So here is a 1 quart can of de-waxed shellac- Sealcoat
No.2
Here is "Spray Shellac" The label says no wax or un waxed
No.3
This can of shellac says do not use under Polyurethane but use Sealcoat but doesn't particularly say it contains wax-maybe it does and I just haven't seen the wording on the can.
Are the first two products the same or interchangeable as far as compatibility?
Yes. The spray product is bound to be a lot thinner and probably many times more expensive pound for pound, but as long as it contains only dewaxed shellac, the solids should be identical.
This is a good one for Michael Dresdner, as he played a leading role in developing Seal Coat for Zinsser.
Are the first two products the same or interchangeable as far as compatibility?
Actually, all three are compatible.... because they're all shellac and each would dissolve into the other when applied. The difference is the first two are de-waxed and the third is not. If you are using it as a tie coat between two dissimilar finishes the de-waxed shellac is what you want. As for the spray can shellac, it was around before Seal Coat came to market.
Here's what Michael Dresdner had to say in a thread about Seal Coat exactly 12 years ago -
Date: Friday, 14 February 2003, at 7:25 p.m.
Ok, the thread on SealCoat has gotten way out of hand, with all sorts of speculations and statements, a few of which are true. Let's start from scratch and clear the air. I will explain what SealCoat is, how it is different from other liquid shellac, how it differs from what you can mix yourself from flakes, and some REAL information about shelf life and all its implications. This will be LONG. Sorry, but there is a lot of info.
Liquid shellac contains wax. It has a fairly short shelf life, but the shelf life is tied to the cut. In other words, you might be able to get 3 years from a 3 lb cut, but add enough alcohol to get a 1 1/2 pound cut and the shelf life drops to about 6 months. The thinner the cut, the shorter the shelf life. This is true whether you buy it or mix it yourself from flakes.
SealCoat is made from a different raw material. It is dewaxed (wax free) shellac that has gone through a patented process to give it a much longer shelf life. Therefore, the 2 lb cut SealCoat will last at least as long (and probably much longer) than thicker 3 or 4 lb cut normal shellacs. (For the skeptics among you, the patent is #6,348,217. You can look it up and read it online with an Adobe reader. I've read every word of it and it is valid.) This patented process made it possible to market a shellac cut to the consistency that we finishers actually use, instead of something that had to be reduced. The cut of SealCoat is perfect for brushing, spraying, and wiping just as is.
There are many advantages to wax free shellac (better water spot resistance, harder coating, more clarity, etc.) but there is no relationship between shelf life and wax. The wax neither shortens nor lengthens the shelf life. The reason SealCoat is dewaxed is because I (along with other finishing writers) pestered the hell out of Zinsser to make it that way. I'm grateful to them for listening. Prior to the existence of SealCoat, there was no way to buy pre-mixed liquid dewaxed shellac except in aerosol cans -- and that is not practical for us.
Joe, here is a response about that very question from Michael Dresdner from 2007. I hope this helps....
Sunday, 28 October 2007, at 12:56 p.m.
In Response To: Zinsser Shellac - why an age limit for use?
Shellac degrade:
As soon as shellac comes in contact with alcohol, which is its solvent, it begins a degradation process called esterification in which the shellac resins convert to shellac esters. The more esters are created, the slower the shellac dries and the softer and more prone to water spotting the final film is. This process occurs whether the can has been opened or not. Applying a fast drying finish that shrinks substantially over soft undercoats, including over esterified shellac, will cause cracking. In fact, old shellac is sometimes used this way in the motion picture and theater applications to mimic old finishes and paints. This may be what happened to Mark.
How long is it good?:
There is no absolute number, but several factors affect shellac aging. First is the cut. The thicker the shellac is, the slower esterification takes place. Therefore, a five pound cut of shellac will have a much longer shelf life than a two pound cut. How much longer? Depending on other conditions, about eight or nine times longer. In other words, adding alcohol to a can of shellac shortens its shelf life. Now, about those other conditions; heat, sunlight and moisture are enemies of shellac, even in flake form. Store in a cool, dry place away from sunlight. When shellac resin arrives at the Zinsser factory it is stored on shelves in a huge room that is actually a gigantic refrigerator. The bad news is that when you buy a can of shellac from the store, you may know how old it is by the date on the can, but you have no way of knowing whether it was properly stored during its travels, its stay at the warehouse, or its life on the shelf. Hence, shelf life remains a moving target and is not an absolute science, at least as far as we consumers are concerned.
What is SealCoat and how is it different?:
About six years ago a patent was awarded for a long shelf life shellac resin that substantially retards the esterification process. SealCoat is made from that resin, meaning it has a much longer shelf life than other shellac AT THAT POUND CUT. That's important, since the cut still matters. One big difference is that SealCoat is sold in a much thinner, lower pound cut formula, which is possible only because of the extended shelf life resin. Of course, storage conditions still matter also, as it will degrade, only more slowly.
Is five year old SealCoat still good?:
For most applications, if it was stored perfectly, probably yes. I tested some of the original lab samples five years out and they were fine, but to be fair, my storage conditions are ideal all year around. With different storage conditions, the answer may be different.
How can I tell if mine is still good?:
The easiest way is to do a baseline test. Take a known fresh sample of shellac that is cut the same as your questionable sample. Put a drop onto a piece of glass. Check it frequently tracking how much time it takes before it hardens completely, and ascertaining just how hard it gets by pressing a thumbnail into the cured drop. Do the same test with your material and compare both drying times and final hardness.
Incidentally, while it is wise to use only shellac that dries quickly and hard when employing it under other finishes as a sealer, you can use even softened shellac as a final finish. The coating will not be as durable, but it is certainly acceptable. I've seen companies sell lathe finishes that are shellac intentionally softened with the addition of large portions of wax, and these are considered quite appropriate for light use turnings, such as art pieces. As long as it dries in a reasonable amount of time, you can use it; just don't expect the same wear properties as from fresh shellac.
First, a big thanks for providing the trail to the patent. I have been meaning to look it up for ages and never got around to it.
(http://www.google.com/patents/US6348217). The patent explains the process Zinser uses to prepare stable shellac. Reading between the lines the patent describes a process for removing a highly reactive acid component from the shellac. This acid seems to be responsible for making the stored shellac insoluble after some time and also for the reactions with solvent that slows drying times.
From the patent information I conclude:
Typical shellac becomes insoluble after storage through polymerization (assuredly cross linking). Neither Oxygen or water appears to be involved. Temperature accelerates this process. Hence, those that store the shellac in the frig are on the right track. The process Zinser uses removes the reactive component to render it vastly more stable. This component appears to be an organic acid.
Typical shellac reacts with ethanol, likely catalyzed by the organic acid mentioned above, to make an ester that slows hardening (drying) time of the shellac film. The stuff that Zinser removes slows this process substantially.
Shellac films get softer over time. Again, the Zinser material gets softer slower.
While not specifically stated, the Zinser product appears to be 35% solids in 95% ethanol/water with a small amount of methanol and a ketone with a high boiling point. Someone needs to convert that to pound cut but it must be a big number. A bargain at $45/gallon.
According to my discussions with Zinnser, both the Sealcoat and the aerosol spray can are totally dewaxed. Dewaxing is required of the aerosol in order for it to be sprayed properly by the relatively low pressure in an aerosol.
Other shellacs marketed by Zinnser contain their natural wax and should not be used under polyurethane or waterborne finishes.