Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

saw blade strope issue

Posts

saw blade strope issue

#1

saw blade strope issue

Randy Johnson

I didn't get reading the thread that got into a strobe effect making the blade look like it was standing still until it had some age on it, and it seemed more appropriate to start a new one.

My comment, is that most of the time, WHAT difference does it make if the blade looks like it is standing still!!??

The only, and I mean only time I touch the blade on my table saw is when I am changing a blade or rotating it to line up the outside edge of a tooth for an accurate cut. And during those two operations the saw is unplugged. Same for tooling changes on the shaper and bit changes on the router. During all ripping operations there is a guard in place. I can't see the blade even if it does look like it is standing still. If I could see it....well, that is what the blade guard is there for. There are those occasions (panel cutting and dados are the two I think of off-hand) where the guard is out of the way. Maybe I just work different than other folks, but the saw is not turned on until I'm ready to make the cut, and is turned off immediately after the cut is made. Spinning, exposed table saw blades scare the crap out of me.

My saw BTW is the 3hp Jet cabinet saw. It's a quiet saw, but even with my severe hearing problems I can hear it as an extra sound over the cyclone.

Re: saw blade strope issue

#2

As far as I've ever been able to tell....

John in NM

This is completely a non-issue in real life, both because it does not happen and because, as you point out, we generally don't touch the blade except to change it.

All I can figure is that someone noticed a slight strobe effect back when ballasts did cause some flickering, and the rest is internet legend. I very much doubt that anyone ever mistook a running blade for a stationary one :D

Re: saw blade strope issue

#3

"Stealth" blades can be a problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I run a 7 1/2" industrial quality 40T combo blade on my saw. With the dust collection running the saw motor noise blends in with the dust collection noise. The blade is silent. (I have a 10" blade that requires ear protection from its screaming)

Once upon a time I would leave the saw running if I had a short trip to make away from the saw. One day I returned, distracted, and forgot the blade was running. Doing something, I got a body part or a piece of wood (memory no longer clear) nearer the spinning blade that I normally would if I knew the blade was spinning. The discovery was sufficient shock that a new rule was established. Along with no extraneous stuff on the saw table, the saw is turned off if I leave it even for what is expected to be a short time.

That said, the strobe effect is absent with modern electronic ballasts.

Re: saw blade strope issue

#4

Different problem... though that one is real

John in NM

Inattention and complacency are real risks, and I have more than one scar to prove it :D

I very much doubt that even with old ballasts there was much risk with a strobe effect, as Alex explained in the earlier discussion. Even if there are coincident harmonics of the light flicker and the blade rpm (usually there are), that just makes the blade look stationary for a fraction of a second every few seconds. Looks funny, but not stationary.

Bunch of silly internet fretting if you ask me, long on superficial theory, very short on practical application. Anecdote at its worst, and quite probably any accidents "caused" by this are more properly attributable to inattention, the single greatest hazard in any shop.

Re: saw blade strope issue

#5

Re: "Stealth" blades can be a problem

Stuart Johnson

Bill, do you get a cleaner cut using a 7-1/2 inch blade or does it give more power?

Re: saw blade strope issue

#6

Re: "Stealth" blades can be a problem

William Duffield

These blades are used in table saws because they have a much thinner kerf, so if you are building stringing or inlay banding for Federal Period or Chester County furniture, you don't waste nearly as much precious stock, e.g., holly, in the form of sawdust.

They don't, however, work in a SawStop, because you can't get them close enough to the brake shoe to allow the break mechanism to start the saw.

Re: saw blade strope issue

#7

Re: Different problem... though that one is real

Jesse Cloud

Yup, inattention is the root of most evils in the woodshop!

Just this morning I was in the middle of a rather tedious and repetitive process using a router on a jig. About half way through, I realized that I was thinking about supper and not about the router. I turned the router off, went outside for some fresh air and a short walk, then came back and gave the router my undivided attention till the work was finished.

Think I'll make that a habit from now on. :D

Re: saw blade strope issue

#8

Personal Theory

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

is that the "strobe blade" effect was invented by a lazy, inattentive, or chemically impaired operator who, after losing something he was born with, needed to find an excuse.

Of course, I could be wrong ;)

Re: saw blade strope issue

#9

why I use a small blade

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Not my invention. I saw the person that demos a hold down at a show use it and thought, this has some advantages.

To be clear, I am using an industrial quality (price around $30) thin kerf 4oT combo blade (CMT, Freud or others) It cuts about 1 5/8" deep.

1. These small blades are not as prone to throwing things or kick back. There is but a small fraction of the energy stored in one of these spinning blades as a standard 10" blade. Less energy stored equals less energy to fling something at you.

