Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

Posts

OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

#1

OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

Barry Irby

A new higher energy standard goes into effect April 15 for water heaters. My understanding is they will be about 2" bigger in diameter and 2" taller to allow for superior insulation. They should be somewhat better on energy retention and about 30% more expensive.

I realize this has nothing to do with wood working, but I thought some of you might like to know. If your water heater is in a tight space, it may give you problems when you have to replace it. I know one guy who owns rental houses just went out and bought two and stashed them. Also, you may have to buy a larger pan.

I have wrapped my water heater and those in all my rentals with insulation much better than this and it did not cost thirty percent.

Re: OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

#2

Re: I've been checking this out

DONinSTL

For a 40-gal., nat. gas water heater the present standard is an efficiency factor of .59EF. The new standard is .62EF. Rheem already has their Performance Plus .62 EF heaters available. Compared to my 12-year-old G.E. tank, their tank is only about 1+ inch bigger in diameter, but it is 4-1/4 inches taller. Right now HD has a Rheem 40-gal., 40,000 BTU, .62EF unit that is only 22 per cent more ($79) than their 40-gal., 36,000 BTU, .59EF unit, and it also has a 9-year warranty instead of a 6-year warranty.

Re: OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

#3

Re:Time to switch to demand?

TomD

What say ye all?

Re: OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

#4

Re:Time to switch to demand?

John McGaw

I've certainly thought about it. Problem is that I'd have to do some considerable gas and vent plumbing if I was to go for a gas-fired demand unit and an almost equally expensive electrical refit to support an electric one. Guess I'll just tough it out with what I have and replace it with the most efficient unit available when this one dies.

Re: OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

#5

Re:Time to switch to demand?

Bill Howatt

Demand vs regular is a real bi-polar "argument".

A few years ago I looked into demand (on-line) and there were 2 distinct camps - some thought it was great and the others thought they bought an expensive failure. Installation cost and poor heater life seemed to be the major issues. Admittedly, most people tend to post problems than success.

Don't know if things have changed but I'm still on the regular tank.

Bill

Re: OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

#6

Re:Time to switch to demand?

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

I don't think an electric one would ever pay for itself, because it takes a lot of KW's to heat water quickly. With gas on demand water heaters, the length of run from the heater to the tap you are using will waste water until the hot water reaches the faucet. You also have to look at the initial cost versus the potential savings by know what it currently costs you to heat water. You also have to consider if things like a dishwasher will end up heating water with the internal heater because the "hot" water isn't hot enough.

On demand water heaters can only raise the temperature a certain amount depending upon the flow. The lower the flow the higher the temperature change you can get, conversely the higher the flow the less temperature change you can get. If you need high temperatures and have high flow rates, you may need two or more on demand heaters to get the desired output temperature. Manufacturers furnish charts showing flow rates and temperature change for their units.

Lee

Re: OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

#7

Re: OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

To me this is another "feel good" measure for the ECO group, and will homeowners will see far more cost than benefit. I have my water heater in a room where the furnace and my deep freezers reside. The room is neither heated nor air conditioned. The heat "loss" from the appliances keeps the room above freezing in the winter and costs nothing in air conditioning losses in the summer. As most water heaters are kept in spaces heated and cooled in home temperatures, (near 70F), I seriously doubt the additional cost will ever be recouped by the homeowner prior to replacement of the unit.

Much like the incandescent light bulb law, it does nothing but cost me money. IE: I, like most people, have many lights in my home that see very little use, storage areas, spare bedrooms etc. Energy cost probably were in the $0.10 cost per YEAR for each of these bulbs, now my replacement bulb cost has risen far more than I can recoup in my lifetime, and the lighting quality is worse!

Personally, I would like to see almost all of the the Government agencies closed and the money spent on scientific research. The market would then determine what is economical for use.

Re: OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

#8

Flow.... never thought of that...

John in NM

That probably accounts for the problem with the one system I have any experience with. House sitting for some people who had a propane on demand system, it couldn't seem to produce enough hot water and worked inconsistently - hot at first and then not hot enough.

