Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

Posts

Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#1

Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

Barry Irby

There is a long post (or group of posts) about the inverters for lathes on the Turning forum. It seems they are out dated and out of production after a few years.

Yesterday I watched a segment of This Old House and they were touting a HVAC system with all sorts of dampers and a digital thermostat. As a Home Inspector in a very conservative part of the country I have seen about a half a dozen systems with zoning dampers. None of them was set up and working properly.

I was in the market for a car and some of them were "Powered by Microsoft". My son, who builds computers and is far more into it than I have ever been, snorted and said, "Microsoft never supports anything for more than ten years."

I admit I am turning into an old Fuddy Duddy, but am I the only one that sees these things and is skeptical? I thought a lathe was supposed to last a lifetime, or more. Your ten year old or his grand dad should be able to operate your HVAC system. And I tend to drive my cars a long time, with ten years being the first step. What happened to the KISS principle? Durability?

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#2

not only electronic controls

Dick Coers

Some manufacturers won't support any parts on 10 year old machines, let alone the electronics. The simple word discontinued shows up way too often, and way too soon. Don't get me started on the expected lifespan on major appliances.

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#3

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

Bill Howatt

The addition of electronics turns anything into the fast obsolescence environment. Look at expensive cameras, they use to be virtually a one-time purchase now the new ones come out faster than new cars with more features you supposedly must have. The old quality cameras held their value - the new ones depreciate like a new car.

If you have a VFD that is not a custom unit that must be physically part of the machine you can replace it with a different model so not all is lost by any means.

Even if MS doesn't support your 10 year old car anymore, what's the big deal? Presumably after a lot less than 10 years it is debugged and working as intended. You may not get the new features but the owners of the Model T found that out too when the Model A was put on the market too. If one of the pieces using the MS software breaks then it is up to the dealer to provide a new one. The other main competitor in car software is actually Blackberry with its QNX software.

When you install an complex system be it HVAC or anything else then it requires more knowledge to set it up and run it. The problem is in the setup and if it is done properly then it should be fine. The homeowner really shouldn't have to know the equipment other than what button to push to make it go. Like driving a car without knowing how the transmission works. A bit simplistic perhaps but if you want to have the presumable best comfort at what is hopefully the most economical cost then you have to do things like this. Of course, in the old KISS days nobody was trying to heat 3500 sq-ft plus size houses.

Bill

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#4

Disposable Culture

Hank Knight

Barry, we have been growing ( I guess that's the right term) into a disposable culture for many years. I remember when you returned milk bottles to the dairy to be refilled and delivered back to your front door. Soft drink bottles were returned and were worth 2 cents each. It started with little things like one-use, throw-away containers and grew from there. Now our throw-away culture encompasses just about everything. You can buy a new TV for little more than it would cost to get the old one repaired - IF you could find someone to repair the old one. Things become obsolete in a blink of an eye. I had a problem with my 2 year old Sony flat screen TV the other day and called Sony's customer service line for help. I was told that the TV was no longer supported by telephone and that I might be able to find help online - for a fee. I figured out the fix while I fumed and tried to reach Sony's online CS chat room, which I believe to be unreachable.

I had a 1996 Jeep Grand Cherokee, that I bought new in '96 and maintained meticulously. It ran like a top, but it developed an electrical problem that drained the battery in 2 days when the car sat idle. I spent several hundred Dollars on unsuccessful attempts to have the problem repaired. The last attempt ended when the jeep service department told me they thought they had isolated the problem in the wiring behind the dashboard and it would cost me $300.00 for them to remove the dash so they could continue to investigate. They still weren't sure they had the problem diagnosed. Thanks, but no thanks. The problem had already cost me a bundle. I donated the car to charity and bought a new one. The new one is hi tech, wired into the Internet and has all kinds of wiz-bang electronic features. I'll bet money that I won't get 5 years use out of it, if that, before it becomes "unsupported" and obsolete. Then I guess I'll throw it away like a milk carton and buy a new one.

Sorry for the long rant, but your post hit a nerve.

Hank

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#5

Re: You are not the only one.

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I despise the fact that almost all of the major manufactures are adding electronics to major appliances that have absolutely no real advantage to the users except to dazzle with bright displays. The timers used in the 1950's on ranges worked well for extended lengths of time and were usually easy and fairly cheap to replace. Today's electronic displays don't really do much if anything to enhance cooking and if one function fails it requires replacement of the entire (expensive) module. Refrigerators and even freezers are the same. Don't even ask about dishwashers and Clothes washers.

When I was in high school (in the 1950's) I started a business repairing small appliances, from toasters, irons, fans, TV's, Radios etc. I grant you the cost in man hours of work was way higher to purchase one of these at the time, but the useful life was almost infinite. The old Sunbeam Toasters did a far better job of making evenly toasted bread than 99% of the units today. They were designed well for both function and repair. Same was true for 99% of the appliances of the time. I worked on many 20 year old appliance and repaired them to new condition for a very reasonable charge. I don't know of ANY appliances made today with repair in mind.

