Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Apply glue to one side or two sides?

Posts

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#26

Well, maybe

Keith Newton

But since the weakest of all the physical properties of almost all woods, is that of splitting along the grain. If there was any grain deviation away from the glueline, would likely run off, then continue to follow the grain, even if only a few inches down was too dry.

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#27

Re: Do you consider 3500 psi high?

TomD

"A typical clamp (Taylor or Hargrave) with an acme thread like is used in furniture factories and other shops can apply 3500 pounds of clamp pressure."

So the average small acme screw could develop the force to jack up a truck. Ah, yeah. I don't really believe it even if the threads were heavily greased, which they aren't. I have several of those old bottle type threaded jacks that have huge acme threads, and are well greases, and they easily lift the front end of a Farmall Cub off the ground, but it only weights

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#28

Re: I have a clamp question

TomD

Seriously?

http://www.engineersedge.com/calculators/torque_calc.htm

I inserted 150 in #, based on the idea I could apply 50 pounds force over a 3 inch handle, which to me seems generous. One could use a go-bar, and spike this way up, or a wooden handle and loose a lot.

I picked .5 for the diameter in inches of the screw, and I got 960 as the result, which sounds in line with what you are reporting, though I can't see how there isn't a thread pitch value, so this probably isn't the correct calculator.

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#29

Hey Tom, i was curious too. I found this *LINK*

Keith Newton

They didn't give any numbers for the bar clamps, but they do for several sizes of C-clamps of various duty weights, getting up to over 9000# with 7/8" or maybe 1", and I'm just guessing that the handle gets longer as they go up.

On their super C clamp, they show 3000# for 1/2" thread, and 4500 for 5'8"

Yes, you can exceed the range that they list here, but DAHIK that you can bend them out of alignment when you exceed their expected range.

But then, I've never seen a bar clamp with this large a screw.


http://www.jugenheimersupplies.com/pdf/clamps.pdf

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#30

That is the trouble with engineering...

John in NM

You have to be sure what you are talking about is what Bill is talking about.

With the calculator you posted, the limiting factor will be hand applied torque - since the human hand/arm is far less strong than the 5/8" acme thread rod typically found in bar or pipe clamps.

At any rate, assuming 100 in-lbs for hand applied torque - 50 lbs with a 2" radius handle, that calculator gives you 800 lbs at the face of the bolt.

However, put a 24" cheater on the handle, and you get 9,600 lbs at the face of the bolt. The shear strength of threaded rod is vastly higher than any kind of torque we apply when woodworking. For 5/8" acme, its got to be somewhere well over 2,000 in-lbs (yes that is a guess, I haven't looked it up. The Machinery Handbook probably has the figure somewhere).

I suspect that the spec's Bill is quoting are arrived at not through hand application of torque so much as materials limits of the clamp itself. 3,500 lb is a pretty reasonable figure for service use if your limiting factor is what the bar will take with minimal deflection, rather than how much load your hand/arm can apply.

The point of all this is that in regular use, clamping pressure required is very minimal for woodworking - which is why I said that our capabilities are far over what is needed for a properly made joint.

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#31

Of course there is a thread pitch factor

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

... and several other factors which will keep you from being able to calculate the force at the clamp jaw. Instead, clamp companies provide gauges to calibrate their clamping stations in factories and the force at the clamp jaw is measured by the gauge. But choose to believe clamp companies don't know what force their clamps are capable of delivering if you wish. It won't matter if you never glue panels.

One can turn this discussion around and approach it from what is required. Franklin recommends 175 to 250 psi for an edge glued joint with a dense wood , maple for example, in a factory production situation. Pick a typical situation for panel gluing ( length, thickness, number of clamps, and one sees that what ever clamp you use must deliver something around 2000 psi to achieve the recommended clamping force. It is a short leap of logic to then conclude that clamp manufacturers (maybe not yours) will make clamps to deliver at least this force, plus some, for a margin of error.

