Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

OT - Toilet problem

Posts

OT - Toilet problem

#1

OT - Toilet problem

Nat Robison

I have a toilet (20 years old) and I just replaced the flush valve and the flapper. This is a pre-low flow toilet and I think it flushes with about 3.5 gals per flush.

Ever since the replacement, I can't get it to flush properly every time. There's virtually no slack in the chain to the flapper. Basically, the flapper is closing too soon but other than adjusting the chain, what can be done?

It seems likes it's set up for low-flow and closes too early, when only about the half the bowl has cleared. It will flush all the way about once every 5 times and usually by holding the handle down far longer than you want to.

Anyone have a similar problem? I hate to replace the toilet over this but I'm out of ideas and open to suggestions. About all I can find online has to do with the chain to the flapper.

Re: OT - Toilet problem

#2

Re: OT - Toilet problem

Dick Coers

Can't you just hold the handle down longer?

Re: OT - Toilet problem

#3

Re: OT - Toilet problem

garthinsandiego

Try adding some slack to the chain. Sounds like the flapper isn't raising high enough to stay open. Normally the air trapped in the bulb part of the flapper will provide sufficient buoyancy to hold the valve open until the tank water level drops below the bulb. The buoyancy of trapped air in bulb part of the flapper reduces to zero and the weight of the flapper will pull it to the closed position. I think if you have a too short chain, the weight of the flapper in a partially raised position is too much for the little bit of buoyancy of trapped air to keep the valve open.

Re: OT - Toilet problem

#4

Lengthen the chain

David Yoho

What you described sounds like the chain not having any slack isn't allowing the flapper to work like it should. The tip-off for me was when you said holding the handle down longer made a difference. Lengthen the chain and see if that doesn't resolve your issue.

Re: OT - Toilet problem

#5

Re: Lengthen the chain

Nat Robison

I just gave that a try and it worked.......this time. I swear I've tried the chain on every available link and haven't found the sweet spot. Seems like the advice elsewhere on the 'net was to shorten the chain so you got the maximum pull on the flapper. Instruction with the flush valve said to leave a bit of slack but that didn't work every time when I installed it. Will keep on trying.

Thanks.

Re: OT - Toilet problem

#6

Ditto

Grant in Iowa

Garth is on the money here. If, when you flush the toilet you see the flapper go to nearly vertical, the chain is too tight. You want the flapper to raise juuust enough to stay there while the water rushes down.

Low flow toilets are nice, but they can be a problem in older homes/ businesses because the sewer lines may have worked fine with large doses of water, but won't flow well with the new toilets.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: OT - Toilet problem

#7

Re: OT - Toilet problem

walta

I think if you look at the new flap it will have a hole in it that the old one does not.

This hole allows the air to escape and the flap closes sooner than the old one.



Walt

Re: OT - Toilet problem

#8

I think you're right

Nat Robison

I think you're right and I think that's the problem. Looking into it further, it appears this style of flapper is pretty much only for 1.6 gal toilets. They do make flappers specifically for older toilets and I guess I'll have to locate one of those. I don't recall seeing any at Lowe's when I bought the other one.

Re: OT - Toilet problem

#10

Another consideration

Keith Newton

Do you have the float set to where the water is up close to the top of the overflow?

I just replaced an old set about a month ago, which didn't clear the bowl with enough water to do the job until I set the float almost as high as the tank overflow tube.

There is a little collet ring around the riser tube, which slides up, allowing the slits to open on the outer / top part, enabling it to be raised. Be sure to have a hand on top when you slip the ring up, or the water pressure may blow the top portion off, and rinse your ceiling.

Re: OT - Toilet problem

#11

Re: Another consideration

Gary Smyth

If you look inside the tank there might be a mark that says "water level". If the water on flushing refill does not reach that mark you will experience a uneven flush. You said that it sometimes works so that may not be the problem but do check out the bathtub ring on the inside of the tank. Adjust the float so that the water reaches that level. If the level is correct then it's likely the chain length. Flappers can be bought cheap so if the problem still isn't resolved then look into a different flapper.

Re: OT - Toilet problem

#12

Re: plug the hole? Hmm?? 


Re: OT - Toilet problem

#13

Re: OT - Toilet problem

Alex Grigoriev

Buy an American Standard Champion 4, and you won't have a problem with flush anymore. It's 1.6 gpf. Be aware that they are available in different bowl height, and you may not want the 16" one which is usually sold at homedepot.