Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

#1

Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

So I've started to put finish on my (butt ugly) wall clock. :b It's not turning out how I envisioned it to look. Ever have one of those projects that turns into a monkey on your back and you can't wait for it to be done? This has become one of those.

I've dyed all the pieces with water based TransTint dye. I have several jars of different strengths. I tested on some scrap and liked the color; Early American Maple I think is its name. So I applied it to the pieces, let it dry several days till I could work on it again, then sanded the raised grain. Looked okay.

The panel for the bottom door I want finished completely before I glue it up so I don't see any unfinished areas should it shrink/expand a little. So, I started to brush on some Zinser SealCoat. Dried, and sanded it a little. Looks ok. But as I looked at it later, I realized it is NOT the same color as my sample. Not even close. It's not the nice caramel color I wanted, it's more of a poopy brown color. What a moron. I must have grabbed the wrong jar. Oh well, I've been known to do much dumber things... at least all the pieces are the same ugly poopy brown color. It has a nice consistent ugliness to it. :\

There have been other "oh crap" moments with this project. Can't wait for it to be done. I guess this is one of the risks of making these types of things and doing them in short bursts of time and hurrying to get anything done.

That's where I'm at with this - putting finish on the lower door panel before glue up. This will obviously be hanging on a wall and doesn't need lots of protection. How many coats of this Zinser should I brush on? After I get X number of coats brushed on I'll smooth everything out (brush marks and so on) with a rubber charged with shellac and DNA. I've done that with other things and seems to work well.

I don't want the finish to be too glossy though. Any suggestions as far as that goes regarding how I am applying it?

I've put some shellac on the inside edges of the rails and stiles. I'm sure once it is glued up I'll have to plane some edges to get a nice fit to the case. That means I'll need to re-apply some dye to those areas then shellac. I'll try to remember to grab that right jar of dye.

If I screw it up any more, I'll just paint it with blue milk paint...

Thanks.

Joe in Cleveland (considering new hobbies...)

Re: Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

#2

Which Zinser shellac?

Dick Coers

Not that it will make a difference in the application, just wondering. I apply enough coats to get an even sheen all over. It soaks in the curl grain for a long time until it matches the hard grain. Especially after the pores are opened up after the dying process. Can't say how many coats that is, don't know if you have thinned it or just straight from the can. Not wanting a gloss is going to be an issue with shellac, that's the only sheen you get. You'll have to knock it back with steel wool, or synthetic wool if you want something duller.

I just can't say it often enough. You should never be surprised with a finish on the finished piece! All those surprises should come on a piece of scrap. That scrap must get the exact full treatment you intend on the furniture. You won't be the last one to post like this, I'm certain!

Re: Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

#3

how many coats

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I find the Zinsser to be a bit thick as it comes (3 pound cut for the stuff that is not dewaxed). I used 2-3 coats with it thinned a bit. The answer is lay it on until it forms a forms a smooth film of shellac. If wood fuzz is not filled with shellac, add another coat.

Sand the ugly dye down to where most of it is gone and add the correct stain. You don't have to be rid of all the stain to recover, and who knows, the combination may be perfect. many finishing schedules call for a base coat of one dye followed by another.

Keep in mind that the shellac will add color.

Its a nice shaped clock. Stick with it until it is right.

Re: Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

#4

Re: how many coats

Steve Schoene

Part of your problem may come from using Transtint dye. It's a multi-solvent dye and will dissolve in alcohol, the solvent in Shellac. Applied by brush particularly, the shellac is quite likely to lift or dissolve the dye into the shellac. Alcohol will dissolve the dye even if initially dissolved in water.

Also remember that dye color can't be judged until it has a top coat. That will alway change the color from the dyed surface.

Applied properly you really shouldn't have brush strokes to sand out. I recommend thinning the shellac to 2lb. cut or even a bit less. For me the brush is important. I like a Taklon Gold water color wash brush. Yes, it doesn't hold a lot of shellac, but it flows it on smoothly without brush marks. You do need to work quickly, brushing only in one direction and never going back over a place you have missed or need to correct--take care of that on the next coat.

Re: Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

#5

Color change with that dye...