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#32

Clint Searl

Overkill

Clint Searl

For the kind of work done by WC'ers, anything more than a Bessey light/medium bar clamp just ain't necessary.

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#33

Good luck

John in NM

Finding one of those in 8' length :D

I'll stick with pipe clamps. The one time you need a long one you can make it out of a couple of the short ones you use every other day.

But yeah, if it were just about applying the minimum pressure, should you do everything else just right, that clamp would be all we need.

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#34

Clint Searl

Re: 10'

Clint Searl

There was a project that needed a long span clamp, so I bought a 10' piece of black iron pipe and made one up. It now leans in a corner. But the point I was hoping to make is that a 3000# rated clamp is irrelevant to 99% of what's done that is equally well served by a 900# Bessey bar clamp.

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#35

Why not...

John in NM

Buy a 3/4" union and use two 5' pipes - that's what I do :D

For my money, pipe clamps fill a useful niche. I have a bunch of Wetzler F clamps too, and use them a lot, but I wouldn't trade in my pipe clamps for more Wetzlers.

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#36

Re: Bessey Bessey KBX20 K Body Clamp Extender

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have the above clamp extenders, with my 60" Bessey K-Body clamps I can easily reach 8 foot +. They do make 96" (As I remember), but never found the need to store them. I also have many pipe clamps with various lengths of 3/4" black pipe ~ most of the pipe was free from my old place of employment ~ bought many of the clamps at yard sales and auctions (cheap) and numerous couplings so can make any length I wish. My only issue with pipe clamps is that even with cork faces, I find I have to insert a block of wood to prevent marking the softer hardwoods.

The Bessey K-body clamps are rated at 1500 lb. I have never seen a need for more. I also have a number of Jorgenson smaller clamps I really like.

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#37

Re: Why not...

William Duffield

You don't need a union, or the setup time that goes with it to disassemble and reassemble your pipe clamps, and you surely don't need something as complicated as the Bessey extender either. Just take two pipe clamps, orient them with one crank on either end, twist one of the sliding ends 90°, hook the sliding ends together, and slide one until they engage. An additional advantage is you can tighten it from either end.

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#38

I did that once....

John in NM

Found it a little floppy to set up until I got the clamps snugged. That was when I started using the union. To each their own :D

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#39

I think you mean coupling, not union

Keith Newton

A union is what you need when you need to do a repair in the middle of a run where you don't want to undo everything to the far end, but can't screw in a new piece without it unscrewing on the opposite end.

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#40

Probably....

John in NM

I'm certainly no plumber. Sleeve threaded at both ends.

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#41

Re: I did that once....

William Duffield

I have some couplers, too, and definitely use them on occasion.

I wouldn't recommend anyone try my method on a complicated, stressful glue-up, and especially if you haven't practiced it a couple of times on a dry run.

Of course, you need to have both clamps laid out where you plan to use them, and adjusted to just about final length with the tails properly aligned. You pick up the first clamp, hook the head end over one end of the glue-up, grab it by the tail end and pull it tight enough the head doesn't slip off. Then, you pick up the second clamp with your other hand, hook its head over the other end of the object to be clamped, and drop the tail end into the same hand that is holding the tail of the first clamp, hooking them against each other, with a finger and thumb hooked around on one tail and two or three fingers hooked around the other tail. Then, you squeeze them together, applying sufficient pressure to both heads that neither one slips, so you can let go of the second clamp with your other hand and reach its crank, and tighten it. Easy, right? :\

Obviously it helps to have large hands, long, flexible fingers, and a strong grip.

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#42

Re: Of course there is a thread pitch factor

TomD

"But choose to believe clamp companies don't know what force their clamps are capable of delivering if you wish. It won't matter if you never glue panels."

I said I have a C clamp with a psi load cell on it, they are made for measuring deflections in testing modulus. And I already mentioned what one gets. Presumably these are also made by clamp companies, possibly with greater care that 5 dollar clamps as they are lower end instrument grade.