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#6

Re: You are not the only one.

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

The female end of the driver's seat belt on my 2004 F-150 failed two weeks ago. It would not catch the male end, a non-electrical problem. NC law requires seat belts. Alarm every thirty seconds if not latched. Half of seat belt $239 plus sales tax, $90 installation because seat has to be removed to get access to attachment bolt. OUCH! Bah Humbug!

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#7

Re: You are not the only one.

Barry Irby

I just bought a $3200 Fridge. Has a display on the door that ALWAYS says 37 and 0 degrees. I thought it was amazing that it could do such an accurate job of maintaining the temp. Then I realized its displaying the SET points and not the actual temp. Seems like a pretty useless bit of info.

It seems to me the people that design these things must not use them. Or maybe they make a lot more money than I do.

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#8

Bill, Double check....

Barry Irby

The seat belt failed in my Honda. The "stalk" part that was bolted to the floor. Found out that the safety equipment had a lifetime warranty. Had to push on the dealer a bit, but they replaced it free. (The body shop that was working on the car was going to charge me until I said I woudl get one from the junk yard. Then they fessed up and sent me to the dealer.)

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#9

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

BrianMonumentCO

Remember that the only time microsloth wont make something that doesn't sux is when it makes vacumn cleaners.

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#10

You have that right....

John in NM

We liked our old fridge (circa 1995) so much that we bought the same model for the new house (2005). The new one had a circuit board to handle auto defrost, instead of the simple and inexpensive clockwork used for decades before. Board failed within 3 years of buying the thing, rather than replace a $200 board every few years, we opt to defrost like in the old days.... progress!

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#11

2014 Honda Civic

Mark Nowicki

I bought one slightly over a year ago, this is the cheapen down version that the Consumer Report panned.

So far, Honda has replaced a squeaky heater fan twice. The dealer always provides with a courtesy car for the duration of the repairs.

I need the courtesy car because the book time for heater fan replacement on a 2014 Civic is 14 hours (@ $102.95/hr shop rate)

They need 14 hours because to access the fan they need to remove the heater core, and to remove the heater core they have to remove the entire front panel, the airbags, all the controls, the whole smash.

At my rate, the car will be out of warranty in about two months. As much as I enjoycar repairs, this is not something I am looking forward to.

Mark

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#12

Re: You are not the only one.

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

Lots of displays make sense to the programmer and not the user.

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#13

This is a downside to capitalism . . .

CJ in MPLS

Unfortunately, the folks that are aware that it is a downside are far outnumbered by those that don't, so it is unlikely to change anytime soon.

What is kind of cool is that the whole concept of "makers" offers a possible solution here. You need to find a kid that will hook up a Raspberry Pi and some appropriate daughter boards to your lathe. ;)

The downside of this solution is that the Raspberry Pi will then keep track of how often you use the lathe and then share your stats with friends and with bots that will try to sell you new turning tools.

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#14

you folks have selective memories

Jerry Gibbs

Most of the cars made in the 60s and 70s were junk. I did a lot of work on my wife's 67 Mustang. It looked pretty, but it was terribly engineered and was dangerous. Remember when folks bought an new car every two years? There was a reason. My 05 Highlander is running fine with 100k miles. In the 60s anything past 70k was borrowed time.

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#15

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

Stuart Hough

My parents bought a brand new Fridgidaire refrigerator/freezer in 1966. We had it through 2 moves in 10 years. Then when we moved for the final time before I got married Dad asked Mom if she wanted a new fridge. She said "Hell no! This thing is built like a tank!" That fridge lasted 22 years before a leak developed and the compressor burned up. Things are engineered for a life cycle that lasts only as long as the projected R & D for the next "Great New Thing". I did my research for the last fridge I bought my wife, and it has held up for 12 years now...no bells, no whistles. The only problem was a faulty gear drive on the ice-maker. Got a replacement unit from Whirlpool and have had zero trouble for 8 years. Most of the problems, from what I have found, is that most of the folks buying things nowadays are younger folks who don't understand the concept of maintaining your cars, appliances, whatever. Just buy another, toss the old one, and complain about how we are killing the environment with the refuse. JMHO

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#16

Start disassembly in backseat to remove glovebox

GolfSteve in Calgary

To take off the glovebox door of a 2001 VW golf, you start disassembling the car in the back seat. No bull.

(It's actually not a hard or long job, but you take off the centre console around the stick shift first, then some trim around the radio in order to access the left glovebox hinge....but you do start the job in the back seat).

As much as I hate a lot of electronic doo-dads, the electronic diagnosis tools built into the car are wonderful if you have the software to read the codes. For my VW, a $300 interface cable has saved me plenty of money at the mechanic.

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#17

Re: you folks have selective memories

Jesse Cloud

Jerry's right.

Same with computers. They were huge, cranky, and damn hard to program and operate.

