Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Flexible Sanding Wheel

Posts

Flexible Sanding Wheel

#1

Flexible Sanding Wheel

Kelly M. Robison

Hi All, I'm looking for a flexible sanding wheel for sanding the inside of a curve. The one that I have [which was given to me by a friend] is about 1/2" across and has a 1/4" shaft. I'm told that It can be used in my router table. I want to buy some new ones and can't find them on-line. Does anybody know where can I can buy them?? The one that I have is like a smaller version of a large "flap wheel" .

Thank you,

Kelly in Port Orchard, WA

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#2

Danger Here

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Be Carefull, Kelly. You must make sure that the sander you get is rated for the high RPM of a router which is 10-20 times whats a drill would be. The speed rating will be stamped right on the disk parts.

You should have no trouble finding appropriate items at either Grainger.com or McMaster.com

You can also try Klingspor through the WC Marketplace tab on the left side of your screen.

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#3

Router table? *LINK*

John in NM

Yikes! :D

Depending on the size of the curve, I believe those inflatable drum sanders work pretty well.

I've also come across a custom flap wheel outfit, but never tried one of their products - my stuff is really too small for these.


http://www.flap-wheels.com/

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#4

First time in over 40 years of woodworking

Dick Coers

I've ever heard of someone wanting to sand with a router! I'm not sure I could think of a worse thing to do. Abrasives break down with heat, if it did live after you hit the switch, it ain't gonna last long. Flap sanders are miserable on flat surfaces. They sand out the softer grain, leave the hard grain. Don't do it! Well if you do, make sure someone is video taping, might just get on tv with that video of you picking sandpaper out of your teeth!

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#5

Ellis Walentine

Tell us what you really think

Ellis Walentine

No, I fundamentally agree about flap sanders in a router. Yikes.

Back to the OP:

Don't even think about it. But, you didn't say what the scale of the curves might be. Can you touch them up with a 1" or 2" or 3" spindle sander? Must it be crisp vertical surfaces, or can you dub things over a bit?

Might be a good discussion here.

Ellis

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#6

Re: Tell us what you really think

TomD

I wouldn't do it, but if it has variable speed and soft start, isn't a router just a sophisticated motor?

If will probably be above the level of the table, unable to be retracted, so you would need a false table to house the lower edge, and presumably you wouldn't have the bottom in the drawer so you can get that also. If the bottom isn't there, it would probably go better with a simple hand scraper.

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#7

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I certainly would not use any of these in a typical single speed router as they run at 23,000 to 24,000 RPM. Klingspor has a number of flap sanders ~ but all that I looked at had a MAXIMUM speed of 12,000 RPM.

http://www.woodworkingshop.com/category.aspx?id=25

It would not only be very DANGEROUS to spin them up to twice the max rated speed, but also would not sand the wood well. At the normal router speed the abrasive would burn the wood, the resin holding the abrasive would likely melt or disintegrate and bits would fly everywhere. A drill press or dedicated spindle sander is the proper place for these items.

I would assume the variable speed routers with a 10K speed would work but still think it would be a risky endeavor to obtain a good finish with this setup.

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#8

go back one step

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Tell us what you need to smooth, in detail. There may be a better way of going about it. For example, I smooth inside curves with a curved sole spoke shave.

I am unsure what the device you are seeking looks like. Can you post a picture?

Klingspor makes all sorts of sanding devices. Also, there are things like you describe, as best I can imagine it, for sanding metal. Check some place like MSC, Granger, or Travers.

Routers spin at 18,000 rpm. Be certain what ever you put in a router can handle the forces or the result will be an exploded sanding device.

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#9

Re: Danger Here

Lars Parrington

Also try supergrit.com and industrialabrasives.com, although they don't have any smaller than 1" dia.

supergrit sells an adapter for their flapwheels to run in a dremel tool, which is interesting since a dremel can run up to 35000 rpm.

I would certainly wear some protective gear when using these things, but I don't think it would actually be all that dangerous if one of them did come apart on you, especially one as small as 1/2" diameter. Pretty much every time I use a cut-off disc in a dremel, it binds and then explodes on me, and dremel corp must sell millions of those discs. A small sanding wheel can't be too different.

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#10

Re: go back one step

Yonak

Based on a recommendation by someone on this site I got the Sand-Rite self feeding brush head for sanding inside curves. It's not cheap but, as I use it regularly, it's worth it for me.

It's refillable. I mounted it to a dedicated 1750rpm motor. I use it for 3/4"d. coves and works well for inside curves at least that small.

