Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Need another opinion

Posts

Need another opinion

#1

Need another opinion

Bobinnp

besides mine . A friend of mine has an older dining room table. He had it refinished some time ago. They did a nice job, only problem is the finish is Danish oil I believe. This is a family with several grand kids and they entertain a lot. I want to help them out with a more durable finish. It is a very nice looking table, thus the lady of the house keeps its appearance very neat with frequent applications of lemon pledge and murphys.

My solution would be to wipe it down with acetone,( testing a small area first), lightly sand with 400. Then apply several coats of wipe on poly. Any guidance would help.

Bob

Re: Need another opinion

#2

Re: Need another opinion

Barry Irby

I would test for the presence of silicon. Not sure but I am suspicious of the Pledge.

Re: Need another opinion

#3

Re: Need another opinion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Wipe on may not be as durable as brush on oil based. Personally I would use a polyurethane floor finish. Thin it enough to flow well (about 3 parts finish to one part naptha or mineral spirits depending on how cold it is).

Re: Need another opinion

#4

JL

Re: Need another opinion

JL

I always am leery of putting another layer of finish on top of an existing unknown finish.

I would lean more towards a bit heavier sanding (220 grit then 300 grit). Whatever you do, make sure that the acetone has completely evaporated.

Behlen's Rockhard is another finish other than floor finish.

Re: Need another opinion

#5

I vote for a sheet of glass

Dick Coers

"Lemon pledge and Murphy's" scare me for adhesion with a film finish. Kids can be brutal to something with a thin film finish as well. I just discovered my second vessel that has adhesion problems with a wipe on poly finish. Finished about 4 years ago, and slight clouded spots on 1 vessel. The other vessel is so bad you can get your finger nail under the finish and take it off completely in those clouded spots. These were dyed maple, but can't remember if I used dewaxed shellac for the first coat back then or just went to the Minwax wipe on poly. Sure hope this isn't a trend for me, I sold several pieces during that period, all finished like that!

Re: Need another opinion

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Need another opinion

Jesper, Denmark

Sand With 120, spot coat of shellac. Two or more coats of semi gloss poly - I have had most luck with solvent based poly, not water.

Any problems with the previous finish will show up at the shellac stage and can be fixed.

Re: Need another opinion

#7

Re: Need another opinion

Bobinnp

Thank you. I will sand it down. And refinish from there . Thanks too all.

Bob

Re: Need another opinion

#8

Re: Need another opinion

Steve Schoene

The Pledge is likely to cause serious problems with a film finish applied over it, especially with a polyurethane. Sanding is NOT a good way to remove the silicone, and unless it is either removed or encapsulated it is likely to cause fisheyes in subsequent film finishes.

First I'd remove as much dirt as possible, starting with barely wet, barely soapy water. A few drops of dawn makes a good soap. Then I would use naphtha or other light mineral spirit to remove as much oily substance as you can. Remember to use lots of paper towels so you are wiping off the surface, not just wiping it around.

I would use a dewaxed shellac to try to seal in the silicone. It should be sprayed--brushing will just pull too much of the silicone into the shellac due to the mechanical action. Spray starting with several really dry coats. If you aren't equipped for spraying, use the Zinsser aerosol shellac, which is dewaxed. After a full coat you can then shift to a varnish product. I'd avoid polyurethane because it typically has more adhesion problems than non-poly varnish.

Frankly if the surface still looks good, I'd likely just stop with a cleaning.