Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Bosch alternative to SawStop

Posts

Bosch alternative to SawStop

#1

Bosch alternative to SawStop

charlie belden

http://www.woodmagazine.com/blogs/woodworking-blog/2015/03/16/bosch-develops-tablesaw-with-blade-brake-safety/

Re: Bosch alternative to SawStop

#2

Re: Bosch alternative to SawStop

William Duffield

That's really good news. Bravo to Bosch! It may now force the other saw manufacturers to add the technology to their saws. They have delayed way too long, unlike automobile manufacturers, who government regulations have forced to add critical life saving improvements to their vehicles. Of course, lots more people are maimed and killed in auto accidents than in woodshop table saw accidents.

I would like someone to compare the time it takes a SawStop to stop the blade vs. Bosch's time to retract the whole blade, brake and trunnion below the table top. If it is slower than SawStop's technology, then the average severity of injuries would be greater, but still far less than everyone else's. (I'm not saying Bosch is slower; they may be just as fast, or even faster.)

In case anyone missed the announcement, SawStop now also has a jobsite saw.

Re: Bosch alternative to SawStop

#3

Interesting....

John in NM

Bosch doesn't wreck the blade, and the cartridge is reused once by flipping it over. Neat.

As William says, the real question is whether it is as effective, since it has no braking system.

It will also be interesting to see if this is similar enough in design (the idea of dropping the blade is also a Sawstop feature, IIRC) to get into a patent dispute. Perhaps the Sawstop patent is up now, it's getting pretty close in any case.

Re: Bosch alternative to SawStop

#4

Re: Interesting....

William Duffield

Yes, the SawStop method also drops the blade. I emphasized the stopping, because it is done more quickly than the retraction, and most of the damage is done by the moving blade. I've put my hand into a stopped tablesaw blade, and only needed a band-aid. Of course, that is anecdotal, not a rigorous, statistical study. A stopped blade can still do some damage, but it is insignificant compared to what a moving blade can do.

Re: Bosch alternative to SawStop

#5

Re: Interesting....

Bill Howatt

From what I've read the SawStop jams the blade and this energy is used to also drop the blade. The Bosch system uses its sophisticated air-bag technology, suitably adapted, to very quickly drop the blade. Stopping the blade with a disc brake seems to be a secondary consideration. This site

http://www.protoolreviews.com/tools/power/corded/saws/bosch-reaxx-table-saw-gts1041a-preview/14811/

says they thought the Bosch system dropped the blade in 50 microseconds but they did not have that number confirmed from Bosch.

I'd like to know the sensing mechanism. Wet wood apparently will fire off the SawStop and who has been on a jobsite where all the wood was bone dry?

Bill

Re: Bosch alternative to SawStop

#6

As a satisfied Sawstop owner

Neal in San Jose

The firing with wet wood is less of an issue than you might have been led to believe. If in doubt, with the saw not running, simply contact the blade with the suspect wood. The safety circuit will test the conditions and will light a light if the brake will fire in use. You can then choose to override the safety circuit and saw the wet wood as with a "normal"(non sensing) table saw, then you reset the circuit. The circuit will reset itself the next time the saw is turned on if you forget.

The only time I have fired mine was the way your are "supposed to". I stuck my index finger into the running blade. It works! The cost of a new blade and new brake cartridge was less than my emergency room deductible would have been with a "normal" saw.

Re: Bosch alternative to SawStop

#7

Re: Bosch alternative to SawStop

Jesse Cloud

It will be interesting to see detailed specs and prices on the Bosch saw. I've been thinking about swapping my old Unisaw with the 50 inch fence for something smaller.

In the meantime, a couple of interesting facts.

We did the math when the Sawstop came out... Lets round off and say your blade spins at 1800 rpm, with a 40 tooth blade, thats 72,000 teeth per minute, 1,200 per second, and 1.2 per microsecond. So that 5 msec stop time sends 6 teeth through your finger. Way better than the alternative, but not trivial either.

Also, when the Sawstop brake goes off, it doesn't necessarily ruin the blade. At the school I went to we just had a couple or three teeth replaced, way cheaper than a good blade.

Re: Bosch alternative to SawStop

#8

Re: Interesting....

William Duffield

First, it depends on how wet it is, and it's far from "bone dry" that a trigger might occur. If you think you are cutting soggy wood, there is a simple test. Before you turn it on, push the board against the side of the blade. An indicator light will show whether it is wet enough to trigger the brake. If so, you can override the brake with a simple turn of a key. The override remains in effect until you hit the stop switch.

The Bosch saw has a similar sensing mechanism, so it should also have a problem with tripping on cutting wet wood.

Re: Bosch alternative to SawStop

#9

Re: Bosch alternative to SawStop

William Duffield

That should be 1.2 per millisecond, not per microsecond. That's a three orders of magnitude difference. One of the reviews made the same mistake. I'm being picky. I think we all knew what you meant. The numbers I've heard, but I don't think are published, for the SawStop is 3 msec. to stop, 5 msec. to retract. Don't quote me on that. It might be different for the contractor's saw and the job site saw.

Re: Bosch alternative to SawStop

#10

Re: Bosch alternative to SawStop

TomD

Aren't saws around 4000 RPM? Either way, you don't get X teeth through your fingers, each tooth is taking a tiny bite, there are say 60 teeth, that is 240 000 tooth contacts a minute, 1/4 million. They hardly scratch the surface.

Re: Bosch alternative to SawStop

#11

Re: Bosch alternative to SawStop

Barry Irby

I was thinking the same thing. I believe my saw motor runs at 3600 RPM and the pulleys are similar in size so the blade MAY be turning 5000 rpm.

Either way, I have no experience with either the Sawstop or the Bosch, but I do have some experience with my Delta TS and either one would be a lot better than the absence of any brake.