Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

A problem needing a solution

Posts

A problem needing a solution

#1

A problem needing a solution

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


I finally found a spare(if and when needed) "cruiser" sized handle for my favorite ax. But, it is so fat that it would destroy the balance of the ax. It is too wide by 1/4" and too thick by 1/8".

The problem is how to spoke shave it to match the handle in the ax while preserving the shape and symmetry about the handle axis.

It would seem that if I could mark the depth of the wood to be removed, 1/16 from each face and 1/8 from each side I could then spoke shave to this depth mark and thereby preserve the symmetry. Or there might be another solution. Or I might hope that I was better spoke shaving symmetrically than I think I am and just go for it.

Any idea on how to proceed?

Re: A problem needing a solution

#2

Like dovetailing, it takes practice...

John in NM

You should be able to shave that down by eye. First few seem to take forever, but that is more the worry of screwing up than actual time. If you had to make six of them you'd be an old hand by the time you were done.

Man, if I lived where you do I'd probably never buy a handle again. All that nice straight hardwood, I'd be making them as needed - I have a duplicator that would get them close four at a time. Getting hard to find wood handles at all in hardware stores around here, let alone decently made ones.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#3

Re: Handle Sources *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

John and All,

Here's a couple of links for handles, though not anywhere as near as fast or convenient as running down to the local hardware store and picking one up, but as you said they are getting harder and harder to find.

I've ordered from House Handle, seemed like good prices and the service was good.

I have no experience with Tennessee Hickory Products.

http://www.tennesseehickoryproducts.com/

https://www.househandle.com/

Bob in NJ


https://www.househandle.com/

Re: A problem needing a solution

#4

Re: Like dovetailing, it takes practice...

Gary Smyth

I used a marker to do the outline of a "whip" handle I liked and used a belt sander (stationary, on its back) to work my way down the sides and around. The spokeshave I had was either too dull or had too much of a bevel and kept digging in to where I quickly shied away and searched for an alternative. With 80 grit it went quickly. Smoothed with a hand sander before stain. In the picture, the bottom two were from the same bin and purchased at the same time. Number 8 is not perfect, as fair, or as thin as the handle in #2, or the newly found #4, but it works for me. I kept the heavy fawn foot as it feels better for back of my hand.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#5

Re: A problem needing a solution

Rum

Mark 1 eyeball works for me for the layout, its not entirely rocket science just go slow and keep eyeballing down the lines to keep it straight. Marking the center lines can help some and then just remove an equal amount from either side of that then fair the curves.

I'd like to claim I do it all with a drawknife/spokeshave but I've had trouble keeping the curves fair so I mostly use rasps and files for the bulk of the work. I'll use a draw knife to rough but you aren't removing much material there so it would go pretty quick with a decent rasp.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#6

Re: A problem needing a solution

ben d.

My Grand Paw used to make all kind of handles many, many years ago and after he roughed them out he would do all the finish work with a piece of broken glass. when it dulled he would get another piece and keep going. Does not dig in and you can get it exactly as you want with no gouges or digs.

I have even used the same method on things but not like the 30's folks did.

Give it a try.

ben d.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#7

off center turning?

Dick Coers

That handle is so straight, you might be able to lay out 4 different centers, taking off the 1/8", move to another center and repeat, etc. Then blend into the head flare by hand. I've never done it, but seems possible.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#8

Re: A problem needing a solution

Brian Roberts

With a similar project in the past I used a Dremel tool with their small router base attachment.

I used a small dental burr extended to a depth that matched what I wanted to remove. I did several grooves in the area to be reduced and then used a spoke shave to bring the wood down to my routed gauge cuts.

Worked quite well actually.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#9

Re: A problem needing a solution

Joseph Mulherin, sr

I agree with your method of slimming the handle....with a very sharp blade and easy pressure on the tool to the wood.

An aside.... take a picture or make a drawing of the old handle and show the Tenneseehickoryproducts

the outline of the handle...top and side and the exact measurements you are comfortable with. They could make you a perfect handle for future use, but in the meantime go with your method as mentioned in your first message.....and use RUM's mention of the curved rasp file and sandpaper to finish.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#10

Re: A problem needing a solution

Ray Thompson

Laying flat as in the pic draw a line down the center, measure the width and take half of the overage off of one side; then take the other half off the other. Rotate the handle 90 degrees and make another line down the center, measure and take half off one side and half off the other. Blend to suit.

Ray

Re: A problem needing a solution

#11

Re: A problem needing a solution

Keith Newton

Right angle disk grinder, with coarse disk will make easy work of this.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#12

Re: A problem needing a solution

Barry Irby

My best friends father manufactured striking tool hands form the end of WWII till he passed away. He would have done this on a big horizontal belt sander. With him doing it it woudl have looked easy. He woudl have studied the old handle until you thought he had had a seizure and then taken the new one to the sander and reduced it down. Of course, tens of thousands of hours of "practice" helped.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#13

We have handles as well as trees

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

While our flea markets don't have old tools they all have numerous purveyors of handles of every kind (except Cruiser axes)- wheel barrow, post hole, mattox, hoe, shoves, hammers, etc.

Re: A problem needing a solution

#14

Re: Like dovetailing, it takes practice...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What is that strange handle on #4? And what is #6?

Re: A problem needing a solution

#15

Thanks for advice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am going to try Rum's suggested approach with a sharp spoke shave and Sureform rasp. .

Re: A problem needing a solution

#16

Re: Like dovetailing, it takes practice...

Gary Smyth

#4 is a barn find with a mismatched handle. I wanted the handle and got the ax head as a bonus. $3

#6 is what I've always known as a camp ax. Had since boy scout days

Note the thickness of the handles. The camp ax is about 9/16" and the dark 11/16". The fat newly store bought ax handle is 1" to 1 1/8" thick.


Re: A problem needing a solution

#17

Re: Like dovetailing, it takes practice...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The small ax is commonly called "cruiser". It is what I used. I am not big enough to swing effectively a large DB ax.