Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

OT Shop Roof leak problems.

Posts

OT Shop Roof leak problems.

#1

OT Shop Roof leak problems.

Keith Newton

My shop roof is pretty flat. I think the pitch is about 1.5 / 12", originally built as a grocery store back in 1927, Safeway # 10.

I had the current roof put on after the tornado in 1999. It is a torch-down type, with the seams running across the 50' way for ~ 100' up the run. Over time, some wrinkles have formed up and down the slope, which has led to some separation where the seams cross over the wrinkles. Since this has formed, I have tried to get up there regularly to repair them ahead of any leaking, however snow and ice always makes the problem worse.

Just before dark yesterday a leak started right in front of my unisaw. I just put a bunch of pails under them, planning to deal with it this morning. By owning, the leak had shifted about 12', so I got up there with tools to clear some of the snow-slush. Even without finding the source for the leak, just getting the snow off, due to dropping the water table stopped the leak, which would indicate somewhere high on a wrinkle.

What I'm thinking about doing to head off some of the problems in the future, is to, cut down both sides of these standing wrinkles, which would leave a space about 3' - 4' wide, running up and down the slope. Then I might cut a new roll in half, from 36" wide down to 18", and torch it down on top of the other. I'd probably need to do some kind of thinning of the edges where each layer droops off, to prevent and easy line for seepage at the old overlaps, then torching on my half wide patch.

What say yee, Anyone with a background in roofing on here? Does this sound like a good way to milk some extra years out of this roof. I really can't afford to buy a new roof now, though I wish I could.

OH! and one last thing. While I was up there clearing the re-frozen snow melt, which was about 1.5" ~ 2" deep, I was thinking about some of the images I've seen in the news lately up in the New England states, where the snow is deeper than I have ever seen. I couldn't help but dow a few quick, in my head calculations for the dead-load on my roof. A cubic foot of fresh water weights 62.5#, so each inch of depth per square foot is 5.2#. Since my 2x10" rafters are on 2' centers, and 14' long between trusses, then at 2" deep, that would be 20.4# per running foot, or 291#, not counting the weight of the deck and roof material, so I should be fine.

I was just wondering, if up there where you guys probably are expecting to get some major snows, if the codes require more substantial framing, and or if the weather people offer warnings about roof collapse for certain types of structures?

It seems like there would be a lot of that making the news down here in the mid South. I wouldn't be surprised if there was a phone app, where you could activate your location, and type of roof, so you would get a warning that maybe you ought to go rent a room somewhere tonight. ha.

Re: OT Shop Roof leak problems.

#2

Re: OT Shop Roof

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Can't help with the roof.

My kids (one in Maine, one in New York) are both using roof "rakes" to keep their roofs over their heads where they belong. I have clients in the Boston area who tell me there are guys making regular round in the neighborhoods clearing roofs.

And it's only mid-February. We'll have 6-8 more weeks of this.

Re: OT Shop Roof leak problems.

#3

Kneale Brownson

Re: OT Shop Roof leak problems.

Kneale Brownson

If I understand, you have water backing up behind the ice, causing it to seek the least path of resistance, which is through the gaps in the surface roofing.

Do you have the ice build-up because of the sun heating the roof or because of heat loss through the roof?

What's beneath your torch-down surface? My understanding of torching down is to fuse the roofing surface to the underlying material so that it can't do things like the wrinkling you describe.

My parents had a flat-roofed house built in 1949 in northern Michigan (average snowfall of 250 inches a season) where they used the hot tar and gravel process. Kind of like paving the roof.

Re: OT Shop Roof leak problems.

#4

Re: OT Shop Roof leak problems.

Keith Newton

The deck is OSB on top of the old 1x6 ship lap pine, then a layer of fiberglass reinforced felt nailed down on fairly close centers. When they rolled out the top layer, they used a big propane torch, which melts the tar on the underside of the uphill 30" of the 36" wide rolls. This is allowed to cool, and contract before they went back lifting the 6" overlap, torching it and pressing the melted edges together.

Over time, the Sun heating it up causes expansion, leading to the wrinkles,which I'm sure the nailed down bottom layer was suppose to prevent. But once they started, continued to grow, I suppose due to some melt when expanded, then taking a new SET each cycle, never contracting back to the original size.

The top layer of the seam of course gets hot more quickly than the bottom, popping it away at the lower melt seam. This would be above normal rain flow levels, but any snow buildup can cause there to be a water level well above the wrinkle tops. And of course, it is worse down on the lower 20' where the slush is more saturated from the runoff from the 80' or run above.

Re: OT Shop Roof leak problems.

#5

Re: OT Shop Roof leak problems.

mdclor

Keith, IIRC the snow load for Upstate NY was in the 40-50 pounds per sq ft. That would be the equivalent of 2-2.5 ft of heavy, wet snow. When Buffalo gets dumped on, 6-8 feet in a couple days, there would be reports of buildings, usually garages or mobile homes, collapsing. Sorry, I can't help with your roof situation.

Re: OT Shop Roof leak problems.

#6

Re: OT Shop Roof leak problems.

Jerry Roberts

Keith. My back porch has just about the same pitch as your roof problem.The first one I had was plain ol roll roofing which didn't last no time. Next I had a rubber roof put down with a BIG torch. I lasted awhile but still had some problems. I just contacted my son in Atlanta, just now, cause I couldn't remember the name, who knows roofs. I had a modified Bituman roof put on. Can be either torch or roofing cement. Ended my roof problems. Its been on several yrs and is great. Hope this type fits your situation. Of course this is Florida.

Re: OT Shop Roof leak problems.

#7

Re: OT Shop Roof

C. John Hebert

I live in Maine and I just plain gave up raking my roof this year. The snow around the house where I've been raking it off is so deep now that it's just plain hard to get at the roof anymore. Roof rake's are flimsy aluminum with long poles in 3 sections that get up pretty high but unless a roof is pretty steeply pitched, a step ladder will most likely have to be used while raking. Up here, the snow is pretty light, so raking is an ease (sorta). Heavy wet snow is a b*tch. In any event, it's better than shoveling but shoveling a steep pitch would be impossible anyhow. I've got ice dams everywhere as a result of not raking, but....I wasn't left with a choice this year with all this damned snow.

Re: OT Shop Roof leak problems.

#8

Re: OT Shop Roof leak problems.

CJ in MPLS

The roof repair sounds good to me. The manufacturer should specify the application conditions for the materials you are working with so you'll want to approximate those as best you can. At a minimum, you'll likely get relief for some time. Keep in mind however that I'm one of those engineering types that likes to make swags all the time. I've a good track record if I say so myself, but my wife has instituted a rule that all swags must be identified as such. She is a doctor and it bothers her to have someone acting confidently about "guessing". ;)

Re: OT Shop Roof leak problems.

#9

Re: OT Shop Roof leak problems.

TomD

A good weight to figure for snow is 13 pounds per cubic foot, or as high as about 20 pounds. Weigh a bucket of water, then weigh the same volume of snow, and throw in some ice, or water if you get that also in a representative sample from your roof. [( Weight of snow/water) x 62.4 lbs] is your weight per cubic foot of snow. The point of this test is you can use any size container (net out container weight) for this test.

I live a few hundred yards north of Lake Ontario. We get reasonably dry winters, but at the moment we have a few feet of snow, and might get 3 feet tops. Attached are the garage building details for an average garage with a flat roof. Garages are about 14 feet wide which should work out in your sample, but I would guess your rafters are set much wider if they are decked. So look at it this way. Say the rafters are 2x6 in the details (I didn't look), you might get away with one every 2 feet, which is four new rafters every 8 feet. Let's say your rafters are 12 inches deep set every 8 feet, or one new rafter every 8 feet. But the extra depth in the rafter is 4 times stronger and 8 times stiffer.

I'm not an engineer, that is just how I see it when I do this stuff for myself, at my own risk.

http://www.pickering.ca/en/living/resources/shedpackage.pdf