Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

Posts

How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

#1

Bart Goldberg

How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

Bart Goldberg

I have a friend who has an kitchen island that has a "long grain" maple Butcher block top. It is fairly old, and has cupped badly (across the glued up edges). The island base was originally a cabinet, and he had a new open base built it to replace the old cabinet base. It looks like when the old top was screwed to the new base, the shop that built the new base attempted to "pull" the warp out of the butcher block when screwing it to the new base. This has now caused the top to complete split and separate into to halves along its center glue line.

I would like to try and re-flatten the top before gluing the two halves back together and before reinstalling on the new base. I was thinking to rip the remaining halves to a size that I can send through my planer, re-joint the exposed edges to be square to the top, then re-glue. Will this work, or is there a better way?

Thanks

Bart

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

#2

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

Tom Dunlap

I've been looking at various router-planer jigs. Lots of ideas out there.

Tom

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

#3

Bart Goldberg

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

Bart Goldberg

Tom,

Are you suggesting I build a router/planer jig to re-flatted the two halves? Not sure I understand your reply?

Bart

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

#4

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

Howard Acheson

It would be helpful if you could post a couple of photos.

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

#5

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

Barry Irby

I think what you propose will work, but you are going to lose about a 1/4 Inch at each rip, somewhere between 1/2" and 3/4" total off the width. Can you stand that? Will the top end up being too narrow"

The other thing to think about is why did it warp to begin with? I am assuming its concave across the top. I would have assumed it woudl get wet on the upper surface, expand and tend to become convex. It might be wise to understand why it warped so that if you fix it it won't just warp again, or unwarp (?) and try to go back to what woudl have been flat. Is this a seasonal issue or has it warped and remained warped?

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

#6

Ellis Walentine

Your idea sounds good to me

Ellis Walentine

You'll end up losing a bit of thickness, and you'll have to refinish (both sides of) the top after you glue it back up, but it's probably the easiest way to fix this.

It would be good to know how the block will be used. i.e., for actual cutting or not. This will determine how you will want to finish the top. We've had a lot of discussions about butcher block and cutting board finishes here in recent years, and several finishes have been recommended for boards that will be used for cutting, including mineral oil, vegetable oil, walnut oil, beeswax/oil mix, and probably others. If the butcher block itself will not be cut into, any water resistant finish will do. I finished the maple counter top in my new kitchen with four coats of Helmsman spar-urethane and it is holding up beautifully. Polyurethane is very abrasion-resistant, so it stands up well to plates and things being slid on it every day. I do all my cutting on portable cutting boards.

The upshot here is that you want to prevent future cupping, so I'd recommend planing your ripped pieces on both sides to expose fresh wood, and then to let them acclimate for a while, cup side down, on sticks, in a heated space, with good ventilation, for a couple weeks if you have the time. This will give the MC a chance to equalize a bit. Then check to see if they're still flat and, if not, flatten them again before gluing the whole top back together. This may sound like overkill, but the cupped surface indicates to me that there is still a lopsided moisture gradient in the top. And make sure you allow for expansion and contraction when you reattach the top to the base.

Ellis

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

#7

Bart Goldberg

Re: Your idea sounds good to me

Bart Goldberg

Hi Ellis!

Thanks for the detailed reply. The top is used for cutting, so I would stick with the mineral oil, and perhaps my waxy mineral oil concoction as a finish.

I need to take measurements to see how wide the pieces are, but as Mark Mandel pointed out, if I use my planer, I need to support the underside of the cup to ensure the planer rollers don't flatten the board while getting planed. Also, I need to take light cuts with my planer to avoid any tearout. Mark did offer to let me use his wide belt sander, and I may consider this versus using my planer.

Regards

Bart

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

#8

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

John Veerkamp

It may not be really cupped, but worn from repeated use in the lowest area. Look at old cutting boards, they're often dished out. Antique butcher blocks are almost always dished from use.

The wide belt sanding option sounds like the best bet.

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

#9

Bart Goldberg

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

Bart Goldberg

John,

It is not dished in the middle from use.

It is like a huge "C" from end to edge. Not one piece of it is flat.

I am sure that the cause of the warp issue was due to uneven moisture exposure of many years of use.

Thanks

Bart

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

#10

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

Jesse Cloud

I think your idea is a good one. The only reason for a router sled would be if the piece were too wide to fit in your planer. I would run each piece thru the planer at the final height a few times just to be sure the height is spot on and both sides match perfectly.

Also, be sure to mount it in a way that will allow movement.

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

#11

Be prepared to buy some belts

Dick Coers

Wood that has an oil finish will clog sanding belts almost immediately. It's a combination of the heat and the oil.

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

#12

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Why go thru all the fuss and bother....just make a new top and be done with it.

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

#13

Bart Goldberg

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

Bart Goldberg

Fixing this top is rather simple and easy to be honest. Mush less work and less cost then starting from scratch.

Bart

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

#14

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

Joseph Mulherin, sr

OK, then how many glued up boards are in the top which have any sort of curl in them? If many I would suggest cutting them on the bandsaw to get small kerfs , then run them thru the jointer to get even edges, then reglue as many as can be done to fit thru your planer, then reglue the final joint to get the final top fitting level and smooth.This technique should give you and your friend a nice counter top which will last for a few more years. And finish the cutting board with vegetable oil....saturated and finally wiped clean. Tell them to wipe the board with more vegetable oil at least once a month.

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

#15

Bart Goldberg

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

Bart Goldberg

Joe, not sure of the number of boards yet. Will know after I bring the top back to my home shop later today. I agree with your idea of using the bandsaw to cut up the pieces - and have a smaller kerf cut. Also, a bit safer then the TS given that the top isn't flat to begin with.

Bart

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

#16

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

david weaver

I would hand plane the high spots on the individual parts, glue it together, and then do the same again. I know that's not viewed highly here, but it wouldn't take long and it would involve the least wood loss.

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

#17

Re: How to re-flatten ButcherBlock Top?

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Yes, Dave, I agree, do the hand plane as you said then determine what has to be done after.