Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Designing classic columns

Posts

Designing classic columns

#1

Designing classic columns

Dick Coers

I can't find a design guide to the proportions of classic Tuscan columns. Similar to Doric, just no flutes. I've seen the placement of the entasis or bulge, 1/3 the total height from the bottom, but nothing to help design the curve of the column. Straighter on the bottom, to more curve to the top, or a constant curve over the entire column. Any help?

Re: Designing classic columns

#2

Re: Designing classic columns *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Hi Dick,

I've no experience with these, and no idea if this will help, but hope it does.

Bob in NJ


http://shop.columns.com/classical-orders-tuscan.aspx

Re: Designing classic columns

#3

suggestion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The person that can answer this question with authority is Alan Batty. Alan has studied this topic in detail and published a guide to column design. Where to find it, I don't know. He handed a copy out to those interested in our turning club. Maybe Alan put it up in the internet. One of the purveyors of turning supplies sells publications from Alan. Maybe they have it (I think it is the place in Utah).

Re: Designing classic columns

#4

Re: Designing classic columns

Keith Newton

Dick, I have a Chippendale Gentleman and Cabinet-Makers Directory here in my office/library, which has that all described. It takes a little adjusting to understand, since the f & s are interchanged.

I don't think legally that I can take a pic and post it online, but if you will drop me a personal email, I think I can share what you need.

But to try to answer the question, it does appear to curve more at the top. After you come up the column 1/3, then draw a semicircle of that diameter. Then mark off what appears to be 10º segments. The remaining 2/3 height above there, is divided into 4 equal parts. When you project up parallel to the center line of the column, where those 10º segments hit the semicircle arc, each in turn, will determine the diameter at that height.

That is tough to describe, and I'm sure even harder to follow if you aren't looking at a drawing.

Edit; Pics are in your email.

Re: Designing classic columns

#5

Re: Designing classic columns

Tony - Memphis

There are several good reprints at Dover that describe all of the orders quite well. I'm pretty sure the Chippendale book does and there is another that I'm having trouble recalling right now....waiting for the coffee to kick in....

Asher Benjamin, Palladio, Vitruvius, etc.

Tony

Re: Designing classic columns

#6

Re: Designing classic columns

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

You're probably trying to recall "The Four Books of Architecture" by Andrea Palladio. Dover also has a reprint of that book. I would guess Chippendale got his column drawings from Palladio. They are very similar. I have both books in my library.

Re: Designing classic columns

#7

Re: classic columns -> Four Books of Architecture

Rum

Cool, added to the reading list (this is the 1715 translation out of copyright)

https://archive.org/details/architecturePal00Pall

Re: Designing classic columns

#8

Re: classic columns -> Four Books of Architecture

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

The only problem with the online version is you can't measure, transfer and scale dimensions off the drawings using a pair of dividers. ;^)

Re: Designing classic columns

#9

Re: classic columns -> Four Books of Architecture

Rum

Yaah, that's true but I have a laser printer so I can print off pages as needed.

The main downside to that theory is that the scans aren't always scaled perfectly so there's that problem...

On the upside I'm at 7? 8? bookshelves (downsized some when we last moved) and running out of room to put more so it saves me a little there :D

Re: Designing classic columns

#10

Thanks for the help everyone!

Dick Coers

It will be a while before I start these, but now I have the design tools I needed. Thanks for the efforts from everyone!