John in NM

That is very true, you have to have a coat over the dye to see how it will look. I sometimes preview dyed wood by spraying it with mineral spirits - it goes over the transtint without dissolving it and looks about like it will with a coat of oil or shellac over the dye.

Re: Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

#6

question for finishing experts

John Pappas

I'd like to ask a question regarding Joe's problem with color. I believe the best way to adjust color at this point would be to spray with a toner. My question: would it also be a valid alternative to use a glaze to adjust the color? A gel stain, or a mixture of poly/oil/colorants.

Re: Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

#7

A Few Things

David Yoho

After reading all the responses so far, I saw a few things that might need clearing up. First, Joe stated in his message he was using Zinsser Seal Coat. Second, it is a 2-lb. cut.

I agree with Bill's suggestion about sanding and going back with the correct blend of dye. I actually shared this method for popping the figure in figured woods with Joe in a much earlier email about the topic.

When dying a wood like curly maple, to "pop" the grain I like to begin with what I refer to as a "trace" coat of dye that will be the accent color in the figure. The trace coat does several things besides color the figure - first, it raises the grain but since this coat is for the figure only, it gets sanded, which removes the dye on the surface along with the fuzz. Second, it will easily show any glue residue left behind and any sanding swirls, which allows a chance to remedy both before moving forward. With the surface color sanded to bare wood but left in the figure, I apply the color dye I want it to be in the end. This application should not raise the grain or, if so, not enough to worry about. After this is dry I apply the topcoat. Even though I have and do use the Transtint dyes, for most work, especially larger pieces, I use the Lockwood water soluble dyes because I like them better.

So, to Bill's point, it's not too late to sand to bare wood and apply the shade Joe initially wanted. This should actually "pop" the figure more than a single coat of dye will.

Re: Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

#8

Not an expert but...

David Yoho

My response posted above will shed some light to your question as I think Bill gave good information in his response. To answer your question, I first have to agree with what Dick said in his response. There should not be a surprise needing adjustments if the finishing schedule was performed on some scrap first.

Your choices are valid ways to change or enhance the outcome of a finished color and certainly have their uses. I just think they wouldn't be necessary if the practice is done and approved before applying anything to the real deal.

Re: Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

#9

Re: Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

don stephan

Jeff used to carry a product called Shellac Flat. Don't know if he still carries it, and if it can be diluted to produce sheen between gloss and flat. Check on the Homestead Finishing web site.

Re: Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

#10

Re: Which Zinser shellac?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"Which Zinser shellac?"

The SealCoat stuff sold at the borg.

"That scrap must get the exact full treatment you intend on the furniture."

It did. I applied the dye and also put the shellac on it to make sure it was the look we (my wife and I) wanted.

I believe when I went to apply the dye, I grabbed the wrong jar of dye. :\

Stupid mistake.

Thank you.

Re: Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

#11

Re: how many coats

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"Sand the ugly dye down to where most of it is gone and add the correct stain. "

My wife and I looked at it last night. She says leave it alone. She likes the color. So I will continue with it.

Thank you.

Re: Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

#12

Re: how many coats

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"Applied properly you really shouldn't have brush strokes to sand out. I recommend thinning the shellac to 2lb. cut or even a bit less."

The SealCoat stuff is pretty thin. Would you thin this as well?

"For me the brush is important. I like a Taklon Gold water color wash brush. "

I was going to get one from Jeff Jewitt. I kept forgetting to order one (his shop is 4 miles from my house as a crow flies). When I was at WoodCraft I bought one. The guy there told me it was good for shellac. It isn't. I knew it wasn't, but was in a rush. Another stupid mistake.

Thank you.

Re: Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

#13

Thanks David

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"So, to Bill's point, it's not too late to sand to bare wood and apply the shade Joe initially wanted."

Wife says leave it alone. So I will. I'll try to remember my mistakes too.

Thank you.

Re: Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

#14

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

SealCoat

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...is a 2 lb cut as packaged.

I can't imagine thinning it for normal use.

BTW, anytime I have to brush shellac (not too often), I just used a good quality nylon/polyester blend paint brush. Works just fine.

Jason

Re: Brushing shellac - a bit long winded

#15

Re: how many coats

Steve Schoene

SealCoat is already 2lb. cut as it comes from the can.