Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

finish question: Stain lifting

Posts

finish question: Stain lifting

#1

finish question:  Stain lifting

Gary Kittleson

I am finishing the sewing machine cabinet: I have stained it to my wife's desire (too dark for my taste, but..). I'm using General Finish wiping stain. I'm adding a coat of dewaxed shellac on that, and planning on Poly on top for protection. When I'm brushing the shellac on, it is lifting the stain - brush turning color, stain uneven on the wood now -

Why is this happening? I thought the shellac should be good to go on top of the stain...

Lots to learn, apparently..

Re: finish question: Stain lifting

#2

Ellis Walentine

Solubility

Ellis Walentine

Clearly, the stain is being dissolved by the solvent in the shellac, presumably methyl/ethyl alcohol. You didn't mention which General Finishes stain you're using. I recall that they offer waterbased and oil based products. My suggestion is follow Michael Dresdner's advice: "Finish Firewood First," that is, to prepare some test boards before you commit to a finishing sequence, to make sure you are using compatible products and that the final result is what you want. It beats starting over.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: finish question: Stain lifting

#3

Re: finish question:  Stain lifting

Howard Acheson

Is your stain a waterbased or oil based stain? In general as Ellis said, the alcohol thinner in your shellac is dissolving the stain. Most waterbased stains will be dissolved by alcohol. The best way to top coat a waterbased stain is by spraying. Brushing and wiping will dissolve and smear the stain.

Re: finish question: Stain lifting

#4

Re: finish question:  Stain lifting

William Duffield

It's not obvious from the labels whether the General Finishes stain you are using is a dye stain (water based) or a pigment stain (oil based or solvent based). You have to read the fine print on the back of the can. I'm exaggerating: You can tell which General stain you are using by the color of the can, and if you get a little closer it's printed on the front: Red for oil based, or a row of pine trees around the bottom of the can for water-based products).

If you can't spray a light barrier coat of shellac over the stain, then you should be using an oil based stain. They have an advantage in that they will not fade over time, but a disadvantage in that the pigments are opaque, and therefore hide the figure of the wood to a small extent.) General uses very finely ground pigments to minimize this effect. Also, it smells bad. That's a warning that it is probably more hazardous than the dye stains. General's SDS's can be found through this link: https://generalfinishes.com/msds-technical-data