Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Solid panel questions

Posts

Solid panel questions

#1

Solid panel questions

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I am trying to decide how I want to make the panel for my wall clock's bottom door (top door is glass).

I have the rails and stiles cut, mortised/tenoned, and ready to go (glue up). Just need to make a panel to fit in the grooves. The panel will be maple. Not quarter sawn. The grooves in the frame are ~3/16" wide X 5/16" deep. The frame will accept a panel up to 17-7/8' X 8". The frame is made from 1/2" thick stock. All curly maple.

First question:

How much smaller should I make the panel to allow for movement in its width (the grooves are 5/16" deep)?

More questions:

I have numerous pieces of figured maple scraps, cut-offs, and so on to make the panel.

Should I take a piece and rip it down the middle and do book matched? I'll end up with a panel that has grain going in two directions, right? Not sure I'd like the look of that. I would wind up with two pieces that are over 4", glue them up to end up with one panel.

I'm thinking of making the panel thicker than 3/16" and using a plane to bring the edges down closer to 3/16 to fit the grooves. Thinking I would end up with a stronger/flatter panel that way. Kinda like a raised panel with the thicker side to the inside of the clock.

I could do a regular raised panel also with the raised field to the inside.

I guess I have lots of options. Just looking for some input/further ideas.

My biggest question is how much movement to allow for in the width of the panel.

Thanks a ton for any input.

Joe

Re: Solid panel questions

#2

Re: Solid panel questions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Unless the door gets submerged an 1/8" will be plenty.

I have made doors every way you enumerated. they all work. Use what ever you like.

Re: Solid panel questions

#3

Re: Solid panel questions

William Duffield

Esthetically, book matching curly maple is about the worst thing you can do to it (other than painting it), IMHO.

Re: Solid panel questions

#4

Re: Solid panel questions

Dick Coers

I usually allow 1% for the seasonal movement. 8" panel, .08". Depends a little on how dry your shop is right now. Around here, the stock is about as narrow as it will get all year. I prefer a book match pattern as the color of the wood is the same. Use two different boards and you can get two colors. Stock from the same tree, no worries about color. Traditional Shaker methods were to do a thick panel and bevel on the back side. It was first done with hand planes, and no vertical shadow line where the bevel meets the field. Just straight bevel.

Re: Solid panel questions

#5

Re: Solid panel questions

William Duffield

I should have explained why I don't like bookmatched curly maple. The problem is that the chatoyance of one face is always completely opposite the other face. When one appears to be rising, the other appears to be sinking at the same place. I find that very disconcerting.

I know the Shakers have always done it that way, but I really don't understand why they hide the raised panel inside the door. Maybe, like dovetails, it is considered a structural feature only, and shouldn't be celebrated. Maybe, they think the raised field detracts from the beauty of the natural figure of the wood.

Re: Solid panel questions

#6

Re: Solid panel questions

Grant in Iowa

Joe,

There are at least two good resources on the subject:

The first is over at WoodWeb, and is done under the supervision of Dr. Gene Wengert. The tool to use in this instance is Wood Shrinkage Calculator (there are other useful tools there, too). I put in flat sawn Hard Maple and a 12% initial moisture content. Then, I assumed it got taken to Phoenix and dried to 5% MC. The change in that case is about 3/16". You can play around to determine how much moisture change you need to accommodate for in your case. Here's the link: http://www.woodweb.com/Resources/RSCalculators.html

The second is a bit more refined, and may or may not be more useful for your needs. Woodworkerssource.com has this useful tool. You will also find useful information about average wood moisture equilibrium in your geographic area by clicking on the wood equilibrium chart link at the top before you begin. This is a factor many don't take in to account. An example would be if a person moved an item from Florida to Phoenix, the change in humidity is much larger than a person who hasn't traveled much might realize. Here's the link: http://www.woodworkerssource.com/movement.php

I would advise to plan for more movement than exists in your area. You never know where your decedents will end up living. I have lived in the Philippines, the Arabian Peninsula, Utah, California, and now Iowa. When I build things, I like to think the item may get passed down at least a couple generations. If you don't build for it, the item may get discarded when it self destructs upon arrival to another region.

Even if you don't plan on the project traveling, something else to think about is the type of home and the habits of the occupants. Here in Iowa, and old, drafty house in the depths of winter can be down under 5% RH, while a neighboring house might be at 40% if it has a better envelope and enough occupants. Similarly, an air conditioned, well sealed home can be in the same 40% range in summer, while the older home with the windows open could be at 80% at times. True, your wood won't immediately move to extremes, but long winters and hot, humid, & rainy summers have a real effect on wood moisture content within homes and the wooden objects they contain.

Here in Iowa, I always try to build interior projects with lumber that is around 10-12% moisture content, which is on the low side of the outdoor equilibrium for my area. Since I am building largely for indoor use, this works out pretty well for me. I have friends who build exclusively with Kiln Dried lumber, and (at least in my area) they must plan for the wood to move towards the 10-14% equilibrium we have in our area.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Solid panel questions

#7

Re: Solid panel questions

Dick Coers

I think it was all about being simple and plain William. Not even sure they would have used curly maple. Not on purpose anyway.

Re: Solid panel questions

#8

Re: Solid panel questions

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I could very well be remembering this wrong, I would need to look at some of my books to confirm, but I seem to recall reading there are generally considered to be three periods of Shaker furniture: Early/Primitive, Classic, and Victorian.

Classic I think is what most of us are accustomed to seeing reproduced in magazines. The Victorian era/period, the later years of the Shakers, produced a lot of pieces using figured woods and much more fancy designs.

Even during the classic period, a lot of their furniture was painted with bright colors.

Joe

P.S.

I am not crazy about using this curly maple on this clock. I should have used Cherry. It should look ok though. As long as I don't paint it with blue milk paint...

Re: Solid panel questions

#9

curly wood

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think the curly wood will look appropriate for the clock. The clock is a plain design that the curl should enhance and not clash.

Re: Solid panel questions

#10

Re: curly wood

Barry Irby

Rather than a book match, I would suggest you try, at least look at a slip match. Who ever suggested the book match might produce a odd effect might be right.