Note : Even though it says it's self-feeding, it must be manually adjusted.

http://www.sand-rite.com/b-12.html

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#11

Dremel Flap Sander *LINK*

Hank Knight

Kelly, Dremel makes and sells sanding accessories for their tools. I think a Dremel hand grinder turns at about 20,000 rpm, IIRC, so their sanding accessories should be rated for that speed. The little flap sander shown in the link below may be what you're looking for; the size seems to match your description. They should be available anywhere Dremel tools are sold.


Dremel sanding accessories

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#12

A little strong worded?

Dick Coers

Okay, I'll turn it back a little. LOL! Sanding wood is never about high speeds. You give the abrasive time to cut without building high heat. High heat breaks down the abrasive and cooks the resin in the wood. Get the resin warm enough and it sticks to the abrasive, making the abrasive useless. Abrasive manufactures went to aluminum oxide for power sanders. Before that, when we used garnet, and that was great for hand sanding. Remember hand sanding? That sure wasn't close to 10,000 rpm.

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#13

sanding speed -- some points of reference

Lars Parrington

hmm....

The OP asked for a 0.5" diameter flap sander. Running at 10,000 rpm, the surface speed of that flap sander would be 15,700 inches/minute, or 1300 feet per minute.

By comparison, a typical 4x24" handheld belt sander runs at 1600 feet per minute.

Powermatic sells a 20" disc sander. It runs at 1720 rpm. That's 9,000 feet per minute.

The mirka ceros sanders run at 4k to 10k rpm, and are available in sizes up to 6" diameter. That's a 6" disc running at 10k rpm! That's over 15,000 feet per minute, an order of magnitude faster than the piddly little 0.5" flap disc we're all so worried about.

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#14

Ellis Walentine

Another point of reference

Ellis Walentine

A tiny flap disk running at 10,000 rpm (or, egad, 20,000 rpm) may be running at 1300 fpm, but it's the same inch and a half of sandpaper, not a two foot belt or a 20" disk. Something's gotta melt or burn. Pardon my knee-jerk reaction, but this sounds like a big mistake. If it comes to pass, I'll be most interested to hear how it works out.

Ellis

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#15

Re: Jet says 20 000 rpm

TomD

https://www.jetgroupbrands.com/brands/view/product.php?p=560325&gid=3632&id=6&sid=3028&cid=162&brand=jet#.VO2YNiy234w

This is a 1x3 flap wheel, not sure if that is enough flapilation for him or not. Jet says max is 20K rpm

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#16

I'm guessing...

John in NM

We've talked Kelly out of it at this point! :D

I bet the thing is really intended to go in a drill motor, and the guy who gave it to him suggested putting it in a router table, not thinking about the speeds and forces involved there.

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#17

Now that I've read it again... *LINK*

John in NM

And a bit more carefully :D what you're describing sounds like this:


These are intended to be chucked in a drill or lathe and run at moderate speeds, and work pretty well. You can buy them just about anywhere, hardware stores, Home Despot, etc. Best selection for sizes is usually mail order of course.


http://www.mscdirect.com/product/details/84400696?src=pla&cid=PLA-Google-PLA+-+Test&CS_003=7867724&CS_010=84400696

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#18

That will be a slow way to go

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If the inside curve is rough nothing is going to beat a curved sole spoke shave for smoothing. If the smoothing is modest then a piece of coarse sandpaper on profiled block of something will be fast, and cheap.

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#19

Yeah, I think so too...

John in NM

But we don't know all the factors. If it's a tight curve, like those on the grips I make, a spindle sander would be the only fast method:


If the curves are more broad, like for furniture legs and the like, then a spokeshave is the way to go. A bit of a learning curve though.

One of those large, bench grinder type, flap sanders is just the thing for a large convex curve too. I've seen the pneumatic drums used for large concave surfaces, and they seem to work quite well for that. Trouble is that machines of this type run $500 or so.

Hence the market for those slow, occasional use flap sanders - cheap, no learning curve. They're not for me, but I get the reason for their existence.

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#20

Re: Another point of reference

Lars Parrington

You have a point. There's not a lot of time for the abrasive bits on such a tiny sanding widget to cool down. I meant to dig out my dremel today and put one of those little 1/2" sanding drums on it, but I just didn't get around to it. I expect it would work okay when the abrasive is new and light pressure is used. It won't take long for it to dull, and then it will probably burn.

A flap wheel would hopefully expose new abrasive as it wears and thus hopefully last a bit longer.

Re: Flexible Sanding Wheel

#21

Re: Now that I've read it again...

TomD

That one is rated for 30K also. Drill motor is barely 2K. The 20K one was 1" diameter X 3 inch high, which would certianly get into a drawer. I wouldn't use it either, but it isn't because it is any more dangerous than a lot of other things. If your router does 20K this thing is not going to be much use, but speed controllers are cheap or included in a lot of routers, and at that point they are more controllable than a fixed speed, or non-stepped drill trigger.