Grizzly 12 Pc. Carving Chisel Set
Jack Prescott
Grizzly sells the SKU H2930 12 piece Carving Chisel Set for $69.95. Does anyone have experience with this product and would you recommend it??
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Grizzly 12 Pc. Carving Chisel Set
Jack Prescott
Grizzly sells the SKU H2930 12 piece Carving Chisel Set for $69.95. Does anyone have experience with this product and would you recommend it??
Re: Grizzly 12 Pc. Carving Chisel Set
TomD
I don't have experience with that set. I am not a carver. I have carving chisels that I got a box of from someone else. It never has the right chisels for the projects I want to do.
I am not really a huge believer in sets of carving chisels there are always a few that are useless. If I bought a set, I might buy one put together by a master carver who had a book out, where I would be guaranteed that they were all correct for the style I was attempting to learn. I don't know if I would find such a set, though the British have various carving magazines, and seem more into that kind of thing, so it might be out there.
It might help the expert carvers here to know what you anticipate using the chisels for. In the absence of taking up some classical form, I tend to use chisels for fairly general things, like hollowing a handle on a canoe paddle, general shaping, and occasionally to cut flat stock out. These are real uses, but they do not require the kinds of tools carvers need for specific tasks such as their veiners, or maybe chisels that are designed for getting relief. Formal carving (really like the rest of woodworking), seems to be the kind of thing where you need a specific tool for everything. On a dessert island you might get by with a 5mm drill to set a 6mm dowel, but in a shop, that would be ridiculous. If you specialize in a few details, like shells, claw feet, or scripts, there will be certain tools you must have to efficiently do each (and the more of these things you do, the more tools you need, but many may eventually overlap). But the point is that, there aren't a magic few. Or maybe there are 4 or 6 you have to have but not 12. The sets try to be the best complete set, while what you really need are a few basic tools, and then to add the rest relative to the style you want to carve, specifically, or the teacher you have or the project. There is a difference between having the first 12 tools you will need to get started in the stuff you want to do, and a set of 12 that is cherry picked from the widest range of styles and may never have the specific tools you need for any one task.
As a user of Japanese chisels as well as many other types, I was impressed with the prices on the Grizz Japanese gouges. I have bought Japanese chisels from about 10 dollars to 350 a chisel, and they are always really good. So far I haven't bought in because, again, if I want to carve a shell, I will look at the Hedley (?) video, and get the exact tools he uses. Of if a claw foot, that video.
Re: Grizzly 12 Pc. Carving Chisel Set
TomD
One thought is whether you want the kind of handles that roll off benches or not. If you found you didn't like these handles do you have the stones to grind flats on them, or would it bother you to mess them up. Just a thought.
Re: Grizzly 12 Pc. Carving Chisel Set
Dick Coers
2 of those are just straight chisels, basically bench chisels, and another is a straight chisel with an angle grind. So you are basically getting 9 carving tools. I've not seen that set, but other cheap carving chisels I've seen have a horrible grind on them. Really over polished and rounded over edges. Plan on taking off about 1/16" of steel to get back to make a true grind. It's a "you get what you pay for" deal for sure.