Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

wood finish for walnut

Posts

wood finish for walnut

#1

wood finish for walnut

chrispy400623

I'm making a rustic and simple desk for my wife. The desk is made from a walnut slab approximately 3ft by 1.5 ft by 1.5ins+ thick and retains the wany edge and it's original curved shape. It has been sanded to 220 grit and looks good. My question is now how to finish it? Can I use BLO as is or do I need to make additional steps, either before or after the BLO. I like the idea of an oiled finish or is it just a PITA?? I could use wipe-on Polyurethane which I have used many times in the past, but this, hopefully, is an heirloom piece so I want something better! Thanks for any advice.

Chris

Re: wood finish for walnut

#2

Key words

David Yoho

To me there were two key words in your description that would provide the answer to your question - "rustic and simple". To that end I would use an oil finish. Since it's for your wife, where presumably it will be taken care of, you probably don't need to go with a hard top coat such as polyurethane. The good news is, should it require a harder finish later on, one can be applied over the oil finish.

Personally, I don't care for BLO. I would use something like Watco Danish Oil. I have a regimen I use with it on open pore woods like walnut. I just sent a reply today to another woodworker asking about this so I'll copy and paste it for your consideration.

The first coat I like to flood on with a foam brush and allow it to soak in as much as possible. Then I wipe off what remains and let it dry overnight. The next coat is where I apply it heavy but start working it with the 320 grit wet/dry paper and then wipe away the excess and let it set until the next day. The third and successive coats are applied lighter and rubbed with the 600 grit paper. I wipe away the excess each time but being careful not to pull away what’s accumulated in the pores. It’s like grouting tile. The slurry of oil and wood dust thickens to a paste-like consistency while rubbing and it fills the open pores, which leads to a nice smooth surface and finish.

Re: wood finish for walnut

#3

Re: wood finish for walnut

don stephan

Everyone has their own opinion, so I suggest you make some samples with finishes you are considering.

Boiled linseed oil even when well cured will water spot easily. If anyone ever sets a wet glass or spills liquid, . . .

Some feel a sanded oil finish looks ideal, on another forum in the last couple days I read comments that pores filled with sanding dust look terrible. Eyes of the beholder.

The desired final sheen may eliminate some possibilities. A linseed oil finish may never get beyond a matte sheen no matter how many coats are applied. A Danish oil finish may never get beyond a satin sheen.

If necessary, buy some walnut and try some finish options for you and yours to evaluate. Just be sure to complete on each sample the finish schedule you would use on the table.

Re: wood finish for walnut

#4

Clint Searl

Re: wood finish for walnut

Clint Searl

IMO, the only proper use for BLO is as an incendiary accelerant. BLO is also the primary component of "Danish oil" concoctions. Used to treat wood, it leaves a dull muddy ambering cast. If you really want to use oil, raw tung oil is what I prefer. It takes a while to cure, but it's clearer and more protective than BLO.

The proper finish is a poly, oil or waterborne, which can be rubbed out to any degree of sheen.

Re: wood finish for walnut

#5

Re: wood finish for walnut

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you go to the gallery and look for Mayberry, that desk is done with a wipe on varnish (don't recall the brand). The cheap finish is BLO.

Re: wood finish for walnut

#7

Re: wood finish for walnut

Don Evans

No matter what finish you go with consider a 1/4" think piece of glass to cover and protect the top.

A glass shop can make one the size you want and sand the sides and corners so they will not cut u.

Rather inexpensive considering.

Don

Re: wood finish for walnut

#8

Re: wood finish for walnut

chrispy400623

Thankyou Gentlemen for your thoughts and replies. After consideration I will probably go with my previous finishing schedule which is to use a 50/50 mixture of Helmsman spar varnish and Tung oil (From Home Depot), wipe on/wipe off several times, light sanding and then wiping on BLO as I like the texture of the oiled surface.

thanks

Chris

Re: wood finish for walnut

#9

Re: wood finish for walnut *LINK*

Dick Coers

Tung oil from Home Depot may just be a wiping varnish. Many mass marketed barely have any tung oil in them if any. So you may be adding spar varnish to thin varnish. Not sure what you gain. What brand is it? According to Bob Flexnor;

Common brands of finish that are wiping varnish:

Formby’s Tung Oil Finish

Zar Wipe-on Tung Oil

Val-Oil

Hope’s Tung Oil Varnish

Gillespie Tung Oil

Waterlox

General Finishes’ Sealacell

General Finishes’ Arm R Seal

Daly’s ProFin

Jasco Tung Oil

Common brands of finish that are oil/varnish blends:

Watco Danish Oil

Deft Danish Oil

Behlen Danish Oil

Maloof Finish

Behr Scandinavian Tung Oil Finish

Minwax Tung Oil Finish

Minwax Antique Oil Finish

Velvit Oil

Behlen Salad Bowl Finish

Behlen Teak Oil

Watco Teak Oil


Popular woodworking article

Re: wood finish for walnut

#10

Re: wood finish for walnut

chrispy400623

All I can tell you that the mixture that I mentioned produces a mix that I find is easy to use and is not so viscous as spar varnish alone, it meets my needs. Thanks for the info

regards

Chris

Re: wood finish for walnut

#11

you could have told more......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.....for example what "tung Oil" product you are using. If it is in fact one of the varnishes labeled "Tung Oil" then you would be better off omitting the spar varnish.

Spar varnish is varnish formulated with soft resin so that it remains flexible after curing. This is a critical attribute for spars and not what one wants for a table. It is formulated for outdoor use, an irrelevant attribute for a table. A product ideally formulate for your application would be a urethane wiping varnish- easy to apply and durable.