I think that the idea that go bars are used and we are approaching destructive testing limits makes sense. You could hang a ton or so from the frame of a microscope but the actual issue is precision and stiffness not failure under load. If you want to see what it takes to control a working load of 10000 pounds I would consult press specs. It certainly is more elaborate than a C clamp.

In this case flipping the argument is a more sensible approach at 175 psi while obviously still a fantasy is closer to the mark. To close my dining room table joint, 6 feet and 1.25 inches would require about 18000 pounds, or the weight of 3 F-150s.

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#43

Re: Let me fix that for you with a 5-10x reduction

TomD

"Pick a typical situation for panel gluing ( length, thickness, number of clamps, and one sees that what ever clamp you use must deliver something around 2000 psi to achieve the recommended clamping force. It is a short leap of logic to then conclude that clamp manufacturers (maybe not yours) will make clamps to deliver at least this force, plus some, for a margin of error."

So for instance large guitar manufacturers that use titebond, or glues like it, and have all kinds of liability, reputational, etc... reasons for not wanting they bridges to be launched as if by a crossbow, use vac pressure at sub 30 psi. There is no argument about that. There is no more force in the atmosphere. We know what is available, and it is 28 psi ish. We can't come up with magical explanation - there is no more force. We also know zero clamping pressure works, (but I don't know any major manufacturers that use that approach, largely due to time issues, or skilled workforce issues). So if we figure a 5x reduction is realistic, then we can peel back to 400 # per clamp (did you really mean PSI, that could be orders of magnitude given the pad size of clamps, it is also way above yield strength for many woods).

Yield strength or parallel to fiber crush does tend to support your contention, if every clamp is fully indenting on the harder domestic hardwoods. My experience is clamping deformation parallel to grain is common when one "overtightens" on softwood, or when the clamps aren't on straight with hardwood (which is why we have aligned jaw clamps because they won't bruise), Most clamps are set up to allow for deformation in the bars so even the I beam steel Jorgs flex a lot, and pad pressure is a moving target. But it would be easy to test in the home "lab" if one could get the basic parameters from forest products. Something like cutting an endgrain square inch and placing it inside a parallel jaw camp and seeing how easy it was to dent various woods would be an easy test.

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#44

Re: Anyone know what load cells cost

TomD

Particularly a tensile cell. I fall apart as Mr smartypants whenever electronics rears it's head. There are cheap parts on ebay. Anyone know that stuff?

I have thought up a simple testing apparatus for clamping pressure using a bathroom scale. If I get some time, I will test a few clamps today.

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#45

I know what I did wrong!

John in NM

I was trying to chew gum while doing all that! :D

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#46

Re: Atmospheric pressure is 14.5 PSI Approximately

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Tom, not nitpicking but I believe you were referring to "Inches of Mercury" instead of "PSI". (Standard sea-level pressure, by definition, equals 760 mm (29.92 inches) of mercury, 14.70 pounds per square inch). Therefore the most "PSI" you can achieve with a "pure Vacuum" is about 14.7 PSI (at sea level), obviously it varies according to the barometric pressure at your location - slightly more below sea level, less at elevation (drops to about 13 PSI at about 3500 foot above sea level).

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#47

Re: Atmospheric pressure is 14.5 PSI Approximately

TomD

You are correct, I do make that mistake because it is so close to 2x difference. Thanks for jumping in with the correction.

Re: Apply glue to one side or two sides?

#48

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The difference. *LINK*

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

A coupling is a cylindrical sleeve that is right-hand, female threaded at both ends (at least when referring to threaded pipe connections). A union is comprised of 3 parts--two fittings with RH female threads that thread onto each section of pipe , but one has RH male threads, the other has LH male threads on the opposite end, then the third piece of the union is a "coupling" that has RH female threads on one end and LH female threads on the other so that it can be tightened or loosened without turning any of the pipe.

Jason


Example of union