The CDC and DEC repairmen pretty much lived on site. Any problem was blamed on a hairline crack in some board. The tech would replace it with another board that would fail the next week.

My jobs generally had to wait for the weekend. The computer was less busy then and even with my labs low priority we could get 512k of ram the program needed.

I remember being on a waiting list for six months to pay $150 in 1970's dollars for a Texas Instruments calculator that did square roots.

And, yep, now that Walmart sells computers much more powerful that last longer and yep, when they break its often more economical to throw them away.

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#18

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

Randy Johnson

One of the many now defunct industries that once made my town boom was American Kitchens.

At one time, the products they produced were a common sight in many of the post WW II houses in the area. Metal wall and floor cabinets....and round topped Philco refrigerators. The refrigerators were also made here. A few years ago I was turning on the gas for a house that had had a service interruption and walked into a kitchen that hadn't changed since the day it was installed in the early fifties. I was born 6/30/52. The fridge was one month older than me, and was working perfectly. They don't build 'em like that anymore. For what it's worth, the cabinets were a little short on style, but they were built like tanks. The garages and basements in this town are full of them. They were/are too good to throw away.

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#19

Re: you folks have selective memories

Bill Howatt

My father used to own a garage where i was forced labor :). You are absolutely correct, today's cars are so much more reliable and maintenance free that there is absolutely no comparison. Back then, any car still running at over 100K miles was held in awe. Most cars that hit 70K were burning oil and likely in need of a valve job.

People fretted when the few or no grease-fittings appeared, and there were some premature failure issues with them, but my 2005 Grand Caravan at 120,000 miles is still on the original steering components and doesn't know what a grease gun looks like.

Safety, none, compared to a modern car.

Bill

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#20

Some how we/they are missing the point.....

Barry Irby

I can't put my finger on it, but there is a disconnect in the thinking.

HVAC contractors sell equipment based on size. Larger equipment sells for more money. They have no incentive to tell you to insulate and weather strip better.

If you are building a new house you can insulate so well that the HVAC operating cost is very low, therefore it does not matter much how sophisticated the equipment is. Thus, adding $5000 in dampers and fancy thermostats does not make as much sense if your bill is $50 a month and the new equipment saves you 20%.

And it does not pay to be an early adopter of this stuff. My experience was that it broke down very early and the guys that showed up to work on it literally said "Gawlee, we ain't never seened one of these before." And that was a heat pump with a variable speed fan.

OTOH, my son thought the thermostat you could access through your cell phone app was "Way Cool". He thought it was better to do it that way than to reach up and adjust the damper with his hand seasonally.

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#21

Cars are one of the few exceptions...

John in NM

To my dislike of new-fangledness. Reliability and safety were indeed vastly improved in the 1990's.

Based on a friend's Tahoe work truck, I believe they are now on a retrograde trend, but that may be an outlier.

Now if they could just do something about the gawd awful styling of new cars!

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#22

Re: Some how we/they are missing the point.....

Jesse Cloud

"And it does not pay to be an early adopter of this stuff. My experience was that it broke down very early and the guys that showed up to work on it literally said "Gawlee, we ain't never seened one of these before." And that was a heat pump with a variable speed fan."

Yeah, I remember being a 'early adopter' of a VW beetle in Texas. I remember a breakdown somewhere in rural Texas. We were towed to the local garage in one of those "wide place in the road" towns where the mechanic, once he found the engine said "Shoooeee! Is that one of them bugs?" I nearly had a heart attack. But to his credit, he made some calls and sent his boy to Austin to pick up a part. Two days later we were on the road. Even with the long distance calls and the courier service to Austin and back, the bill was quite reasonable.

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#23

Re: Some how we/they are missing the point.....

John McGaw

Actually, the whole design/implementation of a super-insulated super-tight house places one on the bleeding edge. A lot of mistakes have been made along the way as people stumbled toward their ideal and a lot of the early adopters suffered expense and illness as a result. You could, right now, build a house which would require essentially no heating input in even a cold climate by depending on waste heat and solar gain. But if you lived in such a house you might still wish for some sort of HVAC system with zoned control when you discover that some of the house is ten degrees warmer than you like and another ten degrees cooler.

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#24

Re: Some how we/they are missing the point.....

John in NM

A friend of mine has a great story about an early bug owner pulling into a full service gas station and telling the attendant that there was no oil to check - "doesn't need oil, it's air cooled" :O :D :D :D

Re: Electronic controls? Am I the only one?????

#25

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: you folks have selective memories

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Safety - yeah, none!

Today's lowest priced Chevy, Toyota, etc. both handles better and stops quicker than anything made in the 60s or 70s.

A new Corolla has a skidpad rating of around 0.9G, and stops from 60 mph in a hundred feet or so. A 69 Corvette would do about 0.8G and stop in 150 feet.

Then there's airbags, traction control, anti-locks, etc. that are all standard.

Add all that to the reliability of getting maybe a quarter million miles on a car instead of 50 thousand miles.