Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

WC Weekend Accomplishments....

Posts

WC Weekend Accomplishments....

#1

WC Weekend Accomplishments....

Dennis E Peacock

16 Mar 2015

Good Morning Everyone,

Been a very busy week of oncall duty. I'm hoping to get some sleep tomorrow since I'm taking the day off. Got the nightstand finished and the customer picked it up tonight. It gets shipped to his daughter in California this coming week. The guitar building project is still under way but took a weeks break due to oncall duty at the day job.

That's it for me, so what did YOU do this past weekend?

Best of weeks to you all.

Dennis Peacock

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments....

#2

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments.... *LINK*

William Duffield

I went down to Suffolk, VA, and gave a presentation to the Tidewater local SAPFM chapter on my Latta Bench-on-Bench and the Moxon vise I added to it, explaining how to use it, how to build it, with lots of options and potential problems. Perhaps more important, I got to listen to a presentation by Don Williams on traditional finishing techniques and materials (You know, the finish the Keno brothers explain how you have destroyed about 90% of the value of your rare antique when you stripped it off and refinished with polyurinate :( ). Our gracious host was Chris Vickers of highly recommended Somerton Ridge Hardwoods.


Somerton Ridge Hardwoods

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments....

#3

Flexner on the finish topic

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Bob Flexner wrote something on the topic of refinishing antiques to respond to the Antiques Roadshow view of the topic. It is worth a read if someone knows where to find it. The summary, as I recall it, goes something like....If the piece was so little used that it still has its original finish then it is valuable more because its pristine condition than just because it has its original finish. Conversely, if something looks so shabby from use/misuse that you wouldn't have it in your living room, then by all means refinish it.

To that end I just refinished the stock of a 80 year old shotgun. Otherwise the wood was going to be ruined as I continued to use it to hunt with. Ditto for a 90 year old oak china cabinet that was too ugly for anyone to want. Refinished it occupies a central position in my daughters dining room.

I have to agree with Flexner. The opinion of the Antiques Roadshow is misleading.

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments....

#4

Antiques Roadshow

Hank Knight

There's a lot about Antiques Roadshow that's misleading.

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments....

#5

Exception....

John in NM

When it comes to really high end antiques, that rule doesn't seem to hold true (I've found it does with middling stuff, like everything I own).

I have an auction catalog my sister picked up somewhere, full of the kind of stuff that the Keno's go nuts over. One piece in it is a Georgian mahogany dresser that had significant fire damage. Still was expected to go for $12k or so by the auction house.

Keeping with the gun analogy, that dresser was the equivalent of an original Henry rifle - worth far more in original beat to death condition than professionally refinished.

Twentieth century Winchesters follow the rule though - they are worth about the same in poor original condition as in refinished condition.

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments....

#6

collector vs user

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Something that looks like crap might be valuable to a collekctor and worth less to someone wanting to use it . If one intended to actually use say a dresser with comprimised finsih and joinery, fixing it is a must no matter. But it is all irrrelevant for the market for 18th century furniture is dwindling.

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments....

#7

Yes, that is the point...

John in NM

If it's worth more to a collector, my inclination is to sell it to one and get something worth nothing to them but worth something to me. I've never owned any furniture of that grade, but I have owned guns and tools that approached it. Sold anything that people would pay what I considered an absurd price for.

For various reasons, I'm not interested in possessing items that have collector value - mostly because I do not understand the collector impulse. I recognize that someone might pay more for some burnt up mahogany than I would for a car, but I don't understand it :D

The exception I mention is where I get rid of stuff. I'm much more comfortable in the area Flexner was describing :D I've occasionally profited from the exception though, at least in a small way :D

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments....

#8

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments....

Mark Nowicki

Spent the whole Saturday in the shop without interruptions, a rare event.

Worked on the bathroom vanity, mostly ripping jatoba strips and edge-band panels. Installed the drawer slides, build an angle setting jig for my Eclipse guide, played around with some old chisels and plane blades.



Sunday, took a drive to Ottawa to pick up my new old tool, the INCA 259 table saw. Had a nice chat with the seller and admired his shop, his Felder and his hand tool wall which included every plane that LeeValley and Lie-Nielsen makes, plus a few Conrad Sauer and Wayne Anderson products.


It has been over 20 years since I have used a table saw and I have forgotten just about everything.

Mark

Re: WC Weekend Accomplishments....

#9

Doing what's right

David Yoho

Years ago when my shop was full throttle and work was constantly coming in the door I was doing as much refinishing and restoration jobs as I was new builds. I had a couple of customers that kept me very busy with furniture they brought in for refinishing. I saw a lot of stuff in that period and only once was there a piece I refused to do anything to. It was an old Stickley piece that was in pretty good shape and I felt removing the finish would lower its value. I advised the customer to check around with his network of antique dealers and see what they said. Turned out I was right and the guy thanked me later.

The bulk of the furniture I refinished was old but didn't have any monetary or historical value. Even then, when I did any repairs I used methods and hardware as close to original as I could. Always I would consult with the customer and examine the piece to decide what the work entailed before quoting a price and made sure they were on board with the work to be done.

I actually had one occasion where the customer brought me a very old wardrobe asking to have it stripped and refinished. The look on his face was priceless when I told him it didn't need it and I wouldn't do it. He was only looking at it like all the other pieces I'd done for him and didn't give the existing finish a good look. I explained that I'd be glad to dig deep into his pocket if that was what he really wanted but he would pay me much less if I was allowed to clean and polish what was there and he wouldn't know the difference. He went along with my suggestion and in the end was very pleased with the results. There was nothing wrong with the old finish that a good cleaning and polishing wouldn't fix.

The point is most of what I worked on was run-of-the-mill antiques. Most were handed down through the families but some were purchased. The only real value was either sentimental or to fill a need. I never refinished something that didn't need it and those that didn't were treated with techniques I learned from a professional conservator in Charlottesville. I believe in the idea that disturbing the finish (cleaning included) of some antiques, especially those of historical significance, does reduce their value and to that end would never touch them myself.