Blade comparison- by what metric
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
When one speaks of comparing blades it is essential to decide on what metrics are to be used in the comparison. If what is important is blade life then bigger better carbide equals more sharpenings and that blade wins. Other important metrics could be cost or how much it loads the saw motor which would depend on number of teeth and grind on the teeth.
In my opinion an over emphasized metric is smoothness of cut, cross cut and/or rip. In what I do saw cuts wind up hidden or further refined with the jointer or hand plane. Within reason I don't care how smooth the blade cuts.
There is a seldom recognized price to pay for smooth cuts in a combination blade. Forrest gets smooth cuts by grinding little relief on the teeth sides. As a result they load up with resins quicker and dull quicker. But on the occasions where one needs a smooth cut right off the saw they excel. I keep one on hand for these special occasions but it is not the blade I mostly use. For me a workhouse blade needs to be cheap to buy and cheap to own (how long it stays sharp and how many times I can sharpen it).