Probably had something to do with flow rate varying - since they were on a well there would be some variation in pressure depending on whether the system was using a tank and a pressurizing pump or simply using the well pump for pressure. I bet it was the former, and that the on demand heater installer didn't know there would be variations in pressure or flow.

Re: OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

#9

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

All that effort and expense for a measly 0.03% increase in efficiency?

Here's a suggestion: Go hug your water heater. Was it noticeably warmer than the surrounding air? If not, then it's already sufficiently insulated.

Even the so-called 'efficiency' blankets they currently sell are a waste of money.

Re: OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

#10

I don't think it's quite that simple

John in NM

The energy factor calculation is more than a simple heat loss equation, and both the existing and amended EF standards are indexed both to fuel type and WH volume.

I had a Marathon high efficiency electric for a few years. You could turn it off and the water would still be warm (though not hot) three days later. Unfortunately it had a habit of leaking, so we replaced it with a regular one. The difference between the two is noticeable.

Like the light bulbs, however, I dislike these standards being mandated. The relative cost savings in operation does not outweigh the higher purchase prices, so most consumers will not accept the more efficient products without being forced to do so. It is wrong to force them.

Re: OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

#11

Re: Flow.... never thought of that...

Rum

Flow is a big deal with these. A buddy installed one, loved it. Another friend saw that and being of the "bigger is better" camp installed a similar but much larger one. To this day eh can't take a shower without running the sink at at least a good trickle at the same time or the heater won't kick on.

We looked at them for our last replacement but I'd have had to have had the gas line upgraded in size (the 3/4" line that serves the tank just fine didn't cut it for the on-demand ones I found at the time, might be different now) which didn't seem worth it. So we just upgraded the size to 50g and called it a day, so much for efficiency, at least we have lots of hot water.

Re: OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

#12

30 years ago.

Basil

30 years ago, I was newly single and working 16 hour days, 7 days a week. My water heater decided it was a good time to have a fit. It would over heat, pop off dumping hot water and steam under the house every few minutes. I didn't have time to replace or fix it myself and couldn't be home to let someone else do it.

For well over a month I would come home late and turn it on at the breaker box. I would let it heat up for about 20 minutes while making myself something to eat. I would then turn it off and take a shower. The next morning the water was still more than warm enough to wash my face and stuff.

Turning the electricity to the hot water heater on and off cut my electric bill almost in half. I told an uncle about it and from then on he and my aunt did the same. They would turn the water heater on, take showers, wash dishes, whatever required hot water and then turn it off until about the same time next day. My uncle was VERY careful about a dollar.

Here you can sign up to have the power company to control your hot water heater.

Oh yeah, also, when my son was born I turned the water heater temperature down to 125 degrees so he couldn't accidently get burned. That also reduced my electric bill quit a bit.....but it did raise the wife's temperature a few degrees....LOL

Re: OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

#13

Re:Time to switch to demand?

R. Payne

We've got an on-demand and it works well. It'll heat water for 2 showers running the same time or 1 sink and will get 140 F. We had one previously that the plumber who installed it screwed up. Both propane units and when we put the first one in our propane usage fell to less than 1/2 what it was on the tank (although I imagine a large part of this was going from standing pilot to electric ignition).

They've been used in Europe for years (I first encountered them stationed in Germany), both gas and electric. If they weren't more efficient they wouldn't be popular there.

ron

Re: OT Water heater sizing, getting bigger

#14

Re: Insurance savings...

TomD

Looking at my policy, the cost of flood insurance would be lower by 25% if I installed a demand water heater. I didn't realize that.

(though actually this year the cost of insurance went up in my region by 10% due to the cost of keeping the serial crack heads who keep refurbishing their basements and getting flooded out. Around here a lot of the flood risk is as a result of mechanical systems, not living next to the coast, hurricanes, or rivers. So in other words mechanical problems would be a larger segment than in some other places).