Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Gluing bent lams

Posts

Gluing bent lams

#1

Gluing bent lams

Hal

When gluing bent lams on a bending form, I am inclined to apply glue to one side of each lam only which is what I have done in all gluing (edge or face) for years and have never had a glue line failure. However, I have seen a recommendation to apply glue to both faces, I think possibly to insure complete coverage. As long as I am careful to get a good even coat on one side of each lam it seems I should be OK. Would appreciate any thoughts or comments. TIA, Hal

Re: Gluing bent lams

#2

Re: Gluing bent lams

Joseph Mulherin, sr

I agree with you, Hal. In making my rocking chair runners and back slats I only glue up only one side and still have some glue squeezing out when under pressure in my forms.

Re: Gluing bent lams

#3

Re: Gluing bent lams

jcousins

i only glue up 1 side - seems that doing both would create a real mess of squeeze out.

jerry

Re: Gluing bent lams

#4

Re: Gluing bent lams

Jesse Cloud

Not to say that one sided gluing won't work, but Popular Woodworking (I think) did a test several years ago that concluded that joints glued on both sides, preferably with a light coat on both sides, were significantly stronger than one sided joints. Their theory was that the glue soaks in quickly and while you don't need much glue, you do need it on both sides.

Personally, I roll a very thin coat on both sides. The rule of thumb is that you should be able to see a pencil mark thru the glue. Not much squeeze out and my lams are still tight after a couple of decades.

Re: Gluing bent lams

#5

Re: Gluing bent lams

John McGaw

Virtually every glueup I do is one-sided. One caveat is that I try to always 'rub' the joints so that glue from one surface is applied to the mating surface. Sometimes this isn't possible, in a M&T for example, so I will apply glue thinly to both surfaces there. No matter how you do it laminations can be a mess and I don't see any reason to make it more difficult and time-consuming by fussing with both surfaces. I've never had a failure of a glued lamination yet with my method.

Re: Gluing bent lams

#6

the requirement to be achieved

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What is critical is that both surfaces must be wet by the glue for it to adhere. If you have enough glue on the one face, and you have not let it sit exposed so long that the surface has begun to dry where it can't wet the mating surface, all will be well.

Re: Gluing bent lams

#7

Re: the requirement to be achieved

TomD

That is true, I doubt they actually put down both sides glue making plywood.

However...

1) it is like "razor sharp", it isn't one thing. Part of the grading difference in plywood is how much glue is used, getting a rich glue line (not thick), is one of the criteria for higher strength/rated products. Something like a rocking chair could be a classic candidate for fatigue failure, and it not coming apart right away, or when violently broken isn't the issue. It is whether it comes apart after 1 million cycles. When they test spars they have a test that does a low cycle about 10% and a higher cycle like 80%. A lot of spars fall down in the yacht basin after the millionth cycle of the boat rocking gently in the wind. We all expect them to fall down, close hauled in a race. But the stuff fails in different ways.

2) while is it faster to do one side only, what are the other advantages, just in how much of a rush are we? I don't think that this is the normal way to apply glue, in the sense that if I wanted to put glue on a tenon cheek, I wouldn't put it on a piece of scrap wood then press that together with the tenon, then use whatever stuck to bond the tenon. You do see people undergluing some wood joints on purpose, though, which is a different mater.

3) The biggest issue is if you make stuff where it matters, like spars, doing both sides pretty much always works. There is almost always guess work involved in the one side method. As to the glue characteristics if this is a new glue; or the first time you used it with a brand of ply, or species of wood; or the first time you used a method of assembly; or the first time you used it at a given temp, etc... My bugaboo is lighting. I sometimes don't see a miss on a piece of wood I only did one side on, though that would not be a problem for some.

Of course what works is probably going to keep on working for now.

Re: Gluing bent lams

#8

Re: the requirement to be achieved

Hal

Point well taken Bill. My wife and I worked together. I applied glue, she rolled it out and we popped it on the mating lam immediately. I did apply glue on the end few inches of both sides as that is where separation is most likely to occur (I think). Question for all. I will leave the assembly clamped to the bending form for at least 24hrs. Possibly longer would be advisable? I'm bending on a fairly tight radius..17". Lams 1/16 to 3/32". Hal

Re: Gluing bent lams

#9

Glue drying theory and creepyness

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Stuff like yellow glue cures by loosing water. In a typical panel joint water can leave the glue and diffuse into a relatively large mass of adjacent wood. Not the case with lamination. Worse, we may line the bending form with a water barrier- wax paper, aluminum foil, etc. I think it is safe to say that with 1/16" laminations that the glue will never fully cure in the form and even out of the form it may take a long time to get water from the middle joint to the outside where it can evaporate. It may be for this reason that these glues are seen to creep when in theory they should not. Partially cured glue will indeed be creepy.

I don't have an answer other than to be aware that the moisture content of the wood adjacent to the joint must get down in the 12-14% range to develop optimum strength. And, before the glue line gets to this moisture level the glue line will be creepy.

Re: Gluing bent lams

#10

Re: the requirement to be achieved

Jesse Cloud

Not to argue with Bill's analysis, but here's a data point.

I routinely leave lams on the form overnight, then trim them and start cutting the joinery on them the next morning. Never had a problem.

The joinery is typically on the edges, so as Bill suggested there may well still be some damp glue further inside.

One caution: when you take lams off the form, if you will be leaving them around for a while, don't store them with the bend pointing up or down, store them standing up. Gravity is not your friend in this case. Never actually had a problem, but my mentor emphasized it and it sounds reasonable.

I guess I should also add the disclaimer that my shop is in the New Mexico high desert, where humidity is typically around 5 per cent.

Re: Gluing bent lams

#11

For all you "One siders"

Keith Newton

I would suggest that you do some QC by splitting the off-cuts your laminates with a chisel. There was a time that I was with you, but after starting to destroy any ends or edges for Quality Control purposes, I changed my way, and always glue both sides.

I'm partial to epoxy for my bending, due to having control of the open time, and lubricating properties, which is especially important if using a thin veneer face on the inside of a bend. Quick grab glues will cause it to wrinkle instead of slip out toward the edges.

Epoxy also sets harder, which is less prone to creep against springback, and doesn't add any moisture to the wood.

Re: Gluing bent lams

#12

Re: Gluing bent lams

Hal

Thanks all. Lot of interesting thoughts. I take your dissertation to heart Bill. As the saying goes, sometimes you fall into a bucket of ..... and come out smelling like a rose. Because of procrastination, my lams were sawn and milled to thickness some 2+ weeks before I got around to the glue-up and living in So. AZ (south of Tucson), like Jesse my shop is pretty dry..maybe not as dry as Santa Fe. So I think the lams were pretty dry. Finally did the glue-up yesterday and took the clamps off this AM with negligible spring back. Will keep an eye on the creepiness. Thanks again for all the comments. Hal

Re: Gluing bent lams

#13

Re: Gluing bent lams

Barry Irby

If these are an arch or curve, you might put a bar clamp or other restraint across the ends to hold them for a few days.