2. Vastly less resistance to cutting which leads to better control and safety

3 less dust, less power

4. cheap

The smoothness of cut is fine for my applications but few of my cuts are not subsequently planes, jointed etc. Hence, I don't fret smoothness as much as some might.

Re: saw blade strope issue

#10

Re: why I use a small blade

TomD

I totally buy your main points. To me the energy is mostly in the weight of the windings and other stuff in the motor, spinning at 3600 rpm, locked into the blade with 3 belts. Whatever the blade weighs is pretty much irrelevant.

Re: saw blade strope issue

#11

do the calculation before you speculate

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You will find that a spinning full sized 10" blade stores enough energy to send a moderate sized piece of wood flying at interstate speeds.

Re: saw blade strope issue

#12

"Perceiving is more than seeing"

MarkHennebury

The light strobe effect I have not encountered, but I have encountered similar and scary situations, my first issue is the bandsaw; I love bandsaws and have used them extensively; if fact it was the first machine that I purchased, back in the seventies when I was transitioning from hand tool only to machinery. I started with a 14" delta; I quickly added with a 6" riser block for resawing. I then upgraded to a Makita resaw which had a rather nasty looking 2" wide, one tooth per inch, resaw blade on it. The one thing that I quickly realized was that the blade only looked scary when the saw was not running. As soon as you turned the machine on and got to concentrating on your work those aggressive looking teeth just became a fine fuzzy line, a minor annoyance that seemed to encourage you to try and brush it out of your way; An urge a have so far managed to resist.

One day whilst visiting my local butchershop, and watching the butcher use their bandsaw for sawing large slabs of cow, I got to discussing bandsaws with him and how dangerous they are, and how not dangerous they can feel when you are using them; He then told me about an incident when a customer who had been stood next to him watching him cut up some meat pointed to the cut of meat that he wanted, that was on the other side of the blade; And in doing so amputated his own hand.

Another incident was in my own shop, when a friend came in for a visit and I was using an automatic horizontal slot mortiser, the horizontal spindle was not oscillating from side to side but was rotating, and he reached over to put his hand on it, not realizing that it was spinning at 9000 rpm, with a cutter mounted in it. Luckily I stopped him before he touched it, but even though he looked at it he did not see that it was spinning. There was a lot of noise in the shop , machines running , compressor running, but he didn't notice that the spindle was running.

Blades on machinery look more scary when they are not running.

Workshops are like coffee shops where people seem to like to come to visit, hang out and chitchat to you while you are working, but in fact are very dangerous places to the casual visitor especially those with dodgy eyesight.


Re: saw blade strope issue

#13

Re: why I use a small blade

Keith Newton

I'm not sure "energy stored" in a 10" blade, over the 7" blade is actually what makes the difference. Well, I guess if the blade thickness was greater on the larger diameter, it could be proportional to the weight difference, but I don't think it would be like using the inertia of a flywheel.

When you drop down in blade diameter, the motor power output and RPMs stays the same, but the rim speed drops. If the motor RPMs is 3450, and both pulley are the same size, the rim speed of a 10" blade is a little over 100 MPH. I normally use an 8" on my unisaw and contractor saws, which would drop the rim speed to 80 MPH, and the 7" you use would drop on down to 70 MPH.

This change is like dropping into a lower gear in your car, delivering torque or foot-pounds to the teeth proportional to that drop in size. So my 8" blade would gain 20% more power to each tooth, if you keep the same number of teeth.

Of course a thin kerf blade will be stiffer when the diameter is smaller, and more prone to deflection as the get larger. This becomes increasingly more appearant as the blade dulls, or in woods like SY Pine that have a hard/ soft annual rings which offers a path of least resistance, other than straight.

Of course you can add larger blade stiffening washers to larger blades to help overcome some this, but then you give up some usable depth of cut, which makes it more economical to just go with a smaller blade.

If you have a kickback at 70 MPH, that seems a lot less than 100MPH.

Re: saw blade strope issue

#14

I bet the controlling factor is tooth velocity...

John in NM

Speed at the tooth is the big difference between a 10" blade and a 7.5", the difference in momentum when considering all the parts would be small.

Re: saw blade strope issue

#15

energy storage

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

the energy stored in a blade (rotating disk dynamics problem) equals 1/2 the rotational velocity of the blade squared times the moment of inertia. The moment of inertia equals the mass of the blade times its radius squared. The 4 times larger mass of the 10" blade and its larger radius squared result in its stored energy being six times more than the smaller blade.

That said, 10 years experience with the smaller blades has shown me that they don't throw stuff like the larger blades and that the greatly reduced cutting resistance provides greater control of the piece being cut.

Re: saw blade strope issue

#16

yes indirectly part of it, see below

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A better way of looking at the situation is to imagine the energy required to stop the blade. (This will in turn be the energy available to accelerate something like a jammed board.) A large heavy blade is intuitively harder to stop than a light weight small one.

Re: saw blade strope issue

#17

Re: energy storage *LINK*

Lars Parrington

We've covered this before, more than once. Here's a post I wrote back in 2013 with calculations of the amount of kinetic energy stored in spinning blades of various diameters as well as the KE stored in a typical 1.5hp motor.

The conclusion is that the total KE of the system is cut in half when switching from a 10" full kerf blade to 7-1/4" thin kerf.


http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives.pl/bid/1001/md/read/id/463961/sbj/safety-physics/

Re: saw blade strope issue

#18

Not sure that i agree with that

Hennebury

I have a couple of theses saws, Robinson cabinetmakers saws; 18" blade at 3600 rpm coupled to with a 7.5hp motor, 193 mph rim Speed

.

And i haven't had any kickback problems and I don't used the splitter as the one in this photo has, although i probably should.

You might want to consider when you are cutting a 2" thick peice of wood with an 18" blade that protrudes 4.5" up from the table, the teeth at the back of the blade are going almost straight up and the front are cutting down, there are no teeth that are pushing the wood forward to cause kickback as in a small blade, where you are engaging teeth at the top of the blade.

In terms of cutting ease, a sharp 18" blade and 7.5 hp motor make light work of most pieces that you may want to use.

Gives a nice clean face, doesn't leave any ripples in the surface, is great for cutting tenons up to 4.5" long.

In terms of energy you have to account for not only the blade but also the motor rotor to which it is coupled.


Re: saw blade strope issue

#19

Re: "Perceiving is more than seeing"

Barry Irby

A friend of mine worked as a "fixer" in a cigarette factory. There was a cutter in the machine that sliced the cigarettes apart. At the time the machine made 9000 cigarettes a minutes. So this cutter stroked 9000 times a minute and yet it spent most of its time sitting still. Most people could not see than it moved at all and it took a lot of training to keep the fixers from sticking a finger into it to see if it was moving. Had all kinds of guards on it. Part of the problem was that some of the guards would stop the entire machine if you got even close. His problem was that there were something like 130 interlocks on the machine that could stop it. When it stopped, alarms went off and management showed up, hounding to get it going again. Might have been nothing more than the janitor bumped a door with his broom. Last I heard, the machines make 14,000 a minute.

Re: saw blade strope issue

#20

Re: Not sure that i agree with that

Bill Howatt

That is my thinking also.

Look at a blade barely buried in the stock. The horizontal component of force back towards the operator is much higher than in the case of a blade where it is well out of the stock.

You can argue about the hazard of more exposed blade or recommendations on the cleanest cut but we are talking about kickback force.

It is incorrect to just look at these items in isolation, you may have less KE with the smaller blade, your tooth design may make the blade less grabby, your splitter arrangement may keep inhibit grabbing, your technique as a lot to do with it too. What happens is determined by all of these things acting together.

Bill

Re: saw blade strope issue

#21

Re: why I use a small blade

Walt

I agree with good quality 7 1/4" blades on table saws in certain situations. The Freuds from Home Depot are stocked in 40 and 60 tooth. I have the 40 and it works pretty well for thin stock and plywood. The 60 tooth might be even better for ply. Ripping 6/4 hardwood? Not so much. The 40 tooth was around $15, or less than a sharpening would cost on a 40 tooth 10" blade.

Re: saw blade strope issue

#22

5/4 a breeze

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

First off, the Home Depot blades are not Industrial quality blades. These cost about $30 not $15. I don't know what the difference is. Could be tooth geometry, quality of carbide, etc. Don't know.

My small blade largely stays on the saw. Ripping 5/4 lumber is no problem at all, Recently processed 100 bdft of 5/4 poplar for stair treads.

Re: saw blade strope issue

#23

ditto

Lars Parrington

I keep an 8" thin kerf cmt blade on my saw. The saw doesn't even bog down when ripping 8/4 hardwood (unless the wood warps as it's cut, but that's a separate issue). My saw is nothing fancy, just an old delta contractor saw with a 1.5hp motor. If anything, the saw subjectively feels more powerful (yet less dangerous) with the smaller blade.

I occasionally swap over to my $$$ 10" ridge carbide blade if I really need the extra depth of cut for something, but switch right back when I'm done because really I do prefer the smaller blade.

Re: saw blade strope issue

#24

Re: ditto

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

mirrors my experience. I have a 1.5 HP saw too.