Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

Posts

In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

#1

In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

Keith Newton

Before reading the article, I was wondering how they could have been off that much, then remembered back when I was a much younger carpenter, working with a much older carpenter who's eyesight was so poor, he used a carpenter's pencil, because it would mark a 3/16" wide line that he could see to cut. ha

Anyway, they said the old measure was 555' 5", but is 10" shorter now. I was visualizing Elmer on one end of a 6' folding rule, stepping of the increments, which sent me to my calculator. This would have taken 92.5 steps with a folding rule, which when divided into ten inches came up with an interesting fraction. How often would you expect to come up with a fraction like 0.10810810810810810811.

This is not how the measure changed, but was actually measured to a different place. Here was an interesting fact that would make a good trivia question. It was completed, with the 100-ounce (2.83 kg) aluminum apex/lightning-rod being put in place on December 6, 1884.[32] The apex was the largest single piece of aluminum cast at the time", taken from wikipedia.

Dang, When I was a young kid in school, any history that happened 84 years before I was born seemed like a really long time, but I would have known people old enough to have been there. Now, that really doesn't seem like such a long time ago, and to think a 6.25 pound aluminum casting was a big deal, is just a good indicator of how fast and far we've come over the last 130 years.

Re: In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

#3

Re: In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

BrianMonumentCO

Big questions;

1. is the original measurement accurate? My suspicion is no.

2. Did the monument change height because of the 2011 earthquake?

3. did the repairs change the height?

Re: In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

#5

Re: In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

Keith Newton

The standard for where the bottom measurement for monuments has changed from the lowest outside face, to the sill of the lowest outside door, I think, or was it to the floor straight down the middle.

But the ground has been built up since it's construction too.

Re: In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

#6

Re: In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

John McGaw

I've heard that we all shrink in height as we age. This is not necessarily true of circumference...

Re: In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

#7

What comes off the height goes on the waist!


Re: In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

#8

Correct

Gary Smyth

From the web. Modern international standards from the Council of Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat — an official guideline for building measurements — call for a different base point. This standard measures from the lowest open-air pedestrian entrance to the building. (not from in ground brass markers previously used to be a start point)

Interestingly, the only observable height change was the pyramid-shaped tip had been rounded off over time. Surveyors in 1934 also noticed the peak had been rounded and believed it was due to frequent lightning strikes that melted the aluminum tip.

"Well, this time around, we took very careful measurements," "We were able to determine about 3/8 of an inch had been melted off from the very top.

From report. Dru Smith, chief geodesist with the National Geodetic Survey.

Re: In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

#9

Re: In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

BrianMonumentCO

If the monument were measured the same way it was before what is the height? Is it different?

OR has the method of measure produced a different height with the exact same monument.

Sounds a bit like what would happen if we measured peoples heights in street shoes and then measured them barefooted. Of course there will be a difference.

Re: In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

#10

More  same report

Gary Smyth

The original measurement conducted in 1884 by Lt. Col. Thomas Casey is believed to have used four brass markers as a base for measurement. Those markers remain in place about 9 inches below ground off each corner of the monument. It's possible the markers were at ground level in the past. A new plaza was installed around the monument more recently, and "it's clear that what was ground level has changed over the years," Smith said.

Measurements from the brass markers to the top in 1999 and 2014 essentially reconfirmed the original measurement, showing the 1884 measurement was done with "incredible accuracy."

"Well, this time around, we took very careful measurements," Smith said. "We were able to determine about 3/8 of an inch had been melted off from the very top."

That means the original 1884 measurement, completed with much less sophisticated equipment, was within ¾ of an inch of the findings from the newest survey, using the original brass markers as a base point.

Re: In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

#11

A brief history of aluminum

Walt

At one time it rivaled gold in value. Below is a link to a quick read that seems correct.

http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/elements/features/2010/blogging_the_periodic_table/aluminum_it_used_to_be_more_precious_than_gold.html

Re: In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

#12

Thanks Walt, I love history, *LINK*

Keith Newton

One of the earliest ALCOA mines, was about 15 miles from here at Bauxite.

Glad i didn't buy a bunch when it was $500 #


http://www.encyclopediaofarkansas.net/encyclopedia/entry-detail.aspx?entryID=382#

Re: In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

#13

Re: More  same report

BrianMonumentCO

So in reality the monument is only 3/4 of an shorter OR there was an inaccuracy in the original measurement.

Re: In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

#14

Re: More same report

Gary Smyth

Apparently the old measurement when compared with the new height finding (based on the old starting point) was only 3/4 inch different from todays laser/satellite measurements. The 3/4 inch difference comment was in the context of a complement to the original engineers and their effort for accuracy.

Re: In the news, Washington monument 10" shorter

#15

Bart Goldberg

Re: measure twice, cut once - LOL!