Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Anyone have frameless shower doors?

Posts

Anyone have frameless shower doors?

#1

Anyone have frameless shower doors?

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

Had the bathroom updated with new tile in the shower, jacuzzi surround and entire floor. The old aluminum framed bypass shower doors were removed and replaced with clear glass shower wall (fixed panel and swing-through door). The first door had a bow in it. Line up the top and bottom of the door with the fixed panel and there was a noticeable bow outward at the middle of the door. Shower guys brought out a new door. The installer said the new one is not perfect but a heck of a lot better than the first one. I should have stopped him right there and had him put it back on the truck. the second door is also bowed, just as much as the first to my eyes. I put a caliper on it and the bow is 0.085" (about 3/32"). A retired engineer is probably not the kind of customer this firm wants.

Anyway, am I out of line to tell them to bring another door? The fixed panel is dead flat. I was told this happens frequently when they cook the glass to temper it. They also told me they order these doors in a standard size in quantities of about 20 at a time. They custom cut the fixed panel to fit with the standard door and send it off to be cooked. My first reaction was why is the fixed panel perfect and both doors bowed?

Is there an industry tolerance for these things? I don't want to be unreasonable, but for what I'm paying for this, I figure it ought to be pretty darn perfect.

Re: Anyone have frameless shower doors?

#2

Re: Anyone have frameless shower doors?

John McGaw

Maybe I'm more laid-back than you are but I wouldn't worry about that bit of bow unless it actually impacted on the operation or was actually unsightly (to others who aren't pre-informed about the defect). Would anybody but an engineer or machinist notice that much bow over that distance? I put frameless in the en-suite that I fixed up for my mother before she moved in. It has a fixed and a sliding rather than a swinging and both are visually flat so I didn't get out my precision measuring instruments so I can't say if they are perfect but they look good and work well so I will leave well enough alone. I doubt that there is any industry-wide standard and it is unlikely that any maker will allow outsiders to see whatever their internal QC standards might be.

If you decide to go back to them for a replacement I'd suggest that you suggest to them a personal visit to the shop so that you can pre-screen their glass blanks and pick the one that you want. They might just bite to be done to put the job behind them.

Re: Anyone have frameless shower doors?

#3

Re: Anyone have frameless shower doors?

Neal in San Jose

I just went and looked at my frameless shower door, and it is also bowed. I had never noticed it before. Mine is bowed out at the top about the same amount as yours. It is flat from about the handle down, which allows the door to seal about 90% of it's length. I've never noticed any water on the floor, so it is working well, and I haven't had a reason to investigate before now. It isn't visible from the outside and only from the inside if I look for it. If it had caused a leak onto the floor, I would have complained.

My questions are these: will the bow in the door prevent it from sealing, closing properly, or cause other problems? Is it so obvious that it will constantly annoy you? If so, call them back out. If not, I'd go down to the shop and make some shavings. Bear in mind that may be as good as that particular manufacturer can do.

Re: Anyone have frameless shower doors?

#4

Re: Anyone have frameless shower doors?

E Snow

Thicker (8mm +) tempered glass is notoriously bad for both size and flatness.

Having specified and inspected mountains of glass, I'd take the 0.085" bow and the fact that it fits and leave it be. The odds are stacked against you if you expect it both flatter and fitting.

Unfortunately, my experience tells me I am lucky if it ends up +/- 1/8" in any dimension. I've taken to applying a profile tolerance to any glass I specify anymore as that is really about all that can be managed.