Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Costco Shop-lite Revisited

Posts

Costco Shop-lite Revisited

#1

Costco Shop-lite Revisited

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

So walking into Costco Memsahib points out the display and says "Why not get one and replace the old dim light over that wall bench so you're not having to keep taking tubes to the toxic waste day?" (had T8's on the borg shopping list)

Ok, $30, so one goes home. Takes about 15 minutes to switch out the fixture.

Huge difference in light output!

Will have to do some modification however. Traditional shop-lites have bigger/wider shades and thus project light more down to the area below. The new light's very narrow reflector allows the light to spread outward. In my low-ceilinged basement shop, the side-glare will be very annoying.

Won't take much to make an add-on shade so this may just work out after all.

Re: Costco Shop-lite Revisited

#2

Don't be fooled by looking at the lamp

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In judging how much light a lamp puts out don't be fooled by looking at the lamp itself.

LED's and fluorescents work the same. Some primary light generation interacts with a phosphor on the lamp enclosure(glass) to generate visible light of some wavelength (lamp temperature) and spectral distribution ("quality" of light, CRI).

To take a case more easy to illustrate......we have two lamps a 1.5" T12 and a 1" T8 and both put out the same amount of light. The surface area of the phosphor equals the surface area of the lamp tube, which is proportional to the lamp diameter (C = piD). For the same amount of primary illumination the surface of the T12 will appear 1/1.5 times less bright because this illumination is spread over 1.5 times the area. Both lamps will illuminate the bench identically.

LED's look wicked bright because the phosphor is coated on a tiny area. How much light you get on the bench can only be assessed with a light meter or from data provided on the lamp (Lumens).

Re: Costco Shop-lite Revisited

#3

E-Lumenated

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Knew that going in, Bill. See my note below of "I'll Pass" because of the difference in actual output.

The fixture is, however, a big improvement without having to change out old bulbs and a ballast. I may even use the old fixture shade on the side glare issue.

Re: Costco Shop-lite Revisited

#4

If you need LIGHT!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Take a look at the high output T5 fixture at Home Depot. Dazzling. I have 2 over the bench and it looks like a sunny day.

Re: Costco Shop-lite Revisited

#5

Re: If you need LIGHT!

Alex Grigoriev

These to me sometimes seem too bright. I have them on the left and right of the workbench. Also, they may not work with one bulb: need both bulbs to operate, so you cannot temporarily extract one. Anyway, I'm installing two more on the other side of my garage shop.

Re: Costco Shop-lite Revisited

#6

About those T8s...

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

I bought a two tube T8 fixture from Menards last summer for my summer home garage bench. I have all T12 fixtures in my home shop. The T12 lamps come on full bright right away unless the temperature is pretty low. However, the T8 fixture always takes a while to fully illuminate. You can see the difference in brightness as a rolling movement like you get with a bad tube. This is at any temperature. After a while, they are nice and bright, but I find the repeated warm-up time annoying. Is this common or do I have an inferior fixture? Both tubes do the same thing.

Re: Costco Shop-lite Revisited

#7

never seen it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

May be ballast related.

Re: Costco Shop-lite Revisited

#8

I have several

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

shop lights that very current sensitive and will only get to about 50% if we have a drop in the Main's voltage of more than 6 volts. We can always tell if the power co. has feeder issues on our circuit.

Re: Costco Shop-lite Revisited

#9

Re: About those T8s...

Tony - Memphis

I don't have much experience her, but, the ballasts that I have been buying to replace the old ones I had (old type T12) are much much better. They come on instantly. No flicker, hesitation, etc. I couldn't swear they are 100% bright instantly, but if they aren't, I haven't noticed. I'm sure, like anything, there is a a difference in quality among these fixtures. Lowes carries Phillips I believe? I've been real happy with them. I did one as a test and that convinced me to do them all. To qualify, my bulbs were over ten years old, so that might explain some of the difference.

Tony - who can see clearly now!

Re: Costco Shop-lite Revisited

#10

Indeed they are brighter

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The new electronic ballasts are more efficient converting electrons to photons and lamp output dies slowly with use. So new lamps and new ballast yields more light.

Re: Costco Shop-lite Revisited

#11

So

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

DIY/ARG! aside, time over cost-results, isn't it just cheaper just to go buy a new fixture with bulbs for $25?

Re: Costco Shop-lite Revisited

#12

Re: I have several

Alex Grigoriev

This would only be true for old school non-electronic ballasts.

Re: Costco Shop-lite Revisited

#13

Re: Indeed they are brighter

Alex Grigoriev

Electronic ballasts can give the lamp duty cycle close to 100 %. Inductive/capacitive ballasts, per design, will not.

Re: Costco Shop-lite Revisited

#14

Re: About those T8s...

Barry Mabery

..."or do I have an inferior fixture?"

Quite possibly. Or lamps. Or both.