Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Doors with glass

Posts

Doors with glass

#1

Doors with glass

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

In the July/August 2002 issue of FWW, C. Becksvoort has an article on the Shaker Wall clock.

Can anybody explain to me how the upper (and lower door joinery) is done? I don't get it.

In the text he states using haunched tenons, but the picture/diagram doesn't look like it to me.

The article doesn't go into any details on the joinery.

Also, the upper door shows a rabbet for the glass. Would the rabbet be cut before doing the mortise and tenons?

I'm struggling with this step of making my clock. I've made M/T'd cabinet doors before, but never with rabbets to hold glass.

I can't get my head around how I should do the joinery for the top door (mostly). The rabbet is really confusing me(!).

If you cut a rabbet in the rails and stiles, then aren't you left with a gap?

Or, is that filled in with the glass support strips that get tacked into place. That doesn't really seem to make sense either. That would mean on the stiles, the strip is the full length of the stile which would look silly.

See, I'm confused.

Thanks for any advice.

Re: Doors with glass

#2

Re: Doors with glass

William Duffield

First, I would call it a bridle joint, not a mortise and tenon. For purposes of this issue, however, it doesn't make any difference.

The inside shoulder of the rails extends into the rabbet of the stiles. You cut the rear shoulder of the tenon closer to the end of the rail by the depth of the rabbet in the stile. That's not what I would call a haunch, either, but terminology is flexible.

Re: Doors with glass

#3

Re: Doors with glass

David Yoho

If you cut a rabbet in the rails and stiles, then aren't you left with a gap?

If I'm reading what you're wanting to do right, if you cut the rabbet in the stiles full length then, yes, you would have a gap. The rabbet in the rails could be full length but the ones in the stiles would be stopped. Since you're probably doing this with hand tools, you figure the best method to do this. It would be possible with a router by cutting and fitting the mortise and tenons first and then with the frame assembled use the router to make the rabbet. Of course, the corners would need squaring. That's one way. I'd probably employ a router but not exactly that way.

Re: Doors with glass

#4

Ellis Walentine

Couple things

Ellis Walentine

First, Bob LaPoint's drawing on the bottom left of page 55 is poor, but if you look carefully at the blue dashed lines in the rail, they do show that the rear shoulder is not in line with the front shoulder, but rather longer to match up with the rabbet in the stile. That isn't reflected in the color perspective view at the top of the page either. You are right to be confused.

Second, the text on page 56 doesn't jibe with the drawings of the joints, as there are no "haunched mortise and tenon" joints in the drawings at all, and the next sentence, " ...and make sure to offset the glass and panel grooves to allow room for the thumbnail profile along the fronts." makes no sense to me. Hate to knock another editor's work, but this article could (and should) have been much better edited.

Another editorial oversight is the fact that the author refers to Kassay's The Book of Shaker Furniture as the source for "accurate dimensions" for this clock. Actually, the dimensions of the clock in Kassay's book don't remotely resemble the clock Becksvoort makes for that article, nor does the joinery. Kassay's example shows simple, unhaunched, fully housed mortise-and-tenon joints on the corners of the doors and stopped rabbets as David Yoho has suggested. The joints are pinned with hardwood pins, two per corner. There is no quarter-round detail (hence, no molding strips) on the face side of the doors.

A personal preference of mine would have been to fully house the joints like the Shaker originals, for appearance and structural integrity.

Ellis

Re: Doors with glass

#5

Re: Couple things... just to be fair

Bob Entwisle in NJ

The author stated that "Accurate dimensions for the original clocks" not "this clock" are in John Kassay's book. He also states "The version I built appears in my book, The Shaker Legacy". I do not have that book, (or i can't find it) to check if the design in Chris Becksvoort's book is the same as in the article.

That aside, a technique I use when building from or adapting a plan from a book or magazine is to redraw it myself, usually in CAD but often with pencil and paper, in order to check dimensions and otherwise understand how things will or in some cases will not go together based on the original plan. Saves surprises later during the build.

That's a nice little clock, by the way.

Bob in NJ

Re: Doors with glass

#6

Re: Couple things... just to be fair

John McGaw

I haven't had a chance to dig out the magazine article (assuming I actually have it) but in Becksvoort's referenced book the appearance of the clock does not seem to match up precisely with the same clock in Handberg's book 'Shop Drawings of Shaker Furniture & Woodenware, Volume 2". Even the overall dimensions differ slightly.

The first book has zero in the way of construction details while the second is supposed to show enough details to build the piece but does not actually show the internals of the joinery in question beyond showing that there are retainer strips inside the door to hold the glass. Personally, I'd wing it on the joinery and use a regular M&T without the haunch and then use a router to cut the rebate for the glass, squaring with a chisel. This is what I've done on most doors and it is simple and reliable.

Re: Doors with glass

#7

Re: Doors with glass

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thank you all for the responses.

Ellis, you are dead on with your post. Thanks. Even though that article leaves me with a ton of questions and confusion, I am still a big fan of C. Becksvoort. :) I know nothing of the publishing biz or writing articles, but I am guessing the published article is not exactly how Mr. Becksvoort wrote it.

I have all the books mentioned in the above responses. I pulled out Kassay's book and I will need to look at it closer, but I took a quick look this morning and see it has a much more detailed drawing.

I also took a super quick look at the "The Shaker Legacy" book and did not see the clock he made for the article. I did see two others that (I believe) are originals. I just paged through it quickly though.

It has clicked in my head as to how this joint it put together. Now I just have to figure out how to execute it.

Thanks again.

Re: Doors with glass

#8

Page Number

John McGaw

The clock is at the top of page 216 in my copy of "The Shaker Legacy". The clock at the bottom of that page also appears in "The Book of Shaker Furniture" by John Kassay on page 132. That drawing of a contemporaneous piece shows the rail-to-stile joints as more of a closed-end bridle joint or perhaps an open M&T might be more descriptive. In any case it is not a closed M&T and there is no haunch on it.

Looking at the various pictures of Shaker wall clocks now has me wondering why all of them appear to have a date of "1840" on a Roman-numeral face although three examples aren't statistically convincing. Could it be possible that they were using some sort of mass-produced face or is there some other explanation?

Re: Doors with glass

#9

Ellis Walentine

Ah, you're right, John

Ellis Walentine

I was looking at the drawing on page 128 of Kassay's book. The one on p 132 does show the open M&T joint and the 1/4-round moldings, too. Good catch. Clearly there are many ways to skin this cat.

I still prefer the fully housed mortise, but there's no reason the open mortise can't work.

Ellis

Re: Doors with glass

#10

Re: Page Number

joe in a Cleveland suburb

The two clocks shown on page 216 of "The Shaker Legacy" are original Isaac Newton Youngs clocks. The top one is not the one Becksvoort made.

John, you mention the year of 1840. The text on the above page states these two clocks were signed by Youngs in May of 1840. It also says he painted the faces.

I seem to recall reading someplace that he made. Run of these clocks in 1840, so maybe that's why we see them with 1840? I don't know, just guessing.